Turnbull’s citizenship changes reflect the Trumpist zeitgeist – The Sydney Morning Herald

Election-weary Britons head to the polls on June 8. The French will vote this weekend. Americans only recently concluded their distended democratic ritual. Different countries, different systems, different voters. A common theme? Immigration.

Donald Trump pulled off his unlikely victory by invoking a dichotomy: Americans versus others. The antediluvian promise to make America great again was pitched at a demoralised working class, deprived of a social safety net and denied real wage growth for decades.

Play Video Don't Play

Play Video Don't Play

Previous slide Next slide

Australia is toughening up its citizenship test. How does it compare overseas?

Play Video Don't Play

Morgan Huxley's ex girlfriend, Jessica Hall reads out a statement after his killer, Jack Kelsall was found guilty of murder.

Play Video Don't Play

McGrath Breast Care Nurse, Sam Burns, discusses how the loss of her mother at a young age inspired her to help others with breast cancer. Video: McGrath Foundation.

Play Video Don't Play

Immigration is a rally point for prime ministers past and present. As Malcolm Turnbull shifts to the right on the issue, what did his predescessors do? And why did they do it?

Play Video Don't Play

The US online retail behemoth confirmed Thursday it will establish the first of many fulfillment centres in Australia, in a move that's sure to disrupt the local market.

Play Video Don't Play

Immigration Minister Peter Dutton offered a new account of recent Manus rampage in an interview on Sky News.

Play Video Don't Play

In a Facebook live video, South Sudanese-born model Adau Mornyang tearfully recounts an alleged rape she suffered in Adelaide six years ago.

Australia is toughening up its citizenship test. How does it compare overseas?

It cleverly ignored the yawning gulf between a privileged, tax-astute billionaire and his new electoral quarry by excavating an even bigger hole in which immigration was conflated with national security, free trade with job losses, globalism with US decline.

In France, Marine Le Pen's far-right National Front exploits similar tensions by branding asylum seekers "illegal". "They have no reason to stay in France" Le Pen says blithely because "these people broke the law the minute they set foot on French soil".

Theresa May's snap British poll is an aftershock of last year's stunning Brexit quake when ordinary Brits ignored elite opinion to cut ties with Europe. Their disaffection derived substantially from the EU's free movement rules that had foreign labour transforming the British economy in ways that suited capital but left workers feeling worse off.

Le Pen, fanning the same anxieties, frames French citizenship as "either inherited or merited", which may be reasonable coming from a more moderate voice. Most, however, see it as the dog-whistle it is: extremism masquerading as common sense. It is typical of the new xenophobia that parades as an antidote to global uncertainty yet poses an existential threat to French cohesion, as well as European stability.

Against these trends, Turnbull's deification of "Australian citizenship" reflects Australia's more sober debate.

It locates Australian identity as a set of beliefs under the rubric of multiple differences: "We're not defined by race or religion or culture, as many other nations are. We're defined by commitment to common values, political values, the rule of law, democracy, freedom, mutual respect, equality for men and women. These fundamental values are what make us Australian."

Unsurprisingly, Turnbull's new muscularity on Aussie "values", which, rhetorically at least, sits more readily with his predecessor, Tony Abbott, has fuelled plenty of suspicion. Cynical observers will view it as a Clayton's boat people fight, the one you engender once the boats have actually stopped being an issue.

Doubtless an embattled prime minister would welcome any electoral dividend and the extra protection within his own party room. But that does not of itself, make the proposed changes wrong.

Follow us on Facebook

Read more here:

Turnbull's citizenship changes reflect the Trumpist zeitgeist - The Sydney Morning Herald