The Left has long lost this debate, but they keep trying to relitigate it on the campaign stump. The Second Amendment grants the individual right to keep and bear arms. That was the landmark D.C. vs. Hellerdecision, though it applied only to federal enclaves. The McDonald v. Chicago decision extended this right to the states proper. But the Left is obsessed with the militia portion of the amendment: A well-regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed
The Atlantic has a good piece about this whole debate, including an analysis of the opinions from the late Justices Antonin Scalia and John Paul Stevens on Heller. The publication explained that they used two databases Corpus of the Founding Era American English (COFEA) which has 140 million words from documents between 1760-1799 and Corpus of Early Modern English, a massive text bank based on one-billion words British English from 1475 and 1800, to analyze their opinions. To no ones surprise, Scalias majority opinion was more grounded in historical fact than Stevens, though both had inaccuracies. Still, even in the afterlife, Scalia is still right for the most part (via The Atlantic):
Scalia concluded that the phrase bear arms unequivocally carried a military meaning only when followed by the preposition against. The Second Amendment does not use the word against. Therefore, Scalia reasoned, the phrase bear arms, by itself, referred to an individual right. To test this claim, we combed through COFEA for a specific pattern, locating documents in which bear and arms (and their variants) appear within six words of each other. Doing so, we were able to find documents with grammatical constructions such as the arms were borne. In roughly 90 percent of our data set, the phrase bear arms had a militia-related meaning, which strongly implies that bear arms was generally used to refer to collective military activity, not individual use. (Whether these results show that the Second Amendment language precludes an individual right is a more complicated question.)
Further, we found that bear arms often took on a military meaning without being followed by against. Thus, the word against was sufficient, but not necessary, to give the phrase bear arms a militia-related meaning. Scalia was wrong on this particular claim.
Next, we turn to Justice Stevenss dissent. He wrote that the Second Amendment protected a right to have and use firearms only in the context of serving in a state militia. Stevens appears to have determinedthough his exact conclusion is somewhat unclearthat the phrase keep and bear arms was a unitary term of art. Such single linguistic units, called binomials or multinomials, are common in legal writing. Think of cease and desist or lock, stock, and barrel. As a result, Stevens concluded, there was no need to consider whether keep arms had a different meaning from bear arms. Therefore, he had no reason to determine whether keep arms, by itself, could refer to an individual right.
Was Stevenss linguistic intuition correct? No.
[]
Based on these findings, we are more convinced by Scalias majority opinion than Stevenss dissent, even though they both made errors in their analysis. Furthermore, linguistic analysis formed only a small part of Scalias originalist opus. And the bulk of that historical analysis, based on the history of the common-law right to own a firearm, is undisturbed by our new findings.
Oh, and as for the militia aspect of all of this, well, it looks like the Second Amendment was written in a way to show that gun ownership was applicable to the military, or militia at the time, and individual use. The Washington Free Beacons Stephen Gutowski noted this part of the article as well:
So, yeahthis really hasnt been a debate since 2008, when Heller was decided, but keep hitting against that wall, liberal America.
More:
Debate is Over Concerning This Part of the Second Amendment? - Townhall
- Alan Keyes on the Second Amendment and gun rights [Last Updated On: April 2nd, 2011] [Originally Added On: April 2nd, 2011]
- Obama And The Second Amendment [Last Updated On: April 2nd, 2011] [Originally Added On: April 2nd, 2011]
- Suzanna Gratia-Hupp Second Amendment [Last Updated On: May 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: May 20th, 2011]
- Attack of the Second Amendment [Last Updated On: May 21st, 2011] [Originally Added On: May 21st, 2011]
- The Second Amendment died in New Orleans [Last Updated On: May 21st, 2011] [Originally Added On: May 21st, 2011]
- Suzanna Gratia-Hupp What the Second Amendment is REALLY For [Last Updated On: May 24th, 2011] [Originally Added On: May 24th, 2011]
- The Alex Jones Show - LIVE - June 24th Second Amendment Special [Last Updated On: May 30th, 2011] [Originally Added On: May 30th, 2011]
- SA@TAC - Second Amendment Remedies [Last Updated On: June 1st, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 1st, 2011]
- You Choose '08 Spotlight: Ron Paul on the Second Amendment [Last Updated On: June 2nd, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 2nd, 2011]
- IGOLD, Guns, Second Amendment Rights in Illinois and the Madigans [Last Updated On: June 3rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 3rd, 2011]
