The Prometheus League
Breaking News and Updates
- Abolition Of Work
- Ai
- Alt-right
- Alternative Medicine
- Antifa
- Artificial General Intelligence
- Artificial Intelligence
- Artificial Super Intelligence
- Ascension
- Astronomy
- Atheism
- Atheist
- Atlas Shrugged
- Automation
- Ayn Rand
- Bahamas
- Bankruptcy
- Basic Income Guarantee
- Big Tech
- Bitcoin
- Black Lives Matter
- Blackjack
- Boca Chica Texas
- Brexit
- Caribbean
- Casino
- Casino Affiliate
- Cbd Oil
- Censorship
- Cf
- Chess Engines
- Childfree
- Cloning
- Cloud Computing
- Conscious Evolution
- Corona Virus
- Cosmic Heaven
- Covid-19
- Cryonics
- Cryptocurrency
- Cyberpunk
- Darwinism
- Democrat
- Designer Babies
- DNA
- Donald Trump
- Eczema
- Elon Musk
- Entheogens
- Ethical Egoism
- Eugenic Concepts
- Eugenics
- Euthanasia
- Evolution
- Extropian
- Extropianism
- Extropy
- Fake News
- Federalism
- Federalist
- Fifth Amendment
- Fifth Amendment
- Financial Independence
- First Amendment
- Fiscal Freedom
- Food Supplements
- Fourth Amendment
- Fourth Amendment
- Free Speech
- Freedom
- Freedom of Speech
- Futurism
- Futurist
- Gambling
- Gene Medicine
- Genetic Engineering
- Genome
- Germ Warfare
- Golden Rule
- Government Oppression
- Hedonism
- High Seas
- History
- Hubble Telescope
- Human Genetic Engineering
- Human Genetics
- Human Immortality
- Human Longevity
- Illuminati
- Immortality
- Immortality Medicine
- Intentional Communities
- Jacinda Ardern
- Jitsi
- Jordan Peterson
- Las Vegas
- Liberal
- Libertarian
- Libertarianism
- Liberty
- Life Extension
- Macau
- Marie Byrd Land
- Mars
- Mars Colonization
- Mars Colony
- Memetics
- Micronations
- Mind Uploading
- Minerva Reefs
- Modern Satanism
- Moon Colonization
- Nanotech
- National Vanguard
- NATO
- Neo-eugenics
- Neurohacking
- Neurotechnology
- New Utopia
- New Zealand
- Nihilism
- Nootropics
- NSA
- Oceania
- Offshore
- Olympics
- Online Casino
- Online Gambling
- Pantheism
- Personal Empowerment
- Poker
- Political Correctness
- Politically Incorrect
- Polygamy
- Populism
- Post Human
- Post Humanism
- Posthuman
- Posthumanism
- Private Islands
- Progress
- Proud Boys
- Psoriasis
- Psychedelics
- Putin
- Quantum Computing
- Quantum Physics
- Rationalism
- Republican
- Resource Based Economy
- Robotics
- Rockall
- Ron Paul
- Roulette
- Russia
- Sealand
- Seasteading
- Second Amendment
- Second Amendment
- Seychelles
- Singularitarianism
- Singularity
- Socio-economic Collapse
- Space Exploration
- Space Station
- Space Travel
- Spacex
- Sports Betting
- Sportsbook
- Superintelligence
- Survivalism
- Talmud
- Technology
- Teilhard De Charden
- Terraforming Mars
- The Singularity
- Tms
- Tor Browser
- Trance
- Transhuman
- Transhuman News
- Transhumanism
- Transhumanist
- Transtopian
- Transtopianism
- Ukraine
- Uncategorized
- Vaping
- Victimless Crimes
- Virtual Reality
- Wage Slavery
- War On Drugs
- Waveland
- Ww3
- Yahoo
- Zeitgeist Movement
-
Prometheism
-
Forbidden Fruit
-
The Evolutionary Perspective
Category Archives: Transhuman News
Traffic-related air pollution linked to DNA damage in children – Science Daily
Posted: May 22, 2017 at 3:13 am
Science Daily | Traffic-related air pollution linked to DNA damage in children Science Daily The study adds to previous evidence that air pollution causes oxidative stress, which can damage lipids, proteins, and DNA. Research has suggested that children may have different telomere shortening regulation than adults, which might make them more ... |
Go here to read the rest:
Traffic-related air pollution linked to DNA damage in children - Science Daily
Posted in DNA
Comments Off on Traffic-related air pollution linked to DNA damage in children – Science Daily
Boise State gets federal grant for post-conviction DNA testing, but not on Idaho cases – Idaho Statesman
Posted: at 3:13 am
Idaho Statesman | Boise State gets federal grant for post-conviction DNA testing, but not on Idaho cases Idaho Statesman The Idaho Innocence Project will benefit from a $630,000 U.S. Department of Justice grant to test DNA in possible wrongful-conviction cases. But none of the money can be used on Idaho cases, and the grant had to be given to Boise State University. Why? |
Read the rest here:
Boise State gets federal grant for post-conviction DNA testing, but not on Idaho cases - Idaho Statesman
Posted in DNA
Comments Off on Boise State gets federal grant for post-conviction DNA testing, but not on Idaho cases – Idaho Statesman
DNA kits keeping genealogy in forefront – The Daily Gazette
Posted: at 3:13 am
Reporter Bill Buell looks at his "ethnic makeup percentage" page, indicating his DNA history, provided by Family Tree DNA.
