The conservative 5th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals last week upheld a Texas law that prohibits large social media companies from deplatforming their users based on the content of what those users post. This ruling makes a good deal of sense if you want federal appeals court judges to act like outcome-driven partisan hacks. If, on the other hand, you believe in the rule of law, our democracy and limiting disinformation, the ruling is outrageous.
This ruling makes sense if you want federal appeals court judges to act like outcome-driven partisan hacks.
The First Amendment protects us from the government, and only the government, from limiting our speech rights. The First Amendment does not bar private speakers (such as social media companies) from telling other speakers (such as their users) to be quiet or to get off their virtual lawns.
A new Texas law, crafted by Republican lawmakers and signed by the state's Republican governor, bars social media companies from regulating content on their platforms based on viewpoint. While on its face the law would apply equally to those with either liberal or conservative perspectives, Texas Gov. Greg Abbott was explicit that this law was aimed at protecting conservative ideas and values. If you think that sounds so vague that you dont know exactly what social media companies can and cannot do, then youre on the right track. In fact, the trial court judge who reviewed this law and correctly struck it down concluded that it was unconstitutionally vague.
Vagueness can be deadly to a law because if people dont know what they can or cannot do, they might fail to speak (or fail to kick someone off their platform). A social media company wishing to enforce its user agreement and deplatform someone trafficking in lies and conspiracy theories might opt not to act for fear that the user also espoused conservative political views.
Some conservatives are apparently concerned that allowing social media companies to exercise their First Amendment rights and manage the content on their own platforms is abusive. They point to Twitters deplatforming of then-President Donald Trump in the wake of his apparent attempt to use Twitter to stage a self-coup. Twitter famously kicked Trump off of its platform based on a rational belief that his posts put public safety at risk and could incite violence. If this is the type of content moderation they fear, Ill politely suggest they should perhaps be more worried about allowing lies, disinformation and conspiracy theories to propagate without limits.
Far from promoting First Amendment rights, the 5th Circuits ruling seems to end them for large social media companies. It is utterly incomprehensible for any jurist to conclude that the First Amendment prohibits a private company from engaging in content moderation. Lets use an example to drive the point home: Imagine the State of Hypothetical wanted newspapers operating in the state to run more guest essays by business leaders and that its lawmakers passed a law to that extent. If the newspapers, again private actors, lack First Amendment rights, then in theory, such a law would be permissible.
If social media platforms can be made to allow for the expression of viewpoints they find reprehensible, then that means they lack full First Amendment rights.
The marketplace of ideas is one of the primary rationales supporting the freedom of expression protected in the First Amendment. The basic idea is that the truth will emerge when ideas can freely compete in a metaphorical marketplace. This depends on freedom from government censorship. It also depends on a private persons or groups ability to freely say, Youre wrong, and heres why. Sit down and shut up. Texas is preventing social media companies from doing that, therefore undermining that market.
The marketplace of ideas only flourishes if the government doesnt intrude to protect the speech it likes and silence the speech it doesnt. Yet, that is exactly what Texas law does. Texas has stomped on the freedom of one market participant, social media companies, to say and do what it wishes. And Texas has been explicit about its motives. This is a quintessential example of the government implementing a law to protect the speech it likes.
This is a quintessential example of the government implementing a law to protect the speech it likes.
If Texas law is allowed to stand, it will not only take a sledgehammer to our First Amendment protections, but also usher in an era in which social media is even more of a breeding ground for conspiracy theories. Do you believe that Covid-19 is a hoax, that President Joe Biden stole the 2020 election, that a research facility in Alaska is actually a place for experimental weapons that can control your mind, or that you just saw Bigfoot at the market? Well, step right up to the circus that is now America. Share your false views without any fear that someone will point out their falsity.
Legally speaking, it shouldnt matter if the justices on the Supreme Court lean conservative or liberal when it comes to a challenge to Texas law. It should only matter if they lean in favor of faithfully upholding the Constitution. Any judge who honestly looks at the First Amendment and what it protects will trash Texas law.
Simply put, if your viewpoint is that a free and fair election was stolen, a private social media company should, legally and practically, be allowed to kick you off of its platform. Far from harming the freedom of speech, we protect speech by allowing private companies to decide who can and cannot use their platforms. To do otherwise would be compelling the companies to speak, and compelled speech can never be free.
JessicaLevinson, a professor at Loyola Law School, is the host of the "Passing Judgment" podcast. She is also the director of the Public Service Institute at Loyola Law School, director of Loyola's Journalist Law School and former president of the Los Angeles Ethics Commission.
