On Friday, President Donald Trump intervened in the cases of three U.S. service members accused of war crimes, granting pardons to two Army soldiers accused of murder in Afghanistan and restoring the rank of a Navy SEAL found guilty of wrongdoing in Iraq.
While the statements coming out of the Pentagon regarding Trump's actions have been understandably measured, comments from former military leaders and other knowledgable veterans help paint a picture as to why the president's Friday actions are so controversial.
The Army, Navy, and Pentagon all took similar approaches in their official responses to the commander-in-chief's orders: The President of the United States has the power to do this under the Constitution, and we will follow his orders.
The Army's statement which was not attributed to any senior official stated simply that the service would implement pardons of Maj. Matthew Golsteyn and 1st Lt. Clint Lorance.
"The Army has full confidence in our system of justice. The Uniform Code of Military Justice ensures good order and discipline for uniformed service members while holding accountable those who violate its provisions," the statement reads. "The foundation of military law is the Constitution, and the Constitution establishes the President's power to grand pardons."
Navy Rear Adm. Charlie Brown, the Navy's Chief of Information, tweeted that as Commander in Chief, "the President has the authority to restore Special Warfare Operator First Class [Eddie] Gallagher to the pay grade of E-7. We acknowledge his order and are implementing it."
Jonathan Hoffman, chief pentagon spokesperson, told CNN's Ryan Browne that the Department of Defense "has confidence in the military justice system. The President is part of the military justice system as the Commander-in-Chief & has the authority to weigh in on matters of this nature."
But a U.S. defense official also told CNN that there's concern among the department's leadership that Trump's pardons could undermine the military's justice system. CNN and the New York Times also reported that senior Pentagon leadership, including Defense Secretary Mark Esper, urged Trump not to intervene in the three cases.
Several former military leaders echoed the same concerns.
"As President Trump intervenes in war crimes cases on behalf of individuals accused or convicted of war crimes, he ... undermines decades of precedent in American military justice that has contributed to making our country's fighting forces the envy of the world," Gen. Charles Krulak, former commandant of the Marine Corps, said in a statement.
"Disregard for the law undermines our national security by reducing combat effectiveness, increasing the risks to our troops, hindering cooperation with allies, alienating populations whose support the United States needs in the struggle against terrorism, and providing a propaganda tool for extremists who wish to do us harm," he added.
Retired Navy Adm. James Stavridis offered a similar sentiment on Twitter:
While retired Gen. Martin Dempsey, former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, was previously critical of the prospect of Trump's war crimes pardons back in May, he said in a Friday statement that he doesn't know if Trump's intervention truly sends a negative message to current U.S. troops.
"The President has the authority to pardon and provide clemency, but as far as I can tell he hasn't shared his rationale for this particular action," Dempsey said in a statement. "Our military leaders continue to train their men and women on the importance of legal and ethical conduct both in peace and in war. I'm confident those same leaders will hold soldiers, sailors, airmen, and marines accountable. What happens after that is out of their control."
When reached for additional comment by Task & Purpose, Dempsey added that the message Trump's pardons send to allies, partners and adversaries "is another question."
"Again, the President hasn't made it clear why he acted as he did. It can't be that combat is simply too hard for the common man," he added. "Our servicemen and women have demonstrated with very few exceptions that they can act with uncommon honor and valor."
While Dempsey was measured in his assessment, former military lawyers took a more dire view of the precedent set by the commander-in-chief's sudden pardons.
"It's just institutionally harmful," Rachel VanLandingham, a former Air Force JAG and professor of law at Southwestern Law School, told the New York Times. "This isn't about these three individuals, it's about the whole military justice system and whether that system itself is something of value to the operations of the military."
"Trump's pardons put our soldiers in harm's way," Glenn Kirschner, a former Army JAG and NBC/MSNBC legal analyst, wrote on Twitter. "Other countries will assume our soldiers are permitted by the president to commit war crimes w/impunity. It also disregards the victims & insults all law-abiding US troops.