"Pride of ancestry never possessed my soul."
It's an early 20th century line uttered by a wealthy politician looking to gain favor with the working class. I always liked it, and felt as though it summed up the way I felt about my ethnicity. Yet, I was curious. and while I often feigned my disinterest - and some of the time it was genuine -- I never seriously engaged in researching my family tree. Until now.
Like many Americans across the country and peoples throughout the world, digging into the past is becoming something of a hobby for me. Perhaps I'm not as passionate as some, but with the internet putting just about everything at your fingertips, and the recent popularity of DNA kits providing a detailed breakdown of your ethnic makeup, information about the past has never been so easily accessed.
When earlier this year I had the opportunity to provide Family Tree DNA with some saliva free of charge (saving me around $90), I jumped at the chance. I waited for the kit in the mail - a small package with a couple of cotton swabs and some clear tubes - did what I had to do and then sent them off in the mail. Typically it takes about five or six weeks to get the information back to you, and I have to admit I was quite anxious to see what I'm made of.
According to family lore - much of it provided by my older brother - we were mostly German on my mother's side and Welsh, German and Dutch on my father's side. As it turned out the oral history was pretty accurate. When I opened the email from Family Tree DNA that day, I clicked on the link and discovered that I was 95 percent European and 4 percent West Middle Eastern. The European part of me (by the way, I am a blue-eyed blonde) was also broken down into 80 percent West and Central Europe and 15 percent British Isles.
While the results of the DNA kit were interesting but pretty much confirmed what I had already suspected, other people can have a much more dramatic experience.
Albany's Sharon Smith, who was adopted at birth, spent years trying to find her natural birth mother but never succeeded. However, a few months after sending in her DNA kit to Ancestry.com, Smith got an email with a huge surprise. When she opened it up and clicked on "matches," she found a new woman's name with a "relationship range" of "mother-sister."
"I was shocked, I never saw it coming and never thought it was going to happen, but when I opened the email they had found my biological mother," said Smith. "I was very lucky because she just happened to do a DKN kit herself, and we were so closely matched it had to be my mother. I never thought I was going to find her in a million years. I was very lucky."
Smith contacted the woman, who confirmed that she was indeed Smith's birth mother. The two have become close, and last week, Smith had a very special Mother's Day.
"Previous Mother's Days were always about my mom," said Smith, referring to the woman who adopted her. "This year was a very different situation. I am very happy to have a relationship with my birth mom, and I am very thankful she chose the woman she did to be my mom. So, with that being said, I am very blessed that I have had two amazing women who loved me so much to bring me into this world and to raise me to be the woman I am today. So this Mother's Day, I celebrated two special moms. Not many people can say that."
Schenectady's Don Ackerman, a retired social studies teacher in the Niskayuna school district, was also adopted but had little interest in looking for a birth mother. He just wanted to know where he came from.
"I had assumed that I was German, Dutch and English, but when I got my results back the bulk of me, 44 percent, was Irish," said Ackerman, who grew up in Syracuse. "My wife also did it and she was upset because she was also mainly Irish. She always thought she was Dutch. It was fun and interesting to do it, and I discovered I was 12 percent Scandanavian and 10 percent Iberian Peninsula. I also had 1 percent Pacific Islander. But I was an adopted kid, an only child, and I had a wonderful life so it wasn't about finding my mother."
