It appears, by all accounts, to be a momentous scientific achievement and possibly a turning point in human evolution. In a study released last week, scientists at Oregon Health and Science University confirmed they were able to modify genes in viable human embryos, proving the potential to permanently alter the makeup of a genetic line.
In this case, that meant replacing and repairing a mutated gene that causes a common and deadly heart disorder. But the possibilities heralded by gene-editing technology are endless, the scenarios as divided as they are bold. In some visions, it leads to a population of designer babies or consumer eugenics. Others imagine a utopia of scientific advancement where humans live free of disease, and devastating conditions are eradicated for the betterment of humanity. What direction the technology will take is the topic of much debate.
The big thing which is making the scientific and ethics community get excited, and on the other hand a little bit hot and bothered, is its a mechanism to change genes for multiple generations, says Dr. Alice Virani, a genetic counsellor and director of ethics at British Columbias Provincial Health Services Authority. There are two ways to look at it, the more realistic ramifications and the sci-fi, if-this-was-out-of-control ramifications.
Opinion: Gene editing is not about designer babies
The team at the Oregon universitys Center for Embryonic Cell and Gene Therapy used technology called CRISPR, or Clustered Regularly Interspaced Short Palindromic Repeats, to repair or edit the gene carrying the heart disorder, seemingly with greater success than previous attempts by scientists in China.
News of the research has been anxiously anticipated by many in the field, both for what it means for the potential eradication of a disease such as hypertrophic cardiomyopathy and for the fundamental questions it raises about human reproduction, health and society.
When the study was leaked days before its publication in the journal Nature, its lead scientist, Dr. Shoukhrat Mitalipov, attributed the release to likely a combination of hot words: CRISPR, gene-editing, and designer babies.
The study and its combination of hot words didnt disappoint.
The New York Times hailed the milestone in research, while The New York Post cried BABE NEW WORLD and described an amazing and slightly terrifying breakthrough. A headline on Vox declared simply, This Is Huge.
Even actor Ashton Kutcher tweeted enthusiastically about the scientific breakthrough, writing: Scientists successfully used CRISPR to fix a mutation that causes disease. This is why I wanted to be a geneticist!
The tweet ignited among his followers the same range of responses that are always so keenly tied to the issue of changing human genes, from hope that devastating conditions such as muscular dystrophy will be eradicated, to fear about the unknown consequences of playing God.
Dr. Timothy Caulfield, a Canada Research Chair in Health Law and Policy and professor at the University of Alberta, says the polarized and dramatic response he has seen in recent days reminds him of early reaction to stem-cell science, where, he says, It was either going to be cloned armies, or we were going to eradicate all disease.
In fact, neither has turned out to be the case, and so it may be with gene editing as well.
We need to be cautious not to hype the benefits and be cautious not to hype the ethical concerns, he says. There are real issues on both sides of the debate but lets make sure our discourse is evidence-formed.
He described the new research as a genuinely exciting area, and said the potential of CRISPR which is used not only in human genetics, but also has potentially revolutionary applications for agriculture, animals, plants and food has introduced both exciting possibilities and reasons for deep policy reflection.
Erika Kleiderman, a lawyer and academic whose work focuses on gene-editing technologies, stem-cell research and regenerative medicine at the Centre of Genomics and Policy at McGill University, says the Oregon teams research is exciting because it confirms the ability of CRISPR technology to repair genetic mutations, and establishes the basic safety of the technique in a research context. And while she said people often go straight to thinking about the potential for manipulating genes to create so-called designer babies, a concept that is cool but also quite frightening, the medical implications could be equally staggering, and are far more likely.
For example, something like Huntington disease, she says. Being able to prevent that or treat that one day, in my opinion, would be a fantastic leap for our scientific knowledge and medical advancement. That being said, people will raise the eugenics argument. Is that a possibility? Yes. Are we close to that? I dont think so.
Canada has strict laws around genetic modification and editing, and altering genes in a way that could be passed on to future generations is a criminal offence under the Assisted Human Reproduction Act, punishable with fines up to $500,000 or 10 years in prison.
But as the technology takes a large step forward, Ms. Kleiderman and Dr. Caulfield and are among a group of Canadian scientists and academics calling for less regulation around genetic science and research in Canada, not more.