"Mr. Trump's intervention on behalf of those convicted or accused of conduct falling short of the military's crucial legal requirements and moral expectations undermines the training in which the military rightly invests so much effort," Benjamin Haas, combat veteran and former Army intelligence officer, wrote in the New York Times. "It trivializes the values the military spends so much time fostering."
"I can honestly say I have not talked to a single military officer who would be in favor of pardoning any one of these three," Gary Solis, a combat veteran and former military attorney who now teaches the laws of war at the Georgetown University Law Center and the George Washington University Law School, told Military.com. "[Trump[ had a war crime and [Lorance] was convicted, his appeal was rejected and he was serving his time. And the president stepped in and set him free, in essence ratifying his actions."
"Now, those enlisted kids, those Marines, soldiers, SEALs who see a war crime committed are going to think twice about reporting it," Solis added. "You are always going to have somebody who says, 'You dimed on us and put a good friend of mine in the brig,' or something like that ... it's made it much more difficult for those who witness war crimes to report those war crimes."
Despite the appearance of overwhelming disapproval of Trump's Friday interventions, not everyone is upset with the move including Fox & Friends co-host and former reserve military officer Pete Hegseth, who forcefully advocated for Trump to intervene in the Gallagher case. Indeed, Hegseth told Fox News that Lorance's claim that he'd been thrown under the bus by senior Pentagon leaders for political reasons was a "widespread belief" within the enlisted ranks.
"I know this is a feeling that after the Obama administration decided to promote certain people in certain ways, there became no incentive for commanders to ruffle feathers," Hegseth said. "They were incentivized to play the game, the social justice and p.c. games. So you were not getting the military leaders who are willing to take risks for the guys who are doing the heavy lifting."
"President Trump has emboldened the people out there making the impossible calls at impossible moments," he added. "If you look at each of these cases, there's plenty of reasons to question the veracity of these prosecutors. These are not cases where people went into villages with the intention of killing innocent people. These are split-second decisions."
Rep. Duncan Hunter, the Marine Corps veteran and California congressman who also advocated for Gallagher's release, shared this sentiment in his own statement on Friday.
"For years, rampant prosecutorial misconduct, political correctness, and procedures that weight the scales of justice against the accused have personified our military justice system," he said. "Self-serving military bureaucrats have felt empowered in instituting policies that have been damning to our warriors on the front lines."
"Today, thanks to the leadership of President Trump, these Pentagon armchair lawyers are being put on notice,' he added. "The President recognizes that our combat warriors are to be supported in meeting the incredible responsibilities we place on them and I very much appreciate his advocacy for America's warfighters."
Retired Army Lt. Col. Allen West, the former Florida congressman who was himself relieved of command over the improper treatment of a detainee in Iraq, echoed Hegseth and Hunter's statements.
"The travesty of injustice for these men is over ... These men aren't guilty of war crimes, they simply did what combat leaders are supposed to do, engage and kill the enemy," said West. "If our Army could set Bowe Bergdahl and Bradley Manning free, who were guilty of desertion and treason, then no one should raise a contrarian voice in the matter of these pardons. Now, the military JAG officers responsible for withholding exculpatory evidence should be disciplined.
"Islamic jihadists terrorists are non-state, non-uniform belligerents on the battlefield. They seek to blend in with civilian populations and take cover in the midst of non-combatants," West added in a follow-up statement. "These are not 'enemy soldiers.' They are unlawful enemy combatants, and should not be accorded any Geneva Convention rights, certainly not constitutional rights"
According to a poll from the Clarion Project, a Washington, D.C.-based non-profit devoted to "exposing the dangers of Islamic extremism while providing a platform for the voices of moderation and promoting grassroots activism," some 77 percent of respondents believed U.S. service members should not be prosecuted for war crimes committed overseas.