Nancy Curran, a former newspaper columnist and critic for the Gazette and the now-defunct Union Star, has worked in the genealogy field for nearly 30 years now, researching her own past and helping others look into their family tree. The television mini-series, "Roots," raised interest in family genealogy according to Curran, and then the internet and now DNA kits have made the idea of looking into one's past even more compelling.
"I think interest has been steadily growing since the movie, 'Roots,' which came out around the Bicentennial," said Curran. "People were wondering, 'does my family have anything to do with this wonderful experiment we call America.' And then it was the advent of the internet. You used to have to drive to a major library, find some microfilm with an index that would tell you what other microfilm you should be reading. Now you just click away. Increasingly, more and more documents are being digitized. Almost everything is at your fingertips."
Curran has also used the DNA kit - she is 72 percent Scandanavian - but she likes to remind people that the results sometimes don't provide that much information.
"I think my takeaway from the DNA kits is that it is more likely to be confirmation of information you already have," she said. "If you're looking for a relative it's not always going to be dependable. So much of it depends upon whether anybody whose DNA would be helpful to you has actually taken a test. However, sometimes you do get lucky."
Family Tree DNA, Ancestry.com and 23andMe are among the major companies involved in DNA testing these days. It was Bennett Greenspan who founded Family Tree DNA nearly 20 years ago in Houston, Texas.
"I conceived the idea in 1999 and I took my first commercial order in 2000," said Greenspan, who had owned a photographic supply company in the Houston area. "I saw the digitization of an industry I was in, and every time I sold a digital camera I was cannibalizing my own business. I had to do something else and the DNA technology was very interesting to me. People were immediately very enthusiastic about the idea and things just took off."
Business hasn't let up.
"Last year was our best ever," said Bennett, whose parent company, Gene by Gene, does the laboratory work for many of the other companies selling DNA kits. "My guess is that it will continue to grow. The technology is so easy. I can remember when the first cell phone came out and I said, 'I'll never have one of those.' Two years later I had one and now everybody has one. Soon, everyone will know their DNA and people will actually know for sure if they're 20 percent Native American, 30 percent Irish or Jewish, or whatever."
At the Schenectady County Historical Society, librarian/archivist Mike Maloney gets many visitors to the Grems-Doolittle Library looking to fill in their family tree, and many of them have also gone the DNA kit route.
"I think the popularity of genealogy is still increasing due to DNA kits because it adds an extra level of excitement for genealogists as you can pinpoint what part of the world your ancestors came from," said Maloney. "TV shows like 'Finding Your Roots' add the celebrity aspect to genealogy, and our genealogy-focused programs at the historical society always draw a good crowd."
As popular as the kits are, if you're delving into your family history and looking past your ethnicity, the best place to be is in a library with access to a computer, in particular a library with a collection like that of the Schenectady County Historical Society.
"Increased access to records through the internet allow people to do a lot of research from home," said Maloney. "But here we also have wills, yearbooks, naturalization records, church baptisms and other primary sources. You can usually find a few researchers looking to break through genealogy brick walls at our library."
Originally posted here:
DNA kits keeping genealogy in forefront - The Daily Gazette
Posted in DNA
Comments Off on DNA kits keeping genealogy in forefront – The Daily Gazette
Would DNA check after 2015 felony arrest have averted later assault? – Athens NEWS
Posted: at 3:13 am
Since 2011, Ohio law has required that any person charged with a felony must submit to a DNA collection.
But a man now charged in connection with two rapes and one attempted rape in uptown Athens over a 10-year period starting in 2006 managed to avoid DNA collection when he was arrested by the Ohio State Highway Patrol for a felony firearm offense in November 2015.
Thus, Shawn J. Lawson, Jr., 26, was not arrested in connection with the alleged rapes until earlier this month, when a DNA sample was obtained from him after an alleged sexual assault in Lancaster two months earlier.
If law-enforcement had hit on the DNA match for Lawson after the June 2016 alleged rape in Athens, he at least wouldnt have been free to commit the later sexual assault hes been accused of in Lancaster.
Athens County Sheriff Rodney Smith and county Prosecutor Keller Blackburn have now worked out an arrangement where any person arraigned for a felony in Athens County Common Pleas Court will have his or her DNA collected by the Sheriffs Office unless that persons DNA is already on record.
