Like all nations, Australia has a right to a military presence in the South China Sea. But how and why it exercises that right have become key policy questions.
Should Australia risk kinetic conflict with China with aerial intelligence probes along its coast and possible freedom of navigation operations (FONOPs) challenging its maritime claims, all in support of the US strategy to contain China? If so, why?
Prominent Australian analyst Rory Medcalf hassummarizedAustralias interests in the South China Sea as rules, balance and lifelines. He says Australias military is there because Australia is a major trading nation, a regional maritime player in international law, a middle power that benefits from the protection of norms and international law, a partner to its Asian neighbors, and an ally of the US.
Lets examine these reasons and assess whether any of them alone or or even together are sufficient to justify the risk of political, economic and military conflict with China.
First of all, only about 20% of Australias exports pass through the South China Sea, not two-thirds, as its Defense Department White Paperhas it. While still a large chunk, most of this is destined for China and is unlikely to be interrupted by Beijing in peacetime.Further, there is an alternative route available between eastern Australia and Japan and South Korea that passes to the east of the Philippines.
More important, China has not threatened freedom of commercial navigation. The idea that it does or might is the result of clever US conflation of the freedom of commercial navigation with the freedom for its military assets to threaten and spy.
China doesconsider some of these latter activities to be violations of the duty proscribed in the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea to pay due regard to its rights and interests in its exclusive economic zone (EEZ). The US has not ratified UNCLOS yet enforces its own interpretations thereof.Does Australia really want to risk military conflict with China over this US-conflated and politicized principle?
Medcalf says Australia is a middle power and an ally of the US.But that is the problem. Australia is a middle poweronlyand is risking the ire of a great power China on behalf of its ally the US.
Would Australia be doing this on its own if it werent an ally of the US?If not, why is it sticking its neck out?Shouldnt Australias focus be on monitoring and defending its waters and adjacent approaches rather than collecting intelligence along Chinas coast?
Where Medcalfs reasoning goes off the rails is the implication that Australia is there to demonstrate its support of norms and international law.
First of all, its ally the US that it is supporting and assisting in the South China Sea has not ratified the constitution of the oceans UNCLOS that it is using to justify its presence.
Moreover, Australia is hardly a shining example of conformance with international order.It also violates UNCLOS with its EEZ claim on the Heard and McDonald rocks andits mandatory requirement of pilotagefor foreign vessels passing through the Torres Strait.But most embarrassing for Australia in this regard is its behavior regarding its maritime boundary dispute with Timor-Leste.
Yet in an epitome of hypocrisy, Australian Ambassador to the Philippines Steven Robinson joined US Secretary of State Antony Blinken inurging adherence to UNCLOS:Respect for international laws, including UNCLOS, is fundamental to peace, prosperity and stability in the region.
While that remark was clearly aimed at China, this applies to the US and Australia as well.
Finally, Medcalf cites Australias partnership with its Asian neighbors. After the recentdangerous incidentbetween Chinese and Australian warplanes near the China-held Paracel Islands, the Australian Defense Department said it has for decades undertaken maritime surveillance activities in the region.
The original excuse for the presence of Australian ISR (intelligence,surveillanceand reconnaissance) aircraft over the South China Sea was theFive Power Defense Arrangement (FPDA).But this has morphed from a pact to protect Malaysia and Singapore after the British withdrawal from the region to one of support for the US effort to contain China.
Moreover, this 1971 Cold War agreement among Australia, the UK, New Zealand, Malaysia and Singapore provides only for consultation in the event or threat of an armed attack on any party. There is no specific commitment to intervene militarily.
The enforcement of a states EEZ rights is not mentioned, although I suppose the state can ask for assistance in doing so. The FPDA has an Integrated Air Defense Systemfor Malaysia and Singapore based in Butterworth, Malaysia, under Australias command. While most exercises take place off the coasts of Malaysia and Singapore, some have extended into the South China Sea. However, MalaysiasEEZ claim stops well short of Chinas coast.