Both were involved in the creation of an editorial published in the journal Regenerative Medicine in January calling for new consideration of the issues and ethics involved in gene editing, and a revision of Canadian legal policy.
A criminal ban is a suboptimal policy tool for science as it is inflexible, stifles public debate, and hinders responsiveness to the evolving nature of science and societal attitudes, the editorial read. It was signed by seven other experts and ethicists, and came out of a think tank on the future of human gene editing in Canada held at McGill last summer.
Dr. Caulfield says legal prohibition of certain genetic research doesnt make sense when we dont yet know or understand where the science is going, or what the benefits or harms could be. Instead, he says he believes in regulation in problematic areas, while allowing for studies and trials. He says that some of the slippery slope scenarios people fear such as using genetic modification for human enhancement and to achieve superficial traits such as height remain distant possibilities given the complexity of the science.
That is not to say there are not risks or issues to be addressed as the technology continues to evolve. Ms. Kleiderman says that includes consideration of the potential risk to future generations, the safety of the technology and other irrevocable, if unintended, consequences, although she says those risks are not unique to gene modification but true of all technologies.
When it comes to CRISPR, one of the areas it would be most beneficial is with the treatment of prevention of disease which I think most people would be in agreement with, she says. Of course, we need to be mindful of doing not-so-positive things with it, like going down the enhancement route.
She said other potential issues, such as the preservation of human diversity and individuality, the welfare of children born from this technology and the potential for creating new forms of inequality, discrimination or societal conflict, all require significant consideration and research.
There is time. Although the technology is moving quickly, there is still a long way before gene editing is used in clinical human trials. Even after that, Dr. Virani says for the foreseeable future the technology will most likely be used by a small group of people in specific scenarios related to the prevention of serious genetic disease.
Im not saying we shouldnt be concerned about those potential issues, but sometimes we make that leap too quickly, she said. We dont necessarily [think] that the most likely scenario is that couples will use this technology on a very limited basis if they know their child may potentially have a devastating genetic condition. Thats not something that suddenly everyone is going to start to do. I think theres sometimes that leap to, Oh, we can create designer babies, but I think were very much in the lessening-burden-of-disease phase rather than the designer-baby phase, though thats where peoples minds go.
Dr. Virani said one of her own concerns is the possibility of off-target effects, where changing a gene unexpectedly alters something else in the genome. Other concerns are more social reality than science fiction, including that the technology and the ability to prevent disease may only be available to those who can pay for it. Eradicating a horrible disease is one thing. Eradicating it only for families who can afford it is another.
So is it going to look like just the wealthy are going to be able to afford this type of technology? she asks. Thats very problematic in my eyes from an ethics point of view, and thinking about fairness in society. If only poor people get Huntington disease, then the lobby to support Huntington disease research is greatly diminished. Its kind of like a two-fold negative effect.
On Thursday, the American Journal of Human Genetics ran a policy statement signed by 11 organizations from around the world, including the Canadian Association of Genetic Counsellors, urging a cautious but pro-active approach as the science moves forward. The statement includes an agreement that gene editing should not yet be performed in embryos carried on to human pregnancy. (The embryos used in the Oregon research were created only for the research, and were not developed further.) It also outlines a number of criteria that should be met before clinical trials take place, and supports public funding for the research. The U.S. government does not allow federal funding for genetic research on embryos. The Oregon research was funded by the university.
We dont want it to go speeding ahead, said Kelly Ormond, the lead author of the policy statement and a genetics professor at Stanford University in California. We want people to be very transparent about whats happening and we want things to undergo good ethics review, and for society to actually be engaged in these dialogues now while this research is just starting to happen.
She said she believes its important to be pro-active in talking and thinking about the issues related to the technology, and starting a broader conversation of how gene editing should and will be used.
We can all agree that that world [of eugenics and designer babies] doesnt feel very comfortable, and I think most of us dont want to go there, she said. So we need to find ways to prevent that from happening.