View original post here:
Judges ruling against Twitter to protect the First Amendment did the opposite - MSNBC
- Judge blocks Texas bill aimed at preventing social media companies from deplatforming people based on their ... - AOL - February 25th, 2024
- Introducing FIRE's Campus Deplatforming Database | The Foundation for Individual Rights and Expression - Foundation for Individual Rights in Education - February 9th, 2024
- Alex Jones To Tucker Carlson: My Sin Was Decompartmentalizing The American Population - RealClearPolitics - December 11th, 2023
- Does 'deplatforming' work to curb hate speech and calls for ... - October 16th, 2023
- Weighing the Value and Risks of Deplatforming GNET - October 16th, 2023
- TIMELINE: Trump reinstated from 'permanent' social media bans, but will that last? - WCYB - March 31st, 2023
- Twitter Found Trump Didn't Violate Policy, But Banned Him Anyway - December 28th, 2022
- Social media misogyny: The new way Andrew Tate brought us the same old hate - December 28th, 2022
- Google Pays Sharath Bulusu: Well-meaning regulation will help market mature - The Indian Express - December 28th, 2022
- WordPress discussed deplatforming The New York Post after Hunter Biden ... - December 20th, 2022
- App Store 'Gatekeepers' Urged To Deplatform "Dangerous" Twitter Itself - December 12th, 2022
- FACT CHECK: Did Elon Musk Call Twitter Users Upset By Trumps ... - December 12th, 2022
- 'Deplatforming the President': Twitter Files Part 3 reveals events that led to removal of Donald Trump - Business Today - December 12th, 2022
- Twitter Files Part 2: Top Twitter execs interfered with US election before banning Donald Trump - msnNOW - December 12th, 2022
- Conservatives Are Mad Kanye Is Being Censored for Antisemitism ... - November 25th, 2022
- Chronicles Magazine : A Magazine of American Culture - November 17th, 2022
- Amazon accused of absurd and unacceptable censorship after book ... - November 17th, 2022
- PayPal's ideological deplatforming spurs proposed UK amendment to stop ... - November 17th, 2022
- Andrew Tates popularity decreases following deplatforming from social ... - November 7th, 2022
- This is for people who think deplatforming doesn't work - November 7th, 2022
- 4 Great Email Templates For Leaving Your Job - Jobbio Journal - October 31st, 2022
- What is Social Media? - TechTarget - October 31st, 2022
- The dangers of deplatforming - October 31st, 2022
- A Middlebury College Expert Explains the Ways Social Media Fuels Hate and How to Stop It - Seven Days - October 23rd, 2022
- Alex Jones ordered to pay $965 million after misinformation campaign targeting Sandy Hook families - Yahoo Finance - October 15th, 2022
- Kanye West Bank Ban Is An Indefensible Slippery Slope - OutKick - October 15th, 2022
- My New Paper: Donald Trump Should Remain Deplatformed from Facebook, Twitter, and YouTube Despite the High Bar That Platforms Should Apply to the... - October 15th, 2022
- As Washington Post targets Catholic hospitals, every religious institution needs to build defenses - Washington Examiner - October 15th, 2022
- TMCs Derek OBrien steps in to give legitimacy to The Wires Meta joke that turned out to be a hoax - OpIndia - October 15th, 2022
- LeBron James' The Shop Will Not Air Episode Featuring Kanye West After Controversial Remarks By The Rapper - Yardbarker - October 15th, 2022
- Verizon Blacklists One America News Network Following ... - Breitbart - October 7th, 2022
- Conference aims to make trust and safety hot topics in computer science - The Stanford Daily - October 7th, 2022
- Sneako: Andrew Tate 2.0 Has Been Kicked Off YouTube | 2022 - The Latch - October 7th, 2022
- An Early Conservative Victory in the War on Big Tech | Opinion - Newsweek - October 7th, 2022
- Students respond to upcoming Congress to Campus event - Macalester College The Mac Weekly - October 7th, 2022
- Supreme Court Is Putting the Future of Section 230 Protections on Its Docket - Gizmodo - October 7th, 2022
- How to fundraise when the powerful want to stop you - Open Democracy - October 7th, 2022
- Piers Morgan Has Just Grilled Andrew Tate in a Live TV Interview - We Got This Covered - October 7th, 2022
- Kiwi Farms Is Down After Cloudflare Boots the Site as a Customer - September 29th, 2022