Indeed, the FPDA does not justify Australias intelligence-collection flights along Chinas coast. Moreover, Australian Poseidon P-8salso operateover the South China Sea from Singapore, Brunei, Manila and Darwin. These flights may be undertaken under the controversialFive Eyes(FVEY) pact. This is an alliance among Australia, Canada, New Zealand, the UK and the US that focuses on sharing of signals intelligence.
It originated as an anti-Soviet effort but has greatly expanded its remit. Edward Snowden has described FVEY as a supra-national organization that does not answer to known laws of its own countries. Its member states even spy on one anothers citizens to get around domestic prohibitions on such by the members own governments.
If this is the justification for the Australian ISR probes of Chinas defenses, Canberra may wish to reconsider whether it wants to continue to serve as a US proxy in this endeavor.
It is true that AUKUS the agreement to supply nuclear-submarine and underwater-drone technology to Australia will eventually make Australia a recognized player and merge its navy with that of the US in operations in the South China Sea.
But that is as a participant in the US strategy to contain China.This is not at the request of the regional countries. Indeed, some are quite opposed to AUKUS as they see it as the beginning of a renewed arms race.
The next step for Australia may be to undertake FONOPs against Chinas claims, eitherunilaterallyorwith the US. Despite strong US pressure, Australia has so far declined to do so. It has good reasons. Doing so could well trigger conflict. This would be the ultimate of supporting an ally sacrificing itself and its people for it.
But the Australian people may not know that their government is risking their welfare to support the US containment strategy.It is one thing to support allies in a war.But it is quite another to help it provoke a war in which it will be one of the first victims.
Australian Defense Secretary Richard Marles hasdeclared,Our national interest lies in the East China Sea and the South China Sea in what are the rules of the road the global rules-based order. He said Australia wouldcontinueits ISR probes in the South China Sea. It seems that Australia is bent on poking China in the eye regardless of the consequences.
Perhaps it should consider how it would react if Chinese ISR planes were operating off its coast, probing its defenses and dropping sonobuoys to detect its submarine. As an indication, in May, then-defense minister Peter Duttoncalledthe presence of a Chinese intelligence-collection ship in its EEZ off Exmouth Naval Base an aggressive act.
The situation is becoming increasingly dangerous.There was hope that the new Labor administration under Prime Minister Anthony Albanese would take a more rational, longer-term view 0n relations with China.But it has already earned Chinas anger by publicly criticizing Beijings response to US House Speaker Nancy Pelosis recent visit to Taiwan.
Indeed, this serious situation raises fundamental questions for the Albanese government. How far should Australia go on behalf of the US in this game of military chicken in the South China Sea?
Australia may be sleepwalking into kinetic conflict with China in the South China Sea. The government should be clear and honest with its people as to the risks Australia faces and why it is taking them in a sea so far from its shores.
See the original post:
Why is Australia risking conflict with China? - Asia Times
- NSA surveillance exposed by Snowden ruled unlawful - BBC - May 25th, 2024
- Can Edward Snowden Become the Next CEO of Twitter? Elon Musk is Ready to Give Up - Analytics Insight - May 15th, 2024
- Edward Snowden Weighs In On Boeing Whistleblower's Death With Cryptic Message: 'If I Die, It Wasn't Suicide' - TradingView - March 21st, 2024
- Edward Snowden Calls Bitcoin 'Most Significant Monetary Advance Since the Creation of Coinage' Featured Bitcoin ... - Bitcoin.com News - February 25th, 2024
- Edward Snowden: Bitcoin 'Most Significant Monetary Advance Since the Creation of Coinage' - Decrypt - February 25th, 2024
