My first two critiques (here and here) of Hazonys work were focused on his definitions of liberal and conservative, and his arguments regarding philosophy and economics. In this last critique, I focus on his claims about the necessity of religion as a center for a conservative worldview, as he defines it.
Overall, Hazonys work is at its weakest when he gets into the topic of religion. He is adamant that religious observance is necessary to the healthy functioning of a society, and this necessity is supported by conservatism but undermined by liberalism. And his eagerness to argue this point seems to lead to odd lapses in logic. For example, he tells us that when the Enlightenment philosopher Grotius published the first edition of his On the Law of War and Peace in 1625, he made the mistake of admitting in print that his system would hold true even if there is no God and that by saying this, the fundamental incompatibility of Enlightenment rationalism with the God of Scripture had been made plain. But this makes no sense. Saying that something is and would be true independent of Gods existence in no way implies that its truth is therefore incompatible with Gods existence. Those are very different ideas, yet Hazony is treating them as if they meant the same thing.
But rushing ahead, Hazony assures the reader that a political theory in the conservative tradition cannot be made to work without the God of Scripture. Luckily for the prospects of conservative political theory, his argument for this is extremely weak. He goes on to say, Conservatives understand that all human perspectives are limited and local. But at the same time, conservatives recognize that some perspectives are truer than others, and that we can advance toward ideas and principles that better grasp reality in the political and moral domain. Presumably he thinks this is a point of view that is and can only be held by religious conservatives, but that is plainly false. Nothing about being an atheist entails rejecting the idea that humans have limited perspective, for example atheism does not somehow entail a belief in human omniscience or perfectibility. Nor does atheism entail moral antirealism many atheists are also moral realists who believe we have limited and imperfect but real understandings of morality, and that these understandings can be improved upon even though not perfected. Hazony ignores this and attempts to bolster his argument by just asserting a false dichotomy, saying This is the difference between a relativist theory and a conservative one: The relativist sees in politics and morals a realm in which an endless variety of perspectives compete with one another for power without striving to attain what is true, and without anything being right in Gods eyes. But Hazony offers no non-question-begging reason to believe these are the only options.
Suppose Im an atheist who believes the following ideas: I believe that our ideas of social and political order should be grounded in what experience shows actually works. I believe that the human mind is a limited tool, and that what has been shown to work through accumulated experience is a better guide to action than what people can reason through on their own. I believe life is complicated, far too complicated to grasp directly, and grandiose visions to rebuild the social order are doomed to fail because they will be inevitably built on a hopelessly palsied understanding of reality. And because of this, I believe that longstanding social institutions should hold a strong presumption in favor of being upheld, and that its foolish to assume they are useless simply because you, personally, dont see the point of them. (In fact, this is a pretty accurate description of who I am) Now, if someone attempted to convince me I was wrong about all these ideas by saying You may think that, but actually, the God of Scripture doesnt exist, so nothing you just said is true! I would be at most amused by this non sequitur. I certainly wouldnt think that any of the ideas I described had been rebutted, or even engaged.
If the limitations of the human mind make it too feeble an instrument to design a stable and enduring social order through pure reason, then that fact alone would fully explain why attempts to do such a thing would fail. But Hazony claims that such failures actually show God is acting behind the scenes as a countervailing force which stops every scheme of ideas, and every principle, from expanding infinitely outward until it has subjected all things to its rule. The God of Scripture circumscribes all human things, reducing them to their true proportions. This is explanatorily redundant. If a task is beyond the scope of the human mind, thats enough to explain why attempting that task would fail. Nothing extra is explained by saying such failures are also God keeping humans in check, and nothing about believing some tasks are beyond the scope of the human mind requires believing that a God exists.
Hazony goes on to say: Remove him from your thoughts, and your own scheme of ideas, which is local and incomplete, will begin to expand, overrunning its true boundaries. But he doesnt support this through anything beyond mere assertion. He makes no attempt to show this must be true from experience. Like the Enlightenment thinkers he criticizes, Hazony asserts this as though it were an axiomatic, self-evident truth. But experience does not bear him out on this point, as there are many thinkers whose worldviews are deeply rooted in religion who are also philosophical rationalists, and there are many secular thinkers whose worldview is equally deeply rooted in empiricism, the importance of experience over abstract reason, and an awareness of the limitations of the human mind.
Hazony is very fond of using blindness as a description for his ideological opponents. Its never the case that someone who disagrees with him might understand his argument but be unconvinced by it he repeatedly insists they are blind to the reality he describes. Thus, its not the case that liberals understand but disagree with conservatives on nationalism instead, the liberal paradigm is blind to the nation. Its not that liberals might understand but disagree with conservative perspective, its that liberals have been educated in such a way as to leave them blind to the importance of these things. Hazony seems to think his perspective is so self-evidently true that its impossible to see it but not share it if you dont accept his ideas, you must therefore be blind to them.
To be fair, Hazony doesnt think this is an exclusive description of liberals so much as an inevitable side effect of using political paradigms. He says when an important concept or idea has been left out of a political paradigm, those who rely on this paradigm will be blind to political objects of the kind this concept is meant to identify. They will neither see them nor understand their role in the political domain. So, in principle, this should also hold true of people whose worldview is shaped by a conservative paradigm. Yet Hazony show remarkably little curiosity about where his own paradigm might leave him blind, and what he might fail to see or understand as a result. I suspect Hazonys worldview is so deeply embedded with the idea of the Biblical God that he cant comprehend that there are worldviews out there not rooted in his religion that also embrace historical empiricism and epistemic humility, uphold traditions and inherited institutions, and reject moral antirealism. A possible unintended consequence of Hazonys book may be to further fracture the conservative movement by alienating such secular conservatives rather than make a common cause with them, by insisting they cannot be true members of the conservative moment or opponents of rationalist political theory unless they also happen to embrace the Abrahamic God he believes in.