- How two Republicans in Florida are dominating the news - POLITICO - September 29th, 2022
- "White Psychodrama" and the culture wars: A self-reinforcing cycle, going nowhere - Salon - September 29th, 2022
- Regulating Misinformation on Twitter is a Problem, But There Are Bigger Ones on the Horizon - Tech Policy Press - September 29th, 2022
- It's Time to Stop Platforming the Big Lie Playbook - Tech Policy Press - September 29th, 2022
- Alex Jones' defamation trials show deplatforming's limits : NPR - September 21st, 2022
- Libs of TikTok vs. The Washington Post - Idaho State Journal - September 13th, 2022
- Journalist Glenn Greenwald scorches unholy alliance of government Democrats, corporate media and Big Tech - Fox News - September 13th, 2022
- Deplatforming Andrew Tate is the best way to deal with him - Los Angeles Loyolan - September 5th, 2022
- Andrew Tate joins Rumble after Big Tech deplatforming, will post ... - August 28th, 2022
- Pro-Masculine Influencer Andrew Tate Joins Rumble After Big Tech ... - August 28th, 2022
- NBC Journalist Who Attacked Libs Of TikTok Once Took Credit For ... - August 28th, 2022
- Web3 Will Make Or Break Social Media - Forbes - August 28th, 2022
- 2022 Tech Trends | The Future Today Institute - August 20th, 2022
- Commentary: Twitter fast becoming a thought-policed sandbox - The Herald Journal - August 20th, 2022
- What the Trial of Alex Jones Revealed About His Finances - The New York Times - August 12th, 2022
- Big Tech's Ban on Alex Jones Fans the Flames of His Conspiracy Theories - Reason - August 4th, 2022
- A New Cloud Company Looking to Disrupt The Old Order - Digital Journal - August 4th, 2022
- Nazis try to get on the ballot in Massachusetts - but may not have collected enough signatures - Universal Hub - August 4th, 2022
- Meme Creators Want Instagram To Change Its Content Moderation Policies And Stop Deplatforming Them - BuzzFeed News - July 26th, 2022
- Alexs War: A film about the de-platformed conspiracy theorist hits iTunes July 29 - BGR - July 26th, 2022
- Dozens of States Are Jumping on the Social Media Censorship Bandwagon - Gizmodo - July 26th, 2022
- What is Mike Lees TEAM Act and how would it reform Big Tech? | Opinion - Deseret News - July 18th, 2022
- Amid fears of election subversion, DeSantis' handpicked secretary of state will oversee his race - Salon - July 18th, 2022
- Internal Twitter messages show employees targeting Libs of TikTok ... - July 9th, 2022
- Leaked internal messages show Twitter employees debating whether to ban us - July 9th, 2022
- Trump Appeals Dismissal Of Preposterous Suit Against Twitter For Tortious Deplatforming - Above the Law - June 29th, 2022
- Loud music and take-out alcohol. Here are all the new Florida laws going into effect - WKMG News 6 & ClickOrlando - June 29th, 2022
- Study suggests identity advancement plays a key role in the downplaying of Trump's unethical behaviors - PsyPost - June 29th, 2022
- The brewing fight to keep abortion info online - The Verge - June 29th, 2022
- Yes, Elon, There is a Better Way. - International Policy Digest - June 10th, 2022
- Crypto Is An Invaluable Tool In The Fight Against Financial Oppression - - FinanceFeeds - May 25th, 2022
- Law's Jessie Hill discussed the legality of social media "deplatforming" - The Daily | Case Western Reserve University - May 11th, 2022
- Court Dropkicks Trump Twitter LOLsuit For THAT'S NOT HOW ANY OF THIS WORKS - Above the Law - May 11th, 2022
- Commentary: Is Ron DeSantis the Trump of the future? - Palm Beach Post - May 11th, 2022
- Jesus, endless war and the irresistible rise of American fascism - Salon - May 11th, 2022
- Who did Twitter ban during the Trump era, and why? - Los Angeles Times - April 28th, 2022
- The Unholy Alliance Between the US Security Apparatus and Big Tech - Fair Observer - April 28th, 2022
- Jimmy Kimmel Weighs-in on Not De-Platforming Joe Rogan: Its Not as Black and White as Sometimes the Media Makes It Out to Be - EssentiallySports - April 28th, 2022
- 'More tears and tantrums on Twitter are guaranteed' - The Week UK - April 28th, 2022
- Social media has a serious disinformation problem. But it can be fixed - The Indian Express - April 13th, 2022
- Social media company Minds and Daryl Davis tell Joe Rogan ... - April 13th, 2022