How the Constitution Shapes Equality and Inequality in America in 2021 – WDET

The WDET Book Club is reading the U.S. Constitution this summer to understand how it still shapes our lives today, more than two centuries after its inception. Professors Kim Forde-Mazuri and Michele Gilman discuss the idea of equality in the Constitutionfrom a modern-day perspective, and how there is still a long way to go until all Americans aretrulyequal.

Its an ongoing fight and struggle the founders didnt have an inclusive view of equality, but we can. Michele Gilman, University of Baltimore School ofLaw

Kim Forde-Mazrui is a professorat the University of Virginia Law School. He says the Constitution is not wholly responsible for shaping Americaslandscape of equality.We tend to focus on Supreme Court decisions because those decisions tend to place certain limits on what the other branches of government can do. The Supreme Court has evolved over time both in the text of the Constitution and their interpretation. Mazrui says equality purely based onConstitutional amendments is unlikely to take shape.I dont think well ever have perfect [constitutional equality] we are all subject to the culture of our time and we still believe as a society there are certain people who are harmful or immoral or a threat we are continuing to always struggle to draw that line between who gets included and who doesnot.

Mazrui says Constitutionaldistinction based on race or gender is not necessarily a bad thing, as long as it doesnt justify discrimination. A key change the court made is a move toward prohibiting the government from making distinctions based on race and in large part thats a good thing I think unfortunately the court has gone too far in mandating color blindness. He says in the law, its necessary to take into account the historic inequities faced by people of color, rather than this idea of court color blindness.Once youve had centuries of systematic oppression and then simply stopping discrimination doesnt correct for the economic realities that have happened because of thatoppression.

Once youve had centuries of systematic oppression and then simply stopping discrimination doesnt correct for the economic realities that have happened because of that oppression. Kim Forde-Mazrui, University of Virginia LawSchool

Michele Gilman is a professorat the University of Baltimore School of Law. She says the Constitution was designedto overcome its flaws.One thing the framers did well was to have the foresight to know that things change over time and they did provide for ways our constitution could be amended. Gilman says though the Constitutioncan be revised, that alone wont lead to equality in America.Were about to celebrate the 101-year anniversary of the 19th Amendment we still have a long way to go. A constitutional amendment on its own doesnt do all the heavy lifting and so today when we think about what it means to have full gender equality, we are not thereyet.

Gilman says other facets of American government, and the private sector,must influence gender equality. The Constitution is a living document and a lot of the meaning we ascribe to it is the meaning Supreme Court justices have given to it we cannot expect the Constitution to solve all these problems. It protects us against government overreach but it doesnt get to private action. Gilman says formal equality as stated in the Constitution doesnt do the work we need to have a more substantive definition as a society.Its an ongoing fight and struggle the founders didnt have an inclusive view of equality, but wecan.

WDET strives to make our journalism accessible to everyone. As a public media institution, we maintain our journalistic integrity through independent support from readers like you. If you value WDET as your source of news, music and conversation, please make a gift today.

Donate today

The rest is here:

How the Constitution Shapes Equality and Inequality in America in 2021 - WDET