CEOs and Twitter trolls take on Roe v. Wade – Yahoo Finance

The Supreme Court is apparently poised to repeal the federal abortion protection of Roe v. Wade, and CEOs around the country are being called out. Some are decrying the move. Others are saying nothing. Few, if any, are publicly cheering.

There is no easy playbook here. While companies have zero obligationlegal or otherwiseto take a stand on any social or political issue, they have in recent years waded into those waters (consider after George Floyd's killing, North Carolina's bathroom ban, and Georgia's voting laws). And of course companies dont have opinions, CEOs do, which they may or may not share, andas Brian Moynihan, CEO of Bank of America stressed this week on CBS re: Roemay or may not be the prevailing view of their constituents.

It's the settled law of the land. We believe people should have that access," Moynihan said, cautioning that his opinion does not reflect that of all the company's 200,000 U.S. employees. "I could have a personal point of view, but that's not what we do," he said.

Then, there's the issue itself its fate still hanging in the balance. Abortion has long been a third rail of American politics. Some CEOs are stating their positions more forcefully than Moynihan, either because they feel strongly about the issue or because doing so is good for their businessor both. Those who are loathe to speak out about abortion may believe they risk alienating 40% or so of not just their employees, but customers and shareholdersnever mind local citizens and politicians. (BTW, parsing pro-choice and pro-life opinion polls is a fraught science all its own.)

The paradox is the more these difficult issues come to the fore, the more chief executives are being asked to weigh in. And theyve watched with alarm as Disney CEO Bob Chapek fumbled the handling of his companys response to Floridas Parental Rights in Education Act, or what critics have dubbed the "Don't Say Gay" bill.

Story continues

At the Milken Conference this week, I asked Mary Barra, CEO of GMand Disney board memberabout this.

Serwer: Social issues are difficult right now. How do you think about that?

WASHINGTON, DC - MAY 03: Pro-choice activists protest in response to the leaked Supreme Court draft decision to overturn Roe v. Wade (Getty Images)

Barra: Well, at General Motors, we really focus on what are our values, and because we know our employees joined the company, because they want to join a company that has, you know, values that they share. And so when we make statements, it's usually around our values of what we believe. And, you know, General Motors stands for inclusion, we want everyone to participate in our all electric future. And we value all of our customers and all of our employees. So that's our focus. And when we make statements, it's associated with our values and what we believe.

Not a lot of meat on them bones, but to be fair, depending on where you sit and what you believe, its tricky stuff.

Last Saturday in Omaha I listened as Warren Buffett offered sage context at his annual meeting:

The last time that the country was [this] tribal was when I was a kid and Roosevelt was in. Either you hated Roosevelt, or you loved him People are always going to be partisan. They're going to have religious beliefs. They [always] had a certain amount of tribal[ism] alwaysbut I don't think it's a good development for society

As for abortion rights specifically, the controversy is both a moral debate between a womens right to choose and when life begins, and a political one over which entity should adjudicate that question, federal or state government. With the potential demise of Roe v. Wade, state abortion laws, which are already quite varied, will become even more so, further accentuating the distinction between blue states and red states. Will it follow that we will have blue companies and red companies? Well, we kind of already do.

As Yahoo Finances Alexis Keenan reports: Amazon (AMZN), Apple (AAPL), Bumble (BMBL), Citigroup (C), Levi Strauss (LEVI), Match Group (MTCH), and Yelp (YELP) reimburse travel expenses incurred to obtain abortion care that's legally unavailable within their home state.

U.S. Senator Elizabeth Warren (D-MA) joins demonstrators during a pro-choice protest outside the U.S. Supreme Court to support abortion rights (Getty Images)

Meanwhile, Salesforce (CRM) is offering to pick up moving expenses for its employees who live in a state with an abortion ban exceeding that of Roe, and move to another without such restrictions.

On the other hand companies like Walmart, American Airlines, and the aforementioned Disney have made no statements. As for CEOs who are in favor of overturning Roe v. Wade, Im sure theyre some out there, but I couldnt find any. However, The New York Times reports this on a related note:

In September, John Gibson, the chief executive of Tripwire Interactive, a gaming company based in Georgia, wrote on Twitter that he was "proud" of the Supreme Court for affirming the Texas law banning abortion for babies with a heartbeat. His comments angered colleagues, and within a few days he was replaced.

CEOs who are pro-life may be keeping mum because theyre scared of losing their jobs. But if abortion is such a divisive issue, why are pro-choice CEOs speaking out? If conservative CEOs think it's because theyll be attacked by the woke, Twitter troll mob, well, the un-woke Twitter troll mob is none too friendly, either.

Its not a coincidence that the demise of constructive government (aka gridlock) has occurred at the same time we're seeing companies having to step into the political and social arena, i.e. practice stakeholder capitalism. Someone or something has to fill the breach and take the lead. Im glad CEOs are stepping up in many cases, but it really isnt their purview. We need lawmakers to come together and do their jobs,

George Mitchell, a Democrat and former Senate Majority Leader, once told me he had dinner with his GOP counterpart, the late Bob Dole, every week without fail in the early 1990s. And then theres this from an obituary this week in the New York Times of Norman Mineta, former congressman and cabinet member who as a Japanese American was interned in a U.S. prison camp as a boy: Mr. Mineta quickly made it clear that, for him, transportation was not partisan. There are no Democratic or Republican highways, he told reporters.

Sadly, the tribal trolls disagree.

See the original post:

CEOs and Twitter trolls take on Roe v. Wade - Yahoo Finance