First Thoughts: Act now on the climate emergency, I’m with Bonkers, and the perils of altruism – New Statesman

Climate scientists got it wrong. If we kept average global temperatures at 1.5C above pre-industrial levels, they assured us, we would be safe from catastrophic results. Efforts to halt global warming were therefore discussed with a long timescale in mind. We should aim for net-zero carbon emissions by 2050. For many political and business leaders, switching to greener lifestyles less air travel, less meat-eating, etc was an act of generational altruism, intended to keep our children and grandchildren safe.

Now, it seems, scientists and their computers underestimated the effects of rising temperatures. Wildfires devastate California and Oregon and the smoke haze they create takes the air in New York, 3,000 miles away, 50 per cent beyond safe breathing levels; in China, commuters drown on underground trains; in western Europe, towns and villages are all but destroyed by floods; in London, hospitals close because of flooding; in British Columbia, temperatures get close to 50C, breaking past records by an astounding 4.5C.

Concerned scientists are no longer concerned, Bryony Worthington, an architect of the UKs 2008 Climate Change Act, said. They are freaked out. I am not a scientist, just a chap trying to keep his garage dry. But the truth seems clear to me. Extinction Rebellion is right. Governments need to treat the climate as an emergency, just as they did Covid. By the year 2050, it will be too late. It may already be too late.

Im with Bonkers, says Boris Johnson, as reported by Dominic Cummings. My heart is with Bonkers.

He is allegedly referring, during an argument about the merits of lockdowns to slow the spread of Covid, to my old friend, the Mail on Sunday columnist Peter Hitchens who, as well as dismissing global warming as modish dogma, describes lockdowns as Maoist repression. As Hitchens explains in his latest column, fellow labour correspondents called him bonkers when he reported on trade unions in the 1980s. A sensitive soul, he disliked the nickname and the sneering that went with it (there was one of me and quite a few of them) but, now it has the prime ministerial imprimatur, he tweets that he may have a T-shirt made.

This is what we believe, Margaret Thatcher once told a Conservative meeting, extracting The Constitution of Liberty, a book by the economist and political philosopher FA Hayek, from her handbag. Will Johnson wear Hitchenss T-shirt as a similar declaration of faith?

The footballer Marcus Rashford, who successfully campaigned for the government to extend free school meals into school holidays during the pandemic, asks: Why cant we just do the right thing? Why has there got to be a motive? He was commenting on rumours that the right-wing Spectator magazine was preparing an article, which hasnt yet appeared, about how he benefits commercially fromcampaigning.

The answer lies in the right-wing view that theres no such thing as altruism, and that everyone acts rationally, trying to maximise personal and family advantage. And a good thing too, the right believes. Sajid Javids favourite novelist and philosopher Ayn Rand argued that the individual should exist for his own sake, neither sacrificing himself to others, nor sacrificing others to himself. Selfishness, she declared, was a virtue.

Do-gooders such as Rashford are therefore objects of suspicion. Either they are hypocrites, using charitable work as a front for self-interest, or they are fools, failing in their moral duty to become what Rand called heroic beings, who presumably convert penaltiessuccessfully.

I adore Rugby Union and rejoiced at the British and Irish Lions victory in South Africa. But at the end of the game, I realised that 27 of the 39 points scored came from penalties and I didnt know why any of them was awarded. Have I been watching the sport for all these years without understanding the rules? Probably, but, since most players and even some referees dont understand them either, I shant worryabout it.

[See also:First Thoughts: The classroom culture wars, GB News founders, and cricket gets an update]

See the rest here:

First Thoughts: Act now on the climate emergency, I'm with Bonkers, and the perils of altruism - New Statesman