Follow Jana G. Pruden on Twitter: @jana_pruden
- SCARY GHOST ENCOUNTER! (The Hidden) - Video [Last Updated On: September 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 7th, 2012]
- Human Genetics and Genomics: The Science for the 21st Century - Video [Last Updated On: September 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 7th, 2012]
- DNA Research - 07-09-2012 - Video [Last Updated On: September 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 7th, 2012]
- Replying to Equestions on Junk DNA - Video [Last Updated On: September 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 7th, 2012]
- 2013 Rosalind Franklin Young Investigator Awards Announced [Last Updated On: September 8th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 8th, 2012]
- Jackson Lab CEO Leads From Heart [Last Updated On: September 28th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 28th, 2012]
- Love of science lifts Hobe Sound teen to genetics conference in Germany [Last Updated On: September 30th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 30th, 2012]
- Nobel Laureates and Experts Gather to Discuss Genetics and Society [Last Updated On: September 30th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 30th, 2012]
- Seattle Genetics and Millennium Complete Enrollment in Phase III AETHERA Trial of ADCETRIS® for Post-Transplant ... [Last Updated On: September 30th, 2012] [Originally Added On: September 30th, 2012]
- GENETICS Journal Highlights for October 2012 [Last Updated On: October 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 2nd, 2012]
- Myriad Genetics Sponsors Cancer Awareness Initiatives in Support of National Hereditary Breast and Ovarian Cancer Week [Last Updated On: October 3rd, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 3rd, 2012]
- Study Says Genetics Of Intelligence Remains A Riddle, For Now [Last Updated On: October 3rd, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 3rd, 2012]
- ORF Genetics to Offer endotoxin- and Animal-free FGFb and mLIF for Stem Cell Research [Last Updated On: October 4th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 4th, 2012]
- Research and Markets: Human Genes and Genomes. Science, Health, Society Provides Students and Professionals Alike With ... [Last Updated On: October 5th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 5th, 2012]
- Mosquito genetics may offer clues to control malaria, researchers say [Last Updated On: October 5th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 5th, 2012]
- Delphi Genetics Grants Merck License for the Use of the StabyExpress™ System [Last Updated On: October 8th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 8th, 2012]
- This Week in PNAS [Last Updated On: October 10th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 10th, 2012]
- Outsmarting breast cancer [Last Updated On: October 10th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 10th, 2012]
- Economics and genetics meet in uneasy union [Last Updated On: October 10th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 10th, 2012]
- Nurture trumps nature in study of oral bacteria in human twins, study finds [Last Updated On: October 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 12th, 2012]
- Nurture trumps nature in study of oral bacteria in human twins, says CU study [Last Updated On: October 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 12th, 2012]
- Claim That Links Economic Success and Genetic Diversity Draws Criticism [Last Updated On: October 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 12th, 2012]
- Master-builder of the Human Genetics Unit [Last Updated On: October 15th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 15th, 2012]
- Genetics Society of America announces 2013 award recipients [Last Updated On: October 15th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 15th, 2012]
- Myriad Genetics to Announce First Fiscal Quarter 2013 Results on Monday, November 5, 2012 [Last Updated On: October 15th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 15th, 2012]
- Petes Wins Lifetime Achievement Award in Genetics [Last Updated On: October 16th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 16th, 2012]
- 23andMe Names Christine Castro, Neil Rothstein and Jonathan Ward to Leadership Positions [Last Updated On: October 16th, 2012] [Originally Added On: October 16th, 2012]
- Privately owned genetic databases may hinder diagnosis and bar the way to the arrival of personalized medicine [Last Updated On: November 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 2nd, 2012]
- Neil Risch - Wiki Article - Video [Last Updated On: November 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 2nd, 2012]
- GHOST DANCE (The Hidden) - Video [Last Updated On: November 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 2nd, 2012]
- SCARY GAME - "The Hidden" With Mr.Mitch361, Charlie, and ChildDolphin - Video [Last Updated On: November 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 2nd, 2012]
- International Academy of Cardiology: Neil Bowles, Ph.D.: GENETIC CAUSES OF CONGENITAL HEART DEFECTS - Video [Last Updated On: November 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 2nd, 2012]
- The Best Of: "The Hidden" - Video [Last Updated On: November 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 2nd, 2012]
- MEAT SHIELD (The Hidden) - Video [Last Updated On: November 4th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 4th, 2012]
- The 10000 Year Explosion: How Civilization Accelerated Human Evolution - , Henry Harpending - Video [Last Updated On: November 4th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 4th, 2012]
