Conservatives in Frankfort are taking liberal positions – The Record

The two most basic things that distinguish conservatives is, first, a devotion to constitutional government and, secondly, an equal devotion to the free market.

On the one hand, conservative politicians frequently point to the Constitution as the lodestar of their political thought and often call themselves constitutionalists. On the other hand, they profess proud support for economic freedom.

But when it comes to the issue of casino gambling, many politicians who claim to be conservatives all of a sudden come down with an identity crisis.

This Thursday, lawmakers in a Kentucky State Senate committee will consider a bill that will legalize so-called historical horse racing. The bill is designed as a response to a unanimous 7-0 decision by the Kentucky Supreme Court finding that historical horse racing slot machines were not legal on the grounds that they are were not parimutuel wagering on horse races as the horse tracks operating them had claimed.

But the self-professed conservatives pushing this legislation dont even try to hide the fact that it is unconstitutional. Kentuckys Constitution prohibits any gambling outside of pari-mutuel horse racing, charitable gaming and the Kentucky Lottery. Those pushing the bill not only ignore the states Constitution, but the recent courts decision.

The court laid down the five criteria for wagering to be considered pari-mutuel and found that historical racing slot machines fail the test:

Wagering at horse tracks abide by all five, but these machines do not, which make them more like slot machines than horse races.

The bill simply and clumsily defines non-parimutuel wagering as parimutuel wagering, using a definition that is in conflict with virtually every other definition of parimutuel in the country.

And not only does the bill thumb its nose at the court and the Constitution, it goes against every principle of free market economics ever conceived by continuing to give the exclusive right to operate the machines to a few wealthy horse tracks. The biggest recipient of this legislative largess is Churchill Downs, a publicly traded corporation.

The state has received relatively little revenue from the machines. Most of the money has made its way either to Churchill Downs out-of-state investors or into the pockets of wealthy race track owners.

Its something average Kentuckians should remember while theyre waiting for the next federal stimulus check.

Martin Cothran is senior policy analyst of The Family Foundation. He can be reached at 859-329-1919. To learn more about the organization, go to http://www.Kentuckyfamily.org.

Read and share your thoughts on this story

Read the rest here:

Conservatives in Frankfort are taking liberal positions - The Record