Athens Police had been hunting for what they described as a serial rapist since at least January 2016. They suspected him of being involved in three sexual assaults in uptown Athens between 2006 and 2015. Lawsons grand-jury indictment states that the crimes occurred against three separate victims on June 11, 2006; June 20, 2015; and Dec. 12, 2015 (Lawson was arrested for an OVI/felony firearm charges on Nov. 22, 2015, and indicted in Athens County Common Pleas Court on Dec. 14, 2015).
The sexual assaults all occurred under similar circumstances, police have said, when the college-aged victism were walking home alone from the uptown Athens area early in the morning. Lawson would have been 15 years old at the time of the first incident in June 2006.
In the June 2015 case, Athens Police Lt. Jeff McCall used a technique called touch DNA to collect evidence, where DNA can be obtained from areas on the victims body that a perpetrator touched. The DNA obtained in that case led to a match with the DNA from the both the June 2006 case and the later, December 2015 case, thus launching the search for the alleged serial rapist.
McCall said after Lawsons arrest that police obtained DNA samples from as many as 30 community members voluntarily in their search for the perpetrator.
But when the Ohio State Highway Patrol arrested Lawson in November 2015 in Athens County for OVI (drunk-driving) and a felony charge of having a firearm in a vehicle while driving intoxicated, his DNA was not collected, Prosecutor Blackburn confirmed.
DNA collection for felony offenses occurs at the Southeastern Ohio Regional Jail in Nelsonville, Blackburn said, but in this case from what he understands Lawson was released into the custody of his then-wife without being taken to the jail, and thus his DNA was never collected.
Ohio Revised Code 2901.07 outlines state law with regard to DNA specimen collection procedure.
Subsection (B)(1)(a) states that after July 1, 2011, any person 18 years old or older arrested for a felony offense shall submit to a DNA specimen collection procedure administered by the head of the arresting law-enforcement agency. The head of the arresting law-enforcement agency shall cause the DNA specimen to be collected from the person during the intake process at the jail, community-based correctional facility, detention facility, or law enforcement agency office or station to which the arrested person is taken after the arrest.
The Athens NEWS sent the Ohio State Highway Patrol media contact an email on Friday morning asking why this had not occurred in Lawsons case but had not received a response as of our print deadline on Sunday.
Section (B)(1)(b) of ORC 2901.07 states that if the head of the arresting law-enforcement agency has not administered a DNA specimen collection procedure upon the person arrested for a felony in accordance with division (B)(1)(a) of this section by the time of the arraignment or first appearance of the person, the court shall order the person to appear before the sheriff or chief of police of the county or municipal corporation within 24 hours to submit to a DNA specimen collection procedure administered by the sheriff or chief of police.
Court records for Lawsons felony firearm case do not show the court ordering a DNA collection. This issue likely would not have been raised unless the court had been informed that DNA collection hadnt taken place due to Lawson not undergoing intake at the regional jail.
On Friday, Sheriff Smith said that his office has obtained hundreds of DNA testing kits from the Ohio State Bureau of Criminal Investigation and will now collect DNA specimens from those arraigned on felony charges in Athens County Common Pleas Court as a catch-all, even if they were arrested by some other law-enforcement agency.
He said that his office began doing so last week after having never done so in the past. The office is able to tell whether a person has had DNA collected previously by running his or her fingerprints through the Ohio Law Enforcement Gateway database, Smith said. If he or she has not, the Sheriffs Office will gather a sample, he said.
If its never been done, thats when we do the DNA test, he said. Its needed and its something thats very important and we want to make sure it gets done.
See the original post:
Would DNA check after 2015 felony arrest have averted later assault? - Athens NEWS
Posted in DNA
Comments Off on Would DNA check after 2015 felony arrest have averted later assault? – Athens NEWS
Paris police attack: Man charged over ‘DNA link to gun’ – BBC News
Posted: at 3:13 am
BBC News | Paris police attack: Man charged over 'DNA link to gun' BBC News French police have charged a man with terrorism offences after his DNA was found on the gun used to shoot dead a police officer in Paris last month, judicial sources say. The 23-year-old, who was not named, was not previously known to investigators. |
Originally posted here:
Paris police attack: Man charged over 'DNA link to gun' - BBC News
Posted in DNA
Comments Off on Paris police attack: Man charged over ‘DNA link to gun’ – BBC News
DNA testing backlog figures in departure of state scientist – The Daily Courier
Posted: at 3:13 am
In this 2004 file photo a criminologist for the Arizona Department of Public Safety processes DNA samples at their lab in Phoenix. (Emmanuel Lozano/via AP, File)
PHOENIX (AP) The Arizona Department of Public Safety says a former supervisory forensic scientist failed to test DNA samples in dozens of cases and intentionally hid her caseload backlog.