- Edward Snowden's Ominous Warning to the World - Newsweek - January 15th, 2024
- Edward Snowden Says Institutions 'Burning The Public's Faith' At Time When AI Can Replace Them: 'A Revolu - Benzinga - January 15th, 2024
- Edward Snowden: Bitcoin Safeguard for Pensions and Retirement - CoinGape - January 15th, 2024
- Edward Snowden and Jack Dorsey Are Both Asking the Same Question: What Happened in 1971? - Foundation for Economic Education - December 11th, 2023
- Edward Snowden - Simple English Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia - October 27th, 2023
- Edward Snowden On The NSA, His Book 'Permanent Record' And Life In ... - April 17th, 2023
- 209-359-17.. located in Merced.. Find Info before it disappears... - April 17th, 2023
- Edward Snowden gets Russian passport after swearing oath of allegiance ... - April 8th, 2023
- Edward Snowden - Education, Movie & Documentary - Biography - March 5th, 2023
- Before sending a voice message, ask if you could say it in writing: How to stop the avalanche of WhatsApp audios - EL PAS USA - February 25th, 2023
- Entertainment News Roundup: Sean Penn film 'Superpower' catches Zelenskiy at moment of Russian invasion; And the winner is... London rolls out red... - February 25th, 2023
- Edward Snowden Reacts To Elon Musk's 'Pardon' Poll: 'That's A Very Big ... - January 6th, 2023
- NSA files decoded: Edward Snowden's surveillance revelations explained ... - December 20th, 2022
- Edward Snowden says he feels itch to scale back in to $16.5K Bitcoin - December 20th, 2022
- Edward Snowden Offers to Take Over as Twitter CEO for Salary in ... - Investing.com - December 20th, 2022
- Where is Edward Snowden? | The Sun - November 25th, 2022
- Edward Snowden, Elon Musk Optimistic About Bitcoin Despite FTX Collapse - Crypto Briefing - November 17th, 2022
- Snowden's newfound Russian citizenship reignites the debate of privacy versus safety in the US - Tufts Daily - October 15th, 2022
- Whistleblower behind Luanda Leaks, Malta Files and Football Leaks on trial - The Shift News - October 15th, 2022
- 'All The Beauty And The Bloodshed' Trailer: Laura Poitras' Golden Lion Winner Hits US Theaters Later This Fall - The Playlist - October 15th, 2022
- NYFF 2022: No Bears, R.M.N., All the Beauty and the Bloodshed | Festivals & Awards - Roger Ebert - October 15th, 2022
- From Bin Laden to Al Zawahiri: The evolution of Americas Targeted Killing Strategy - Indian Defence Review - October 15th, 2022
- Arundhati Roy on Things that Can and Cannot Be Said: The Dismantling of the World as We Know It - LiveWire - October 7th, 2022
- Billion Dollar Harvest: TikTok's Threat to National and Personal Security MARIST CIRCLE - Marist College The Circle - October 7th, 2022
- 'All the Beauty and the Bloodshed' Review: Politics of the Personal - slantmagazine - September 21st, 2022
- Congressional inquiry reveals secret Customs and Border Protection database of U.S. phone records - CyberScoop - September 21st, 2022
- The Most Controversial Biopics - IndieWire - September 21st, 2022
- VIDEO: Priyanka Chopra celebrated her husband Nick Jonas' birthday like this at the golf course, wrote - News84Media.com - September 21st, 2022
- From Bin Laden to Al Zawahiri: The evolution of Americas targeted killing strategy - MyVoice - September 21st, 2022
- At German artist Thomas Demands MOCA exhibit, finding the material in the ephemeral - Toronto Star - September 21st, 2022
- This is the jungle: Law enforcement slowly waking up to the threat of DeFi exploits - Fortune - September 13th, 2022
- Icarus: The Aftermath Review: A Tense and Affecting Real-Life Sequel - Hollywood Reporter - September 13th, 2022
- Fourth Amendment: The right to be left alone - Minot Daily News - September 13th, 2022
- Opinion | It Is Time to Throw the Monarchies of the World Into the Dustbin of History - Common Dreams - September 13th, 2022
- Do the FBI monitor peoples social media activity and online posts? Is it legal? - AS USA - September 5th, 2022
- Is Trump the Rosenbergs? - JNS.org - JNS.org - September 5th, 2022
- The Patriot Act: Mass Surveillance Before and After 9/11 - Privacy News Online - September 5th, 2022