Continued here:
'What happens after that is out of their control' Former military leaders and lawyers react to Trump's war crimes pardons - Task & Purpose
- The Bradley Manning Trial: A Short(ish) Guide To Understanding ... - NPR - May 3rd, 2023
- Bradley Manning: the angry young man who turned whistleblower - March 31st, 2023
- Bradley Manning timeline | Chelsea Manning | The Guardian - March 31st, 2023
- Bradley Manning Sentenced to 35 Years for WikiLeaks - January 6th, 2023
- A Plan to Let Soldiers Interact with the Army Cloud Using Their Own Devices Got a Bit Clouded - Forbes - September 13th, 2022
- Jarren Duran moved to right field with Jackie Bradley Jr. in center as Boston Red Sox look to avoid sweep Thu - MassLive.com - July 18th, 2022
- Explained: Julian Assange extradition order and charges against the Wikileaks founder - The Indian Express - April 28th, 2022
- Culture of impunity - The News International - November 19th, 2021
- Punishing the conscientious - The News International - July 30th, 2021
- Assange has until 29 March to respond to US appeal over extradition - iTWire - February 21st, 2021
- Chelsea Manning's mother, 65, drowned in bath while heavily intoxicated with alcohol, inquest hears - MEAWW - December 24th, 2020
- University of Iowa Health Care reduces hospitalizations through 'virtual hospital' model - kwwl.com - November 26th, 2020
- Forgotten lessons on the evil of intervention - newagebd.net - November 26th, 2020
- The Korean War's Forgotten Lessons on the Evil of Intervention - Consortium News - November 20th, 2020
- Pentagon counterspy report shows threats growing - Washington Times - November 19th, 2020
- The Korean War's Forgotten Lessons on the Evil of Intervention - CounterPunch - November 18th, 2020
- Obama Commutes Bradley (Chelsea) Manning & Oscar Lopez ... - August 1st, 2020
- Pte Bradley Manning The Celtic League - July 27th, 2020
- WikiLeaks published 75,000 classified US military documents on the Afghanistan War 10 years ago - American Military News - July 25th, 2020
- Accused Whistleblower Bradley Manning Begins Court ... - July 24th, 2020
- Manning calls for dismissal of charges against him - The Hindu - July 24th, 2020
- NEW: Judge Orders Chelsea (Bradley) Manning to be Released ... - July 21st, 2020
- The Judicial Lynching of Bradley Manning - Global ... - July 21st, 2020
- Bradley Manning lawyer says case 'mishandled' as hearings ... - July 21st, 2020
- Interview - Brian Manning | WikiSecrets | FRONTLINE | PBS - July 21st, 2020
- University of Iowa doctors monitor and help COVID-19 patients remotely - UI The Daily Iowan - June 30th, 2020
- The Korean War Atrocities No One Wants to Talk About - The American Conservative - June 30th, 2020
- Julian Assange fathered two children while hiding in Ecuadoran Embassy, alleged partner claims in video - Seattle Times - April 13th, 2020
- University of Iowa Health Care debuts 'virtual hospital' for COVID-19 patients - The Gazette - April 10th, 2020
- On 10th Anniversary of 'Collateral Murder' Release: The US Soldier Who Sought to Save Iraqi Children - Consortium News - April 10th, 2020
- Headlong and Century Films Partner With BBC Arts On UNPRECEDENTED: REAL TIME THEATRE FROM A STATE OF ISOLATION - Broadway World - April 10th, 2020
- Remember That Time John Terry Won an Oscar? The Inevitable Ellen Selfie Meme Onslaught Begins - Infosurhoy - March 31st, 2020
- During time of crisis, Rafi's reaches out to the community - Olean Times Herald - March 19th, 2020
- Assange tried to call White House, Hillary Clinton over data dump, his lawyer says - WTVB News - March 3rd, 2020
- Factbox: News and Quotes From Julian Assange's Extradition Hearing - The New York Times - March 2nd, 2020
- Julian Assange, The Glass Cage And Heaven In A Rage: Day Four Of Extradition Hearings OpEd - Eurasia Review - February 27th, 2020