An audit of the DNA units backlog disclosed the alleged misconduct by Kathy Press, who was demoted and resigned, KPNX-TV reported Thursday.
Press has acknowledged that she was behind but blames it on managers refusal to correct problems.
The lack of timely testing affected at least one criminal case, an alleged 2009 sexual assault in Tempe, in which a police request for further analysis wasnt handled for six years, the station reported.
Press backlog also included cases from Tempe, Glendale, Coolidge, Surprise, Yuma, Tucson and Prescott Valley. The cases included property crimes, sexual assaults and other violent crime.
Maricopa County Attorney Bill Montgomery said the six-year delay in getting DNA results was among factors leading to no prosecution in the Tempe case.
Press denied allowing cases to sit idle to hide incompetence or misconduct. She said she couldnt keep up with a heavy caseload while taking on a leadership role and tried to re-assign cases so they could be completed.
She said the delay in the Tempe case was a true tragedy that was caused by the refusal of leadership within the Department of Public Safety to help fix a backlog they knew existed.
The lapse was discovered by a supervisor after the agency implemented a work-performance accounting and auditing system in 2015.
An internal investigation found that Press hid work files and took steps to conceal her incompetence, the agency said.
The employees lack of professionalism is beyond regrettable, it is reprehensible, the agency stated.
The agency said it has improved accounting processes and has reduced testing backlogs.
Original post:
DNA testing backlog figures in departure of state scientist - The Daily Courier
Posted in DNA
Comments Off on DNA testing backlog figures in departure of state scientist – The Daily Courier
Politically incorrect! Female political leaders of two new novels seem too close – Mid-Day
Posted: at 3:11 am
Prev
The female political leaders of two new novels seem too close to reality. But, would it be fair to pin these books as thinly-veiled biographies?
Sabyn Javeri
A bomb blast, a bullet gone astray, a blow to the head and before you know it, boom! The life has gone out of you. Perhaps you think I didn't try to stop her. I tried to tell her there's danger. Truly, I tried. The General and his men, I said, they will kill you. Why do you think they are letting you do the rally? So they can send you away for good! To a place you can never return from," the opening lines of Pakistani writer Sabyn Javeri's debut novel Nobody Killed Her (HarperCollins) reads.
For those privy to the political turmoil in the neighbouring country over the last decade, the uncanny resemblance of her character Rani Shah - being referred to in these lines - with the fearless Benazir Bhutto can barely go unnoticed. Javeri can't count the number of times she has been asked the question, but any such resemblances she says are purely coincidental.
Anita Sivakumaran
Closer home, Anita Sivakumaran's The Queen (Juggernaut) is stirring a storm for its sharp references to the life of former Tamil Nadu chief minister Jayalalithaa. Her protagonist Kalai Arasi's meteoric rise as a leader of the masses, after her stint as a starlet in Tamil cinema is the first clue. That the publishers are also promoting the novel as one that's "inspired from a true story" is a dead giveaway. But UK-based Sivakumaran would rather that her readers take that call.
If these two recently released novels come across as thinly-veiled biographies of two of South East Asia's most influential politicians of the 2oth century, we probably wouldn't have to wait for their biographies to read about their lives. But, that's also what the authors hope their books don't come to represent.
Inspiration, they claim, should not be misconstrued for reality. "I find that an insult to my imagination. In fact, I feel that shows how limited their [the critics] knowledge of history is," says Javeri, who lives between London and Karachi.
That said, Javeri doesn't deny that her book was inspired by the leadership challenges of Bhutto as a woman. "I really admired Benazir for her unapologetic attitude towards family life. A lot of women feel pressured to choose between motherhood or career, but Bhutto resisted this," Javeri says of the politician.
While her book draws upon Bhutto's assassination as a point of fictional exploration, that is where, she says, the similarity stops. "If one were to read the book objectively, one would find references to all sorts of different female leaders of our times. I found the rise and fall from power of Indira Gandhi and the scandalous rise of the political underdog in Mayawati and Jayalalithaa also very intriguing and I drew upon it heavily when constructing the plot arc," says the writer, whose doctorate research involved studying women who rose to power in the patriarchal world of politics.