And that would be unfortunate, because despite the many quibbles and criticisms I have laid out here, I think Hazony has written an excellent and thought-provoking book. On many points I agree with what he says, and I think he offers strong arguments for many of his views I dont share. While I find much to disagree with in Hazonys book, there is also much to agree with and to learn from. The good points Hazony makes in his book remain good points independent of his religious doctrine, even if he doesnt see it that way. And thats enough for me, even if it falls short for him.
See the rest here:
Critiquing Hazony - On Religion and Rationalism - Econlib
- Secular Americans Are the New Values Voters and This Election Proved It - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: December 26th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 26th, 2020]
- Outcry in Hollywood over Minari's placement in foreign-language category - The Guardian [Last Updated On: December 26th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 26th, 2020]
- Zuckerman: Secular values voters are becoming an electoral force in the US just look closely at 2020s results - Palm Beach Post [Last Updated On: December 26th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 26th, 2020]
- Secular 'values voters' are becoming an electoral force in the US just look closely at 2020's results - Jacksonville Journal-Courier [Last Updated On: December 26th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 26th, 2020]
- The authenticity of the virgin birth | Editorial Columns - Brunswick News [Last Updated On: December 26th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 26th, 2020]
- FL County That Blocked Atheists from Giving Invocations Adopts Revised Policy - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: December 26th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 26th, 2020]
- To the atheist Sartre: Thank you for this vivid incarnation of Jesus - The Irish Times [Last Updated On: December 26th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 26th, 2020]
- Russian New Year: At The Heart Of A Wide Tapestry Of Winter Traditions - Radio Free Europe / Radio Liberty [Last Updated On: December 30th, 2020] [Originally Added On: December 30th, 2020]
- Conservative Writer: Dr. Anthony Fauci is Immoral Because He's a Humanist - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: January 5th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 5th, 2021]
- Theres More to James Randi Than Meets the Eye - National Catholic Register [Last Updated On: January 5th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 5th, 2021]
- Wrestling With Foam-Pillow Atheism - National Catholic Register [Last Updated On: January 5th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 5th, 2021]
- Deadly IS attack threatens China's Belt and Road in Pakistan - Nikkei Asia [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- Pope Francis: We need unity in the Catholic Church, society, and nations - The Catholic Telegraph [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- Kanimozhi: Our culture is different. They (BJP) cant create fear of other religions here. It wont work in TN polls - The Indian Express [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- RTs Waterford Whispers News sketch was woefully unfunny, crude and offensive - The Irish Times [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- Heroes of the Faith: C.S. Lewis - Keep the Faith [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- James "Jim" G. Rice All Obituaries - The Gazette [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- Podcast Ep. 356: Jesus and the Capitol Coup | Hemant Mehta - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- How many Catholics, Muslims, Jews, Mormons and Hindus are in Congress? - Deseret News [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- White Supremacy in the Church: Black Leaders Discuss the Way Forward - University of Georgia [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- Critically Acclaimed Spiritual Fiction Vividly Details an Atheist Woman's Transformative Encounters at an Ordinary Garage Sale, Challenging Her... [Last Updated On: January 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 11th, 2021]
- 'I was fat and in my 30s, then I discovered rugby and it changed my life' - iNews [Last Updated On: January 17th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 17th, 2021]
- Unity has long been a theme, and anxiety, for new presidents - Outlook India [Last Updated On: January 17th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 17th, 2021]
- LETTER: America is divided, but not by Trump - The News Herald [Last Updated On: January 29th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 29th, 2021]
- Jason Whitlock Doubles Down On Comparing BLM to the KKK - Black Enterprise [Last Updated On: January 29th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 29th, 2021]
- Horror flick 'Saint Maud' will scare the devil out of you - The Patriot Ledger [Last Updated On: January 29th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 29th, 2021]
- Clenndenning explores nature of God and belief - Central Wisconsin News - CW Media [Last Updated On: January 29th, 2021] [Originally Added On: January 29th, 2021]
- Catholic Priest: I'd Deny Biden Communion Until He Repents and Converts - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- Women's History Month at the Center for Education - TheHumanist.com - The Humanist [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- Kangana Ranaut Reacts To A Twitter User Who Questioned Her For Claiming She Was An Atheist As A Kid; Tweets A Perfect Explanation - SpotboyE [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- Kangana Ranaut to user who questioned her atheism: My grandfather engraved it in my mind - Republic TV [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- Can you be scientific and spiritual? - Big Think [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- I will be ticking no religion in the census there is so much more at stake than you might think - The Independent [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- Kangana Ranaut responds to Twitter user who questioned her about understanding atheism as a kid, credits grandfather - Hindustan Times [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- For divorced atheist remainers like me, this census was a minefield - The Guardian [Last Updated On: March 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 21st, 2021]
- GOP County Clerk Candidate's First Goal? Putting In God We Trust on Everything - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: March 26th, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 26th, 2021]
- Richard Dawkins on life after death: 'We're all going to die - but we are the lucky ones!' - Daily Express [Last Updated On: March 26th, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 26th, 2021]
- Montenegro was a success story in troubled Balkan region now its democracy is in danger - The Conversation US