- UK court told Assange tried to call White House, Hillary Clinton over data dump - Reuters - February 25th, 2020
- What is happening to Assange will happen to the rest of us - Salon - February 16th, 2020
- West: Bergdahl, Manning, Vindmanthe Progressive Left's Heroes - MRCTV - February 16th, 2020
- Bergdahl, Manning, Vindman: Heroes of the Progressive Socialist Left - CNSNews.com - February 14th, 2020
- Bradley Manning Sentenced to 35 Years for Leaking Secrets ... - January 29th, 2020
- Is Bradley Manning a Traitor or a Whistleblower? I want ... - January 10th, 2020
- The US media is in the gutter with Trump - The Japan Times - December 18th, 2019
- Obama Granted Clemency to Terrorists and Traitors, But Were Supposed to Be Angry at Trump's Pardons | News and Politics - PJ Media - November 23rd, 2019
- World News, Economics and Analysis Based on Bible Prophecy - theTrumpet.com - November 19th, 2019
- Lt. Col. Allen West Commends President Trump for His Clemency and Restoration of Rank to Three Service Members - Released by West4Texas - PRNewswire - November 16th, 2019
- Week in Review: Baghdadis fall, UK fishermen struggle with Brexit and a look inside Miss Maggies kitchen - FRANCE 24 - October 31st, 2019
- Bradley Manning Trial Begins; Prosecutor Says Leaker Gave ... - October 20th, 2019
- Thanking Bradley Manning - truthout.org - October 14th, 2019
- List of charges in United States v. Manning - Wikipedia - October 14th, 2019
- Bradley Manning Sentenced To 35 Years In Prison - Hosbeg.com - October 1st, 2019
- Bradley Manning is still a traitor. And he's also still a man. - August 30th, 2019
- LAWYER: Bradley Manning's Treatment Is A Stain On US History ... - May 18th, 2019
- 'US Withheld Hundreds Of Emails In The Bradley Manning ... - May 17th, 2019
- JUST IN: Chelsea (Bradley) Manning Ordered Back to Jail ... - May 17th, 2019
- Bradley Manning: a sentence both unjust and unfair ... - May 17th, 2019
- Chelsea Manning released from prison after 7 years of 35-year ... - May 11th, 2019
- BRADLEY MANNING: I'm Sorry - Business Insider - May 7th, 2019
- Bradley Manning Admits Providing Files to WikiLeaks - The ... - May 6th, 2019
- Bradley Manning: Is There Anyone More Normal? - reason.com - April 26th, 2019
- Bradley Manning Awaits Armys Decision on Whether to Court ... - April 26th, 2019
- Do you think Bradley Manning being stripped naked is a ... - April 26th, 2019
- Bradley Manning court-martial starts: key points in the ... - April 24th, 2019
- Intent To Harm At Center Of Bradley Manning's Trial : NPR - April 24th, 2019
- Manning Is Acquitted of Aiding the Enemy - April 14th, 2019
- Leaker Chelsea Manning stuck in jail after Assange arrest - April 12th, 2019
- Chelsea Manning Changed the Course of History. Now Shes Focusing on ... - April 12th, 2019
- Fox News reporter calls Chelsea Manning by her deadname during Julian ... - April 12th, 2019
- UPDATE 4-U.S. charges WikiLeaks' Assange with hacking conspiracy with ... - April 12th, 2019
- Assange conspired with Chelsea Manning in 2010 WikiLeaks ... - April 11th, 2019
- Assange accused of conspiring with Chelsea Manning in 2010 ... - April 11th, 2019
- Bradley Manning justice: Our view - usatoday.com - April 11th, 2019
- Chelsea Manning jailed for refusing to testify to jury on ... - April 11th, 2019
- Trial Portrays Two Sides Private in WikiLeaks Case - April 11th, 2019
- Bradley Mannings Defense is the Defense of Freedom and Dignity - April 6th, 2019
- Bradley Manning: US soldier cleared of aiding the enemy in WikiLeaks case - April 6th, 2019
- Does Bradley Manning Have Rights? - Business Insider - April 6th, 2019
- Did WikiLeaker Bradley Manning Leak Documents Because Of Don ... - April 6th, 2019
- Bradley Manning Obituary - Pittsfield, MA | The Berkshire ... - March 28th, 2019
- Bradley Manning Guilty on Most Charges, But Not Aiding Enemy ... - March 26th, 2019