Sivakumaran, on the other hand, argues that even if Kalai's character were lifted, it wasn't done with the intent of portraying the politician. Yes, she admits, that Jayalalithaa was what wheeled her in to write this book. Her story definitely makes for an interesting read. "Otherwise I wouldn't have written it," she says.
"But, in terms of character, I cannot claim to know personally, any of the people who've inspired the fictional characters. I did not read characterisations about them by other writers either. I put myself in the events that are a matter of public record, and supplied a fictional consciousness. Fleshing out a character is to do with really seeing/feeling events through this fictional consciousness," she says.
If there is a political statement that Javeri is making through her book, it is one that moves beyond the realm of imagining real-life political figures in fiction. "It's a book that is written by a woman who is neither a journalist nor an insider into the world of politics, like other male Pakistani writers who attempt political fiction," says the writer without dropping any names.
"Why turn to fiction if you are looking for someone's life story? I think you have biographies for that. Why write a novel where you know the entire story line? My book would not be the page-turner it is, if it was an interesting but predictable life story of a famous person," Javeri ends.
Download the new mid-day android app to get updates on all the latest and trending stories on the gohttps://goo.gl/8Xlcvr
See the original post here:
Politically incorrect! Female political leaders of two new novels seem too close - Mid-Day
Posted in Politically Incorrect
Comments Off on Politically incorrect! Female political leaders of two new novels seem too close – Mid-Day
Clint Eastwood: We’re killing ourselves with political correctness – Starts at 60
Posted: at 3:11 am
If youre a fan of actor Clint Eastwood then you would know he isnt afraid of a little bit of controversy and being politically incorrect.
Political correctness is something that Eastwood, like many Baby Boomers, has spoken out against in the past.
This time he brought up the subject while talking about his controversial 1971 film Dirty Harry.
A lot of people thought it was politically incorrect, he told a crowd during a speech at a Cannes Film Festival event.
That was at the beginning of the era that were in now, where everybody thinks everyones politically correct.
Were killing ourselves by doing that. Weve lost our sense of humour.
No doubt there are many over-60s who would agree with what the 86-year-old actor had to say.
Last year he drew plenty of debate when describing todays generation as a pussy generation.
Everybodys walking on eggshells, he said.
We see people accusing people of being racist and all kinds of stuff.
When I grew up, those things werent called racist. Secretly everybodys getting tired of political correctness, kissing up.
Read more:
Clint Eastwood: We're killing ourselves with political correctness - Starts at 60
Posted in Politically Incorrect
Comments Off on Clint Eastwood: We’re killing ourselves with political correctness – Starts at 60
The Censors’ Disappearing Vibrator – New York Times
Posted: at 3:10 am
New York Times | The Censors' Disappearing Vibrator New York Times I discovered later that the second half of this episode featured two segments with celebrity guests that did not survive the Singapore censors' scrutiny: Jane Fonda wielding a vibrator and Asia Kate Dillon discussing her nonbinary gender identity, both ... |
Excerpt from:
The Censors' Disappearing Vibrator - New York Times
Posted in Censorship
Comments Off on The Censors’ Disappearing Vibrator – New York Times
Online Censorship and User Notification: Lessons from Thailand – EFF
Posted: at 3:10 am
For governments interested in suppressing information online, the old methods of direct censorship are getting less and less effective.
Over the past month, the Thai government has made escalating attempts to suppress critical information online. In the last week, faced with an embarrassing video of the Thai King, the government ordered Facebook to geoblock over 300 pages on the platform and even threatened to shut Facebook down in the country. This is on top of last month's announcement that the government had banned any online interaction with three individuals: two academics and one journalist, all three of whom are political exiles and prominent critics of the state. And just today, law enforcement representatives described their efforts to target those who simply viewnot even create or sharecontent critical of the monarchy and the government.
The Thai government has several methods at its own disposal to directly block large volumes of content. It could, as it has in the past, pressure ISPs to block websites. It could also hijack domain name queries, making sites harder to access. So why is it negotiating with Facebook instead of just blocking the offending pages itself? And what are Facebooks responsibilities to users when this happens?
