Putins puppets who speak of genocide calmly and coolly – The Hill

Its easy to forget that Vladimir Putin isnt the only genocidaire in Russia. Although the recently deceased Vladimir Zhirinovsky made a career of expressing outrageously candid remarks about dropping nuclear weapons on Russias neighbors and the West, there are, alas, many more bloodthirsty madmen in Putins crumbling realm.

One of the most distinguished members of this club is Pavel Gubarev, a leading pro-Russia separatist in the Donbas. In a recent video statement about Russias plans for Ukrainians, he intoned: They are Russian people who are possessed by the devil. We arent coming to kill them, but we want to convince them. But if you dont want to be convinced by us, then well kill you. Well kill as many as is necessary: 1 million, 5 million, or exterminate all of you. Until you understand that you are possessed and need to be cured.

Like Putin, Gubarev directs most of his venom at Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky: And the person who is most possessed is that Zelensky. He is the devils spawn. He is Hitler 2.0 with his rabid nationalism and his rabid Russophobia .

Strong stuff, this and crazy, too. Gubarev really uses the Russian words for kill (ubit) and exterminate (istrebit). Hes not speaking metaphorically. Hes evidently dead serious that Ukrainians must be physically destroyed. And he believes that Zelensky, like Adolf Hitler, must be wiped off the face of the earth. No matter that Zelensky is Jewish, that his family survived the Holocaust, and that his policies are both liberal and democratic.

But liberalism apparently is what rubs Gubarev the wrong way. As he goes on to state, Ukrainians are Satanists, as well as anti-systemic liberal consumers and stupid people who cant figure out whats going on.

If you think none of this makes any sense, youre not alone. But Gubarevs unhinged ravings are all the scarier because they typify the historical, political and cultural nonsense that passes for Russian official discourse in the age of Putin. Former Russian president and prime minister, Dmitry Medvedev, also talks as if logic and veracity had no place in human speech. And Putins propagandists Vladimir Solovyov, Olga Skabeyeva and Margarita Symonyan can make Joseph Goebbels look and sound like a rational philosopher.

Naturally, the scariest part of Gubarevs statement is the casual way in which he informs Ukrainians that, if they dont change their identity, they will be exterminated. Gubarev should be frothing at the mouth; he should be turning red; his veins should be throbbing. Instead, he speaks of genocide calmly and coolly, as if he were delivering a weather report. Evidently, genocidal thinking has been internalized and normalized and not just by him. Its nothing unusual. Its just business as usual.

Which is why Gubarev counts off the millions one, five, or more as if he were engaging in a simple monetary transaction. Ukrainian have been reduced to numbers in his mind. They have lost their humanity. The only way they can reclaim it is by abandoning their Satanic liberalism and reidentifying themselves as Russians as Gubarevs and Putins and Medvedevs. But since the war has conclusively demonstrated that Ukrainians are unwilling to give up their language, culture, history and identity, genocide is Gubarevs and Putins, and Medvedevs, and Mother Russias only possible response. And genocide is precisely what Russia has been pursuing since Feb. 24, 2022.

The most recent genocidal action took place on Oct. 10, when Russia dropped about 100 missiles and drones on mostly civilian targets, killing at least 14. The shelling continues, and the targets have been and still are overwhelmingly civilian; five to 10 Ukrainians die, on average, per day. Small wonder that the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe voted to declare the Russian Federation a terrorist regime.

There is no talking to Gubarev, and there is no talking to Putin, Medvedev and their ilk. Given the right incentive, they might be willing to stop just short of killing all Ukrainians, but no more. Genocidaires dont negotiate genocide, after all.

More importantly, the Gubarevs, Putins and Medvedevs dont negotiate period. The persistent entreaties by some Western policymakers and analysts that Zelensky and Putin should please sit down and figure things out are, alas, dangerously nave, because they presuppose that Russias answer to Germanys Hitler actually wants to talk about anything short of Ukraines extermination. As history has shown, genocidaires stop only when theyve completed their bloody work or are stopped.

Alexander J. Motyl is a professor of political science at Rutgers University-Newark. A specialist on Ukraine, Russia and the USSR, and on nationalism, revolutions, empires and theory, he is the author of 10 books of nonfiction, as well as Imperial Ends: The Decay, Collapse, and Revival of Empires and Why Empires Reemerge: Imperial Collapse and Imperial Revival in Comparative Perspective.

Read the original post:

Putins puppets who speak of genocide calmly and coolly - The Hill