DYER: Progress and decline of populism Red Deer Advocate – Red Deer Advocate

The reports about Luiz Incio Lula da Silvas impending comeback as Brazilian president verged on the ecstatic in the week before last Sundays vote. He was after all, fourteen points ahead of his populist rival, incumbent president Jair Bolsonaro, in the last opinion poll before the vote.

But the polls were wrong. Lula got a respectable 48% of the vote, but he was only five points ahead of Bolsonaro at 43%, and in Brazilian politics the candidates in the lead often fall behind in the second round. The long anticipated global decline and fall of the hard-right populist movement has been at least postponed.

This is particularly relevant to the United States, where Donald Trump constantly praises Bolsonaro as Tropical Trump. Lula is to the left of Joe Biden, but both men are ageing stalwarts of the centre-left who have made political comebacks but already feel a little bit like yesterdays news.

What has already happened in this first-round presidential election in Brazil is a triumph of the hard right in the simultaneous Congressional elections that would make another Lula presidency very difficult. Joe Biden may face similar difficulties after next months US mid-term Congressional elections, if polling predictions are right..

Both men have essentially promised a return to the sensible, moderate centre-left politics of yore, and that doesnt seem to be setting hearts aflame in either country. To be fair, however, Lula bears an additional handicap: a criminal conviction.

I spent a whole day with Lula long ago in So Paulos car-making suburb of So Bernardo do Campo, when he was genuinely a horny-handed son of toil and a trade union organiser. He certainly seemed to be an honest man then, even a poor man, but he was freed from jail only last year after serving part of a twelve-year sentence for corruption in office.

It wasnt a lot of money and the charges may have been trumped up: the judge who brought them and sent Lula to jail, Sergio Moro, was later given a post in Bolsonaros government as justice minister. On the other hand, Lula was not exonerated last year; he was released because of procedural irregularities in the case. He could even face trial again.

So there is no clear evidence that the populist wave is subsiding. Bolsonaro could get a second term, Trump could come back in the United States, Modi is not losing his grip in India. Orbn won a landslide re-election victory in Hungary last month, a hard-right coalition won last months election in Italy, Boris Johnson might even make a comeback in the UK.

The driving force in this populist wave is a thinly disguised alliance between a very rich elite and the resentful, downwardly-mobile parts of the old middle and working classes. The emotional cement that holds it together involves a strong dose of extreme religion, deep social conservatism (e.g. homophobia), ultra-nationalism, and anti-immigrant sentiment.

Populism will be with us for some time yet, and it may even spread a bit. Turkeys President Recep Tayyip Erdoan may cover the rest of the distance to full populism as the countrys economic problems worsen, and France might have gone full populist last year if the French hard-right parties had managed to cooperate. But thats only half the story.

The other side is parties of the democratic left that are winning power in almost all the rest of Latin America Alberto Fernndez in Argentina (2019), Luis Arce in Bolivia (2020), Pedro Castillo in Peru and Gabriel Boric in Chile (2021), Xiomara Castro in Honduras (2022), and most recently Gustavo Petro in Columbia.

Its also noteworthy that only three of the European Unions 27 members currently have populist governments: Italy, Poland and Hungary. Moreover, the new Italian coalition may not last long, and Polands populism is for domestic affairs only: Polish populists are not admirers of Vladimir Putin.

In Asia and Africa, the populist formula has not been deployed in politics at all except in India. As a recently refurbished political technique it is having some successes, but every new political technique loses its freshness after a while.

And neither Lula nor Biden has lost their next elections yet.

Gwynne Dyers new book is The Shortest History of War.

The rest is here:

DYER: Progress and decline of populism Red Deer Advocate - Red Deer Advocate