- Humans, chimpanzees and monkeys share DNA but not gene regulatory mechanisms [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Surprising findings from NHLBI Exome Sequencing Project reported [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- New method helps link genomic variation to protein production [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Ariosa Diagnostics to Present Clinical Data on the Harmony™ Prenatal Test at American Society of Human Genetics Annual ... [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- ALEX JONES Talks To DAVID ICKE: Human Genetics, Election FRAUD [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- David Icke Exposes ROYAL PAEDOPHILES - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Alex Jones - David Icke: Human Genetics, The Religion Of Death - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- David Icke - Infowars Election Coverage 2012 - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- David Icke: Human Genetics, The Religion of Death - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Evening with the UC Davis Genome Center - Oct 6, 2012 - David Segal - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- The Hidden - (Blood For The Blood God, I Must Feed) - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- GHOST ISSUES (The Hidden) - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- The Hidden - (Fart Grenades And Friendly Fire) - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- GHOST ISLAND (The Hidden) - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Growth Hormone - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Social Anthropology And Human Origins - Alan Barnard - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Protein Structural Biology In Biomedical Research. Advances In Molecular And Cell Biology, Volume 22 - Video [Last Updated On: November 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 7th, 2012]
- Exome sequencing: Potential diagnostic assay for unexplained intellectual disability [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Unexplained intellectual disability explained by state-of-the-art genetic analysis [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- DNA variants explain over 10 percent of inherited genetic risk for heart disease [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Novel type 2 diabetes genetic study involves 5 major ancestry groups [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Significant relationship between mortality and telomere length discovered [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Alex Jones on David Icke 2001 - The Turd - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- David Icke Human Genetics [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- BLINDNESS (The Hidden) - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Human Genetics, The Religion of Death : David Icke - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Alex Jones Show - David Icke: Human Genetics, Paedophile Gov., The Religion of Death - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Human Genetics - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- DAVID ICKE: Human Genetics, The Religion of Death (11/6/2012) - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Human Genetics: The Basics - Ricki Lewis - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- The Hidden - (Meat Shields Everywhere, Face Of Protection) - Video [Last Updated On: November 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 9th, 2012]
- Leading Genomic Services Company and Its Partners Raise More Than $150,000 in Support of Pediatric Genetics Research [Last Updated On: November 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 11th, 2012]
- Verinata Health Announces New Findings At The American Society Of Human Genetics [Last Updated On: November 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 11th, 2012]
- DAVID ICKE: Human Genetics, The Religion of Death! ALEX JONES [INFOWARS Nightly News] - Video [Last Updated On: November 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 11th, 2012]
- ALEX-JONES-Talks-To-DAVID-ICKE--Human-Genetics,-Election-FRAUD-n-The-Religion-Of-DEATH - Video [Last Updated On: November 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 11th, 2012]
- Illumina Bioninformatics Overview at ASHG 2012 - Video [Last Updated On: November 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 11th, 2012]
- The Hidden - Fun With No Silence [Last Updated On: November 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 11th, 2012]
- David Icke - Human Genetics, The Religion of Death [11/06/2012] - Video [Last Updated On: November 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 11th, 2012]
- Genetics Center takes part in global meet [Last Updated On: November 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 12th, 2012]
- Half Life 2 Mods: The Hidden | Part 4 | TO WIN, OR NOT TO WIN! - Video [Last Updated On: November 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 12th, 2012]
- US-X - Video [Last Updated On: November 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 12th, 2012]
- Personalized Medicine From Genomics and Bioinformatics Highlighted at UCSF Genetics Symposium [Last Updated On: November 14th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 14th, 2012]
- News in Brief: Highlights from the American Society of Human Genetics annual meeting [Last Updated On: November 14th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 14th, 2012]
- Star Visitors - Dr. Richard Boylan - Coast to Coast AM Classic - Video [Last Updated On: November 14th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 14th, 2012]
- Protein Structural Biology In Biomedical Research, Part A - C. Woodward - Video [Last Updated On: November 14th, 2012] [Originally Added On: November 14th, 2012]