The answer is, in part, HTTPS. When HTTPS encrypts your browsing, it doesnt just protect the contents of the communication between your browser and the websites you visit. It also protects the specific pages on those sites, preventing censors from seeing and blocking anything after the slash in a URL. This means that if a sensitive video of the King shows up on a website, government censors cant identify and block only the pages on which it appears. In an HTTPS world that makes such granularized censorship impossible, the governments only direct censorship option is to block the site entirely.
That might still leave the government with tenable censorship options if critical speech and dissenting activity only happened on certain sites, like devoted blogs or message boards. A government could try to get away with blocking such sites wholesale without disrupting users outside a certain targeted political sphere.
But all sorts of user-generated contentfrom calls to revolution to cat picturesare converging on social media websites like Facebook, which members of every political party use and rely on. This brings us to the second part of the answer as to why the government cant censor like it used to: mixed-use social media sites. When content is both HTTPS-encrypted and on a mixed-use social media site like Facebook, it can be too politically expensive to block the whole site. Instead, the only option left is pressuring Facebook to do targeted blocking at the governments request.
Government requests for targeted blocking happen when something is compliant with Facebooks community guidelines, but not with a countrys domestic law. This comes to a head when social media platforms have large user bases in repressive, censorious statesa dynamic that certainly applies in Thailand, where a military dictatorship shares its capital city with a dense population of Facebook power-users and one of the most Instagrammed locations on earth.
In Thailand, the video of the King in question violated the countrys overbroad lese majeste defamation laws against in any way insulting or criticizing the monarchy. So the Thai government requested that Facebook remove italong with hundreds of other pieces of contenton legal grounds, and made an ultimately empty threat to shut down the platform in Thailand if Facebook did not comply.
Facebook did comply and geoblock over 100 URLs for which it received warrants from the Thai government. This may not be surprising; although the government is likely not going to block Facebook entirely, they still have other ways to go after the company, including threatening any in-country staff. Indeed, Facebook put itself in a vulnerable position when it inexplicably opened a Bangkok office during high political tensions after the 2014 military coup.
If companies like Facebook do comply with government demands to remove content, these decisions must be transparent to their users and the general public. Otherwise, Facebook's compliance transforms its role from a victim of censorship, to a company pressured to act as a government censor. The stakes are high, especially in unstable political environments like Thailand. There, the targets of takedown requests can often be journalists, activists, and dissidents, and requests to take down their content or block their pages often serve as an ominous prelude to further action or targeting.
With that in mind, Facebook and other companies responding to government requests must provide the fullest legally permissible notice to users whenever possible. This means timely, informative notifications, on the record, that give users information like what branch of government requested to take down their content, on what legal grounds, and when the request was made.
Facebook seems to be getting better at this, at least in Thailand. When journalist Andrew MacGregor Marshall had content of his geoblocked in January, he did not receive consistent notice. Worse, the page that his readers in Thailand saw when they tried to access his post implied that the block was an error, not a deliberate act of government-mandated removal.
More recently, however, we have been happy to see evidence of Facebook providing more detailed notices to users, like this notice that exiled dissident Dr. Somsak Jeamteerasakul received and then shared online:
In an ideal world, timely and informative user notice can help power the Streisand effect: that is, the dynamic in which attempts to suppress information actually backfire and draw more attention to it than ever before. (And thats certainly whats happening with the video of the King, which has garnered countless international media headlines.) With details, users are in a better position to appeal to Facebook directly as well as draw public attention to government targeting and censorship, ultimately making this kind of censorship a self-defeating exercise for the government.
In an HTTP environment where governments can passively spy on and filter Internet content, individual pages could disappear behind obscure and misleading error messages. Moving to an increasingly HTTPS-secured world means that if social media companies are transparent about the pressure they face, we may gain some visibility into government censorship. However, if they comply without informing creators or readers of blocked content, we could find ourselves in a much worse situation. Without transparency, tech giants could misuse their power not only to silence vulnerable speakers, but also to obscure how that censorship takes placeand who demanded it.
Have you had your content or account removed from a social media platform? At EFF, weve been shining a light on the expanse and breadth of content removal on social media platforms with OnlineCensorship.org, where we and our partners at Visualising Impact collect your stories about content and account deletions. Share your story here.
Read more here:
Online Censorship and User Notification: Lessons from Thailand - EFF
Posted in Censorship
Comments Off on Online Censorship and User Notification: Lessons from Thailand – EFF