Thinking critically about critical race theory – The Nevada Independent

Im not going to pretend I know what critical race theory is. Refusing to do so, however, apparently puts me ahead of a lot of Nevadans.

Dont get me wrong, I have some ideas of what it might be. Im not alone in that the Washoe County school board recently sat through an 11 hour lecture on critical race theory delivered via a near-endless parade of public comment. According to some of the comments, when a vehicle with California plates parks in the school district parking lot, thats critical race theory. When God isnt mentioned in public schools, thats also critical race theory even though white people are consistently less religious than most minority groups. Birth rates plummeting below replacement levels? Thats critical race theory. Loveless sex, suicidal despair, drug abuse, pornography, sexual chaos, and the districts sexual education program behind it all? All critical race theory.

What about females getting elected to school boards? What about treason, Marxism, 19 million (wholly imaginary) dead Black babies, and (wholly imaginary) instructions on how to safely lick an anus in our school curriculum? Yes, Nevada its all critical race theory, at least according to one especially colorful public commenter improvising during open mic night at the Washoe County school district administration building.

If it seems to you like complaining about critical race theory is just a way for certain people to gripe about social changes they disapprove of, youre not alone. In certain corners of conservative punditry, in fact, this behavior is explicitly encouraged. The goal, as the Manhattan Institutes Christopher Rufo describes it, is to have the public read something crazy in the newspaper and immediately think critical race theory.

In other words, the current moral panic surrounding critical race theory is an explicit attempt by conservatives to motivate their political base using the worst argument in the world. Just as certain lazy libertarians like to yell Taxation is theft! with the goal of getting people to transfer their instinctive dislike of theft to taxation, conservatives are hoping people will transfer their instinctive dislike of whatever critical race theory summons in their minds upon incantation to whatever sociopolitical changes they wish to fight.

This sort of rhetorical maneuvering was easier during the Cold War when communism was an obvious villain and partisan hacks could claim everything they opposed was cultural Marxism. The Soviet Union, however, collapsed three decades ago. The best Marxism can do nowadays is mildly annoy everyone with depressing prop comedy and obnoxious teens on Twitter. The idea that a borderline-suicidal stand-up comic and COMRADE_HOXHADIST1945s twelve followers on some social media platform are going to somehow undermine anything more consequential than a household chore schedule sounds downright delusional at this point.

As complaining about cultural Marxism does little to motivate anyone who isnt actively collecting Social Security these days, conservative activists have been searching desperately for an alternative. This isnt the first time they have looked for one within the musty halls of the academic wing of the social justice movement. Brietbart.com, for example, has an entire section devoted to intersectionality. Why anyone should be worried about intersectionality, however, always requires an explanation. Critical race theory merely requires an imagination.

So what is critical race theory?

Again, Im not going to pretend I know, but I can tell you the Washington Post has a handy explainer of the concept, as well as conservative reactions to it. Thats admittedly not a primary source, however nor, for that matter, is Citizens for Renewing Americas explanation, which explicitly draws the connection in the conservative universe between cultural Marxism and critical race theory.

Subtle.

On the other hand, I can tell you were not going to find out what critical race theory is by attaching body cameras to teachers so we can all collectively surveil one others children in their classrooms. Frankly, advocating for widespread, ubiquitous surveillance of our children sounds like something straight out of George Orwells 1984 in other words, it sounds like cultural Marxism, except that its being advocated for by people who claim to be conservative. Granted, this wouldnt be the first time communist and far-right interests allied with each other, but it still seems a little counterproductive.

What I can tell you is that the term critical race theory is searched for far more often than intersectionality these days, especially (though not exclusively) in Republican-leaning states. Thats why, if I had to guess, critical race theory appears to be the latest pavlovian bell conservatives are ringing to raise funds and crowds by grabbing the attention of people whose minds race whenever they hear someone talk about race. If our school board meetings are any indication, that bell is ringing loud and clear.

Somebody should make a theory about how and why that works.

David Colborne was active in the Libertarian Party for two decades. During that time, he blogged intermittently on his personal blog, ran for office twice as a Libertarian candidate, and served on the Executive Committee for his state and county Libertarian Party chapters. He is now the father of two sons, an IT manager, and a registered non-partisan voter. You can follow him on Twitter @DavidColborne or email him at [emailprotected].

View post:
Thinking critically about critical race theory - The Nevada Independent