- Can code just be 'disappeared' from the internet? - POLITICO - August 28th, 2022
- The Tech Industry Is in Its Whistleblower Era - The Atlantic - August 28th, 2022
- History As It Happens: The Espionage Act's sordid origins - Washington Times - August 28th, 2022
- The inside story of the CIA vs Russia - Asia Times - August 28th, 2022
- 'The rebels were sent to a lunatic asylum': These films end differently in China - Euronews - August 28th, 2022
- Erik Prince wants to sell you a secure smartphone thats too good to be true - MIT Technology Review - August 20th, 2022
- Judge orders DoJ to produce redacted version of affidavit in state secrets investigation of Trump - WSWS - August 20th, 2022
- How to Use the Signal App: Tips & Tricks - Online Tech Tips - August 20th, 2022
- Ruling Class Turns On Conservative Americans - The American Conservative - August 20th, 2022
- Signal Reveals Over 1900 Users Were Affected in a Recent Phishing Attack - Appuals - August 20th, 2022
- Despite resistance, WikiLeaks continues its fight for the truth - Independent Australia - August 20th, 2022
- The Republican party has reason to fear the midterms - The Guardian - August 20th, 2022
- Government pays arms firm that spied on activists to snoop on all our internet records - The Canary - August 20th, 2022
- Edward Snowden, Russia's 'Disinformation Campaign' Drive 'Downhill' Narrative, Says 'Black Swan' Author - Benzinga - August 12th, 2022
- What Does All This TV Talk on Big Ten Do for Big 12 and Oklahoma State? - Pokes Report - August 12th, 2022
- From Defending the Open Internet to Confronting the Reality of a Fragmented Cyberspace: Reflecting Upon Two CFR Reports on U.S. Goals in Cyberspace -... - August 12th, 2022
- US Vows To "aggressively Pursue" Cryptocurrency Mixers - Nation World News - August 12th, 2022
- After cryptos crash and NFTs collapse, Web3 idealists race to prove that the dream of decentralization isnt dead - Fortune - August 12th, 2022
- Prescribing a New Paradigm for Cyber Competition - War on the Rocks - August 12th, 2022
- What is Monero (XMR) Crypto? Is Edward Snowden Behind This Project too? - CryptoTicker.io - Bitcoin Price, Ethereum Price & Crypto News - August 4th, 2022
- Russian hackers get the headlines. But China is the bigger threat to many US enterprises. - Protocol - August 4th, 2022
- Why Is July 30th National Whistleblower Day? - Privacy News Online - August 4th, 2022
- I may have to wait until I'm on my deathbed Panama Papers whistleblower - Namibian - August 4th, 2022
- Whatever Happened to the Transhumanists? - Gizmodo Australia - August 4th, 2022
- Julian Assange? Heres why I am not a fan of his - The Citizen - August 4th, 2022
- Who Is Edward Snowden, the Man Who Spilled the NSA's Secrets? - July 26th, 2022
- Why so silent? Edward Snowden has gone underground since Russia's ... - July 26th, 2022
- Kids spend the summer in STEM camp - Marketplace - July 26th, 2022
- Thomas Demand: The Stutter of History - Announcements - E-Flux - July 26th, 2022
- Empire of Hacking: U.S. is the Biggest Threat to Cyber Security - Xinhua - July 26th, 2022
- Edward Snowden Says 'We Are All Going To Be Billionaires' But... - Benzinga - Benzinga - July 18th, 2022
- Joshua Schulte convicted on all counts in second trial over 2017 leak of Vault 7 cyberwarfare trove published by WikiLeaks - WSWS - July 18th, 2022
- SMITHEREENS: Reflections on Bits & Pieces:SMITHERMATAZ. Category: Public Comment from The Berkeley Daily Planet - Berkeley Daily Planet - July 18th, 2022
- Full Text of All Articles The Berkeley Daily Planet - Berkeley Daily Planet - July 18th, 2022
- As Bear Market Turns All Eyes to Utility, Privacy Stands Poised To Lead Next Crypto Breakout - The Daily Hodl - July 18th, 2022
- Yes, data centers use a lot of water. But a Utah company shows it doesn't have to be that way. - Salt Lake Tribune - July 18th, 2022
- Edward Snowden - National Whistleblower Center - July 9th, 2022
- Commentary: The fight against excessive surveillance continues in Maine and across the country - Press Herald - July 9th, 2022