Freedom wont survive a world where every lethal virus triggers another lockdown – Telegraph.co.uk

Suppose, for the sake of argument, that Covid were to claim 10,000 lives next winter. How would we react? Logically, we should take it in our stride. As Chris Whitty said the other week: There will be more deaths, probably for the foreseeable future, but at a much lower level just as every year there are flu deaths, on an average year maybe 7,000, and in a high year up to 20,000. No one ever suggested that we respond to a bad flu year by banning sports and closing shops.

Then again, not every death counts equally, at least not when it comes to public policy. Deaths resulting from terrorism are far more newsworthy than deaths from domestic violence, because a governments legitimacy rests partly on its ability to protect its people from external attack.

When, in 2017, Khalid Masood used his car to kill four people on Westminster Bridge, the machinery of state was fully mobilised. Yet four people die as a result of being hit by vehicles every day each of them as much the centre of their own universe as the victims of terrorism.

Will coronavirus deaths be treated like stroke or cancer deaths an ugly reality in an imperfect world? Or will they become the medical equivalent of terrorist fatalities, blamed on state policy? Early signs point to the latter.

For a year, now, the worlds media have exaggerated the impact of human agency on the virus. Every international disparity in infection or death rates is presented as a result of policy, rather than of differences in demographics, population density, pre-existing immunity, climate or, indeed, luck.

With most diseases, we take for granted that prevalence varies geographically; but, when it comes to the coronavirus, we pretend otherwise.

It is possible that we will eventually treat Covid as an endemic seasonal illness as we do with, say, Spanish flu, whose virulence has declined over the years. But it is equally possible the reverse will happen, that other diseases will be treated like Covid, that every lethal virus will trigger demands for a lockdown.

Read more from the original source:

Freedom wont survive a world where every lethal virus triggers another lockdown - Telegraph.co.uk