- Gun Law (Second Amendment) [Last Updated On: June 11th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 11th, 2011]
- Ron Paul on the Second Amendment (feat. Rachel) [Last Updated On: June 15th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 15th, 2011]
- "The Sing-Along Second Amendment" by Roy Zimmerman [Last Updated On: June 15th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 15th, 2011]
- Herman Cain on Second Amendment and Abortion [Last Updated On: June 26th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 26th, 2011]
- Second Amendment Legislative Update with Larry Pratt of Gun Owners of America [Last Updated On: June 29th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 29th, 2011]
- Alan Gottlieb w/the Second Amendment Foundation: Guns Save Lives Campaign - Las Vegas [Last Updated On: June 30th, 2011] [Originally Added On: June 30th, 2011]
- Bloomberg's Anti Gun Ad Suggests Second Amendment Enables Terrorists [Last Updated On: July 1st, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 1st, 2011]
- Gamer Walkthrough: Just Cause 2 - A Second Amendment [Last Updated On: July 1st, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 1st, 2011]
- WNY Truthers Obama Administration Caught Running False Flag Against Second Amendment [Last Updated On: July 4th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 4th, 2011]
- Dr. Suzanna Hupp Explains The Second Amendment [Last Updated On: July 4th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 4th, 2011]
- Re: Let's Get Real about the Second Amendment [Last Updated On: July 12th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 12th, 2011]
- On the Rights and Privileges of the Second Amendment [Last Updated On: July 12th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 12th, 2011]
- Second Annual Knife Rights Sharper Future Award, Sandy Froman [Last Updated On: July 12th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 12th, 2011]
- Obama Administration Caught Running False Flag Against Second Amendment [Last Updated On: July 13th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 13th, 2011]
- Citizens Arming Against Flash Mobs [Last Updated On: July 14th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 14th, 2011]
- Sharron Angle's "Second Amendment Remedies" Statement Is NOT Rhetoric! [Last Updated On: July 15th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 15th, 2011]
- Celebrate! Second Amendment Saturday [Last Updated On: July 17th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 17th, 2011]
- Gibbs Passes Amendment to Protect Second Amendment Rights [Last Updated On: July 19th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 19th, 2011]
- Sen. Jerry Moran: Second Amendment rights not negotiable [Last Updated On: July 29th, 2011] [Originally Added On: July 29th, 2011]
- Second Amendment and My 20 Second Video Intro [Last Updated On: August 2nd, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 2nd, 2011]
- Super Congress To Target Second Amendment.avi [Last Updated On: August 10th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 10th, 2011]
- Tribute to the Second Amendment [Last Updated On: August 20th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 20th, 2011]
- what the second amendment means to me. [Last Updated On: August 23rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 23rd, 2011]
- Patriot Pastor explains the Second Amendment [Last Updated On: August 26th, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 26th, 2011]
- Exercising My Second Amendment Right [Last Updated On: August 31st, 2011] [Originally Added On: August 31st, 2011]
- Second Amendment Range Pack Review [Last Updated On: September 3rd, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 3rd, 2011]
- The Second Amendment-Hero or Villain? [Last Updated On: September 4th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 4th, 2011]
- Just Cause 2 the reapers stronghold takeover A Second Amendment [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2011]
- Infowars Special Report With Sheriff Richard Mack: Obama's Stealth Attack on The 2nd Amendment 4/4 [Last Updated On: September 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 5th, 2011]
- 57 Senators Sign Letter Telling To Protect Second Amendment Rights From United Nations [Last Updated On: September 7th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 7th, 2011]
- Infowars Special Report With Sheriff Richard Mack: Obama's Stealth Attack on The 2nd Amendment 1/4 [Last Updated On: September 9th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 9th, 2011]
- Liberal Mayors Are Freaking Out 'The Second Amendment' [Last Updated On: September 17th, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 17th, 2011]
- The Second Amendment Will Not Be Violated! [Last Updated On: September 21st, 2011] [Originally Added On: September 21st, 2011]
- Cooking Up A Collective Right: How a Mythical Monster Nearly Swallowed the Second Amendment Whole [Last Updated On: October 2nd, 2011] [Originally Added On: October 2nd, 2011]
- Marijuana Activist Debates Former ATF Head on Second Amendment [Last Updated On: October 9th, 2011] [Originally Added On: October 9th, 2011]
- Infowars Special Report With Sheriff Richard Mack: Obama's Stealth Attack on The 2nd Amendment 2/4 [Last Updated On: October 12th, 2011] [Originally Added On: October 12th, 2011]
- Where does your candidate stand on the Second Amendment? - Video [Last Updated On: October 19th, 2011] [Originally Added On: October 19th, 2011]
- Second Amendment Activist Nikki Goeser and Author John Lott - Video [Last Updated On: October 24th, 2011] [Originally Added On: October 24th, 2011]
- Sen. Richard Burr on the Veterans Second Amendment Protection Act - Video [Last Updated On: November 6th, 2011] [Originally Added On: November 6th, 2011]
- Issa Stands Up for Second Amendment Rights on Real Time with Bill Maher - Video [Last Updated On: November 16th, 2011] [Originally Added On: November 16th, 2011]
- Just cause 2 Second Amendment Walkthrough - Video [Last Updated On: November 16th, 2011] [Originally Added On: November 16th, 2011]
- Kinzinger Supports Legislation to Promote Americans' Second Amendment Right - Video [Last Updated On: November 19th, 2011] [Originally Added On: November 19th, 2011]
- Second Amendment - Our Safety Our Duty - Video [Last Updated On: December 1st, 2011] [Originally Added On: December 1st, 2011]
- Second Amendment Rights at Occupy Phoenix 15-10-2011 - Video [Last Updated On: December 5th, 2011] [Originally Added On: December 5th, 2011]
- Lt. Col. Allen B. West speaks on Second Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: December 7th, 2011] [Originally Added On: December 7th, 2011]
- Michael Savage on the Second Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: December 17th, 2011] [Originally Added On: December 17th, 2011]
- Darrell Issa on Fast [Last Updated On: January 1st, 2012] [Originally Added On: January 1st, 2012]
- A Discussion on Being a Pro-Second-Amendment Social Liberal - Video [Last Updated On: January 2nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: January 2nd, 2012]
- Mr. Alan Gura on Current Second Amendment Litigation - Video [Last Updated On: January 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: January 7th, 2012]
- Second Amendment; A Political Right; Historic Context; Not about Hunting! - Newt Gingrich - Video [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2012] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2012]
- NEW JERSEY PAYS CASH TO TRASH SECOND AMENDMENT - Alex Jones Infowars Nightly News 2012-01-09 - Video [Last Updated On: January 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: January 12th, 2012]
- Second Amendment fan says gun bills go too far [Last Updated On: February 6th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 6th, 2012]
- Tea Party hosts head of Gun Owners of California [Last Updated On: February 6th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 6th, 2012]
- Second Amendment Paranoia - Video [Last Updated On: February 6th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 6th, 2012]
- Second Amendment ~ "Wotan Rains On A Plutocrat Parade" (David E. Williams cover) - Video [Last Updated On: February 6th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 6th, 2012]
- What is the second amendment? - Video [Last Updated On: February 6th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 6th, 2012]
- Biggest Factor in Gun Rights, Congress, Not Courts [Last Updated On: February 6th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 6th, 2012]
- Judge squelches bid to overturn Illinois gun law [Last Updated On: February 7th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 7th, 2012]
- A VIEW ON THE SECOND AMENDMENT - Video [Last Updated On: February 8th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 8th, 2012]
- Dr. Suzanna Gratia Hupp on The Second Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: February 9th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 9th, 2012]
- Second Amendment University - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2012]
- The politics of gunplay [Last Updated On: February 13th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 13th, 2012]
- Gun advocates want ability to bring guns to work parking lots [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2012]
- Breyer's Robbery Illustrates Why RKBA So Important Everywhere [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2012]
- House committee adopts 2nd Amendment language [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2012]
- Sneaky White House Budget Provisions Undermine the Second Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: February 19th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 19th, 2012]
- Barack Obama, "Greatest Gun Salesman in America" [Last Updated On: February 22nd, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 22nd, 2012]
- Open carry advocates battle Upland [Last Updated On: February 23rd, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 23rd, 2012]
- Tenn. lawmakers debate parking lot gun bill [Last Updated On: February 24th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 24th, 2012]
- SAF Condemns Texas Law Prof's Claim that OH School Shooting is 'Exercise of 2A' [Last Updated On: February 29th, 2012] [Originally Added On: February 29th, 2012]