Tory campus free speech bill would ‘stoke new culture war’ – Times Higher Education (THE)

The new Conservative government should legislate to create a national academic freedom champion, while restrictions on low-quality courses in universities could rebalance funding towards further education in a shift tailored to the Conservatives new electorate, according to a former Tory adviser and senior civil servant.

With the UKs general election having brought to power a Conservative government with a significant Commons majority, sector attention will focus on the partys manifesto commitments, which notably include pledges to strengthen academic freedom and free speech in universities and to tackle the problem oflow-quality courses in England.

A paper published by Policy Exchange,titled The First Hundred Days: how the Government can implement the pledges in its 2019 election manifesto, says that ministers should move quickly to introduce an academic freedom and free speech on campus bill and thus adopt a plan advocated in arecent report on the issue by the thinktank.

Universities are a potential target if the Conservatives seek to bolster their increased support from working-class, largely non-graduate voters in towns across the Midlands and North by waging culture wars against institutions they perceive as hostile to Tory values.

Iain Mansfield, head of education, skills and science at Policy Exchange, formerly special adviser to Jo Johnson in his brief return as universities minister, said key recommendations in the thinktanks free speech report included extending the statutory duty on freedom of speech to include students and student unions as well as HEIs.

The report also recommended that the Office for Students should appoint a national academic freedom champion who would have the power to investigate allegations of academic freedom or free speech violations and then lead on sanctions where appropriate, he said.

Those would be two things which could be done by the new government, he told Times Higher Education.

Mr Mansfield, a former senior civil servant in the Department for Education, said a recent report by the Policy Institute at Kings College London had found that at least a third of Conservative or Leave-supporting students dont feel comfortable sharing their views at university.

ThePolicy Institute research also foundthat only a minority of UK students have heard about incidents where freedom of expression has been restricted in their own university.

Universities are already subject to requirements to protect freedom of expression under existing legislation.

Nick Hillman, director of the Higher Education Policy Institute and a former Tory special adviser, said: Because the Tories did even better in the election than anybody expected, to then use that [campus free speech] as a way of stoking a new culture war, Im not sure who will benefit from that.

Its not clear to me that either the politicians or the universities benefit from pretending theres a bigger free speech problem in our universities than there really is.

And hurried legislation tends to be legislation that doesnt stand the test of time, he warned.

On the manifestos reference to low-quality courses, Mr Mansfield said this should be understood in conjunction with where the Conservatives have won seats.

I think that steers them very much towards a genuine wholesale rebalancing between HE and FE in terms of funding, numbers, esteem and so forth. I think that will have to be part of the solution [in] looking at low-quality courses.

There were a range of mechanisms for establishing which courses arent delivering, such as the teaching excellence framework, dropout rates and data on progression to employment, he said. Mr Mansfield added that he would favour the reintroduction of number caps for at least some institutions or courses.

john.morgan@timeshighereducation.com

Read more:
Tory campus free speech bill would 'stoke new culture war' - Times Higher Education (THE)