It gives me no joy to write this piece.
Even a cursory review of the redacted version of the affidavit submitted in support of the governments application for a search warrant at the home of former President Donald Trump reveals that he will soon be indicted by a federal grand jury for three crimes: Removing and concealing national defense information (NDI), giving NDI to those not legally entitled to possess it, and obstruction of justice by failing to return NDI to those who are legally entitled to retrieve it.
When he learned from a phone call that 30 FBI agents were at the front door of his Florida residence with a search warrant and he decided to reveal this publicly, Trump assumed that the agents were looking for classified top-secret materials that theyd allege he criminally possessed. His assumptions were apparently based on his gut instinct and not on a sophisticated analysis of the law. Hence, his public boast that he declassified all the formerly classified documents he took with him.
Unbeknownst to him, the feds had anticipated such a defense and are not preparing to indict him for possessing classified materials, even though he did possess hundreds of voluntarily surrendered materials marked top secret.
It is irrelevant if the documents were declassified, as the feds will charge crimes that do not require proof of classification. They told the federal judge who signed the search warrant that Trump still had NDI in his home. It appears they were correct.
Under the law, it doesnt matter if the documents on which NDI is contained are classified or not, as it is simply and always criminal to have NDI in a non-federal facility, to have those without security clearances move it from one place to another, and to keep it from the feds when they are seeking it. Stated differently, the absence of classification for whatever reason is not a defense to the charges that are likely to be filed against Trump.
Yet, misreading and underestimating the feds, Trump actually did them a favor. One of the elements that they must prove for any of the three crimes is that Trump knew that he had the documents. The favor he did was admitting to that when he boasted that they were no longer classified. He committed a mortal sin in the criminal defense world by denying something for which he had not been accused.
The second element that the feds must prove is that the documents actually do contain national defense information. And the third element they must prove is that Trump put these documents into the hands of those not authorized to hold them and stored them in a non-federally secured place. Intelligence community experts have already examined the documents taken from Trumps home and are prepared to tell a jury that they contain the names of foreign agents secretly working for the U.S. This is the crown jewel of government secrets. Moreover, Trumps Florida home is not a secure federal facility designated for the deposit of NDI.
The newest aspect of the case against Trump that we learned from the redacted affidavit is the obstruction allegation. This is not the obstruction that Robert Mueller claimed he found Trump committed during the Russia investigation. This is a newer obstruction statute, signed by President George W. Bush in 2002, that places far fewer burdens on the feds to prove. The older statute is the one Mueller alleged. It characterizes any material interference with a judicial function as criminal. Thus, one who lies to a grand jury or prevents a witness from testifying commits this variant of obstruction.
But the Bush-era statute, the one the feds contemplate charging Trump with having violated, makes it a crime of obstruction by failing to return government property or by sending the FBI on a wild goose chase looking for something that belongs to the government and that you know that you have. This statute does not require the preexistence of a judicial proceeding. It only requires that the defendant has the governments property, knows that he has it and baselessly resists efforts by the government to get it back.
Where does all this leave Trump? The short answer is: in hot water. The longer answer is: He is confronting yet again the federal law enforcement and intelligence communities for which he has rightly expressed such public disdain. He had valid points of expression during the Russia investigation. He has little ground upon which to stand today.
I have often argued that many of these statutes that the feds have enacted to protect themselves are morally unjust and not grounded in the Constitution. One of my intellectual heroes, the great Murray Rothbard, taught that the government protects itself far more aggressively than it protects our natural rights.
In a monumental irony, both Julian Assange, the WikiLeaks journalist who exposed American war crimes during the Afghanistan and Iraq wars, and Edward Snowden, the former National Security Agency employee who exposed criminal mass government surveillance upon the American public, stand charged with the very same crimes that are likely to be brought against Trump. On both Assange and Snowden, Trump argued that they should be executed. Fortunately for all three, these statutes do not provide for capital punishment.
Rothbard warned that the feds aggressively protect themselves. Yet, both Assange and Snowden are heroic defenders of liberty with valid moral and legal defenses. Assange is protected by the Pentagon Papers case, which insulates the media from criminal or civil liability for revealing stolen matters of interest to the public, so long as the revealer is not the thief. Snowden is protected by the Constitution, which expressly prohibits the warrantless surveillance he revealed, which was the most massive peacetime abuse of government power.
What will Trump say is his defense to taking national defense information? I cannot think of a legally viable one.
Today's breaking news and more in your inbox
Read more:
Why Trump will soon be indicted | News, Sports, Jobs - The Sentinel - Lewistown Sentinel
- Beguiling new documentary puts WikiLeaks star Jacob Appelbaum in the spotlight - The Globe and Mail - June 18th, 2024
- WikiLeaks' Assange extradition appeal to be heard next month By Reuters - Investing.com - June 18th, 2024
- Will the First Amendment Save Assange? - The American Conservative - June 10th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Assange wins right to appeal against an extradition order to the US - Manchestertimes - May 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange's legal saga could soon end in UK | AP ... - May 25th, 2024
- London Court To Decide Whether WikiLeaks Founder Assange Is Extradited To The US - Newstalk 750 - 103.7 KFQD - KFQD - May 25th, 2024
- London court rules WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange can appeal an extradition order to the US - Montana Right Now - May 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange can appeal extradition to the US, UK court rules - KABC-TV - May 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange allowed to appeal extradition from UK to US - The Times of India - May 25th, 2024
- London court rules WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange can appeal an extradition order to the US - Leader Publications - May 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Assange wins right to appeal against an extradition order to the US - News10NBC - May 25th, 2024
- Wife Of Wikileaks Founder, Stella Assange Vows To Fight On As He Faces Extradition To The U.S. - Moneycontrol - May 15th, 2024
- The Cultivation of Don Jr: A Framework to Think of the Russian Attack - Emptywheel - May 15th, 2024
- Peace People founder urges Joe Biden to release Julian Assange if Wikileaks publisher is extradited to the US - The Irish News - April 28th, 2024
- WikiLeaks editor-in-chief on why the world needs Assange to be freed - The Saturday Paper - April 28th, 2024
- Not too late to block Assange extradition, WikiLeaks editor says - The Independent - April 11th, 2024
- Not too late to block Assange extradition, WikiLeaks editor says - Evening Standard - April 11th, 2024
- Julian Assange: UK court orders delay to extradition of WikiLeaks founder to US - The Associated Press - April 2nd, 2024
- Julian Assange: UK court orders delay to extradition of WikiLeaks ... - April 2nd, 2024
- Julian Assange, WikiLeaks founder, given chance to appeal against U.S ... - April 2nd, 2024
- U.K. court gives WikiLeaks Julian Assange three weeks before extradition - The Washington Post - The Washington Post - April 2nd, 2024
- WikiLeaks' Julian Assange wins temporary reprieve from extradition to US - TRT World - April 2nd, 2024
- Julian Assange wins temporary reprieve from extradition to US - Reuters UK - April 2nd, 2024
- Timeline of the Assange legal saga as he faces further delay in bid to avoid extradition to the US - The Associated Press - April 2nd, 2024
- UK delays extradition of WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange to the US - The Hill - April 2nd, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange will not be immediately extradited to the U.S., British court rules - CNBC - April 2nd, 2024
- Will Julian Assange Be Extradited to the US? Why Its Complicated - Bloomberg - April 2nd, 2024
- Julian Assange gets brief reprieve in the UK - OCRegister - April 2nd, 2024
- US granted extension by UK High Court to provide 'satisfactory assurances' for fair trial of WikiLeaks founder - JURIST - April 2nd, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange wins partial victory in U.S. extradition case - The Globe and Mail - April 2nd, 2024
- Julian Assange wins temporary reprieve in case against extradition to US - The Guardian - April 2nd, 2024
- Julian Assange Scores Temporary Win in Fight Against Extradition - The Daily Beast - April 2nd, 2024
- Assange granted temporary reprieve from extradition to U.S. - The Hindu - April 2nd, 2024
- Protect the founder of WikiLeaks for the future of press freedom - The Baylor Lariat - March 21st, 2024
- The Trust Fall: Julian Assange film review impassioned documentary about the WikiLeaks founder - Financial Times - March 21st, 2024
- The Trust Fall: Julian Assange review partisan portrait of WikiLeaks man - The Guardian - March 21st, 2024
- Rep. Massie bringing Julian Assange's brother as guest to State of the Union - Fox News - March 13th, 2024
- Assange's extradition would mean the end of legality, Russia believes - Prensa Latina - March 13th, 2024
- The Press Freedom Case of the Century - Random Lengths - March 13th, 2024
- UN expert on freedom of expression urges end to Julian Assanges prosecution over press freedom concerns - Fox News - March 5th, 2024
- WikiLeaks has not released the footage of NASAs moon landing shot in the Nevada Desert. - Factly - March 5th, 2024
- Public meetings called by the SEP/IYSSE in Britain: The fight to free Julian Assange is the fight against war! - WSWS - March 5th, 2024
- Why extradition of WikiLeaks Julian Assange to US would be cataclysmic for press freedom - Committee to Protect Journalists - March 5th, 2024
- Stella Assange: This case has normalized intimidating journalists everywhere - EL PAS USA - March 5th, 2024
- China and Iran Have Their WikiLeaks Moment - AOL - March 5th, 2024
- 'It would be a good thing if British courts give Assange necessary protection': German Chancellor - The New Indian Express - March 5th, 2024
- Navalny And Assange: Exposing Crimes Of The Powerful Like No "Ordinary" Journalists Could - Worldcrunch - March 5th, 2024
- US Refuses to Assure UK Judges That Assange Won't Be Executed If He's Extradited - Truthout - March 5th, 2024
- WikiLeaks - Wikiwand - February 25th, 2024
- Assange targeted by U.S. and Trump over his WikiLeaks exposures, lawyer says - Reuters - February 25th, 2024
- Julian Assange: Who is he and what secrets did Wikileaks reveal? - BBC.com - February 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Assange begins final attempt to avoid ... - PBS - February 25th, 2024
- Wikileaks founders last bid to resist extradition to the U.S. - CNN - February 25th, 2024
- What to know as Julian Assange faces a ruling on his U.S. extradition case over WikiLeaks secrets - CBS News - February 25th, 2024
- Who is Julian Assange? Will the WikiLeaks founder be extradited to the US? - Al Jazeera English - February 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Assange may be near the end of his long fight to stay out of the US - The Associated Press - February 25th, 2024
- Wife of WikiLeaks' Assange calls U.S. extradition hearing a 'farce' - NBC News - February 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks' Assange faces wait to find out whether he can challenge extradition to the US - The Associated Press - February 25th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange starts final UK legal battle to avoid extradition to US on spy charges - The Associated Press - February 25th, 2024
- 'Created a serious and imminent risk': US lawyers argue for spying charges against WikiLeaks founder Juli - The Times of India - February 25th, 2024
- Julian Assange is fighting extradition to the US. Here's what you should know about the WikiLeaks founder's situation - ABC News - February 25th, 2024
- Julian Assange: Who is he and what secrets did Wikileaks reveal? - BBC - February 25th, 2024
- Julian Assange's father calls on government to pressure UK, US to release WikiLeaks founder - ABC News - February 25th, 2024
- Australian lawmakers approve motion calling for release of Julian ... - February 17th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder Assange will die if extradited to US: Wife - Press TV - February 17th, 2024
- WikiLeaks founder: Assange 'will die' if UK appeal fails and sent to US: wife - RTL Today - February 17th, 2024
- The Last Flurry: The US Congress and Australian Parliamentarians seek Assange's Release - CounterPunch - January 24th, 2024
- Vault 7 - Wikipedia - November 17th, 2023
- WikiLeaks - Wikipedia - May 3rd, 2023
- WikiLeaks' Website Is Slowly Falling Apart - February 25th, 2023
- 12 Years Of Disruption: A WikiLeaks Timeline - NPR.org - February 25th, 2023
- Who is Julian Assange? What to know about the WikiLeaks ... - February 25th, 2023
- How Much Did WikiLeaks Damage U.S. National Security? - February 25th, 2023
- Julian Assange - WikiLeaks, Arrest & Facts - Biography - February 25th, 2023
- Ram Madhav writes on BBC documentary on PM Modi: A hit job that is a damp squib - The Indian Express - January 30th, 2023
- WikiLeaks - BadMFS -- Developer Guide - January 6th, 2023
- News Outlets Urge U.S. to Drop Charges Against Julian Assange - The New York Times - December 4th, 2022
- Elon Musk starts new Twitter poll on whether Assange and Snowden should be pardoned - Republic World - December 4th, 2022
- WikiLeaks - Government - October 31st, 2022
- WikiLeaks - What is WikiLeaks - October 31st, 2022