City Council Hit With Federal Lawsuit Over Its Rules On Citizen Speeches

Get Breaking News First

Receive News, Politics, and Entertainment Headlines Each Morning.

By Mike Dunn

PHILADELPHIA (CBS) A local activist has filed a federal lawsuit against Philadelphia City Council claiming that Council violates the First Amendment by limiting the topics of speeches made during its weekly meetings.

Activist Patrick Duff has, for the past few weeks, made speeches in City Council that push Councils limits on public speaking. Specifically, youre only supposed to speak about bills that are up for a vote, and Duff intentionally went beyond that. On Thursday, Duff upped the ante by announcing in his speech that he was suing Council over the rules.

I just want to present you with this, he said. This is a lawsuit against the city that I had to file because you dont allow open public comment.

Duffs suit, filed in federal court, alleges that Councils public speaking rules violate citizens rights.

Im sure everybody would like to speak openly in the city, Duff said. What this does is allow people to have open public comment, as the (state) Sunshine Act and the First Amendment allow us to do.

With a different view is Darryl Zaslow, the attorney who four years won a State Supreme Court decision that forced Council to have any public speeches. He says the legality of Councils current rules is unclear and there are arguments to be made on both sides.

It is by no means a clear cut win on either side, Zaslow said. The right to speak is very clear on matters of concern which are coming before the council or are before the council. The courts have interpreted that sometimes very narrowly, which does give City Council the right to make the claim that they do have the right to limit it.

Read the rest here:
City Council Hit With Federal Lawsuit Over Its Rules On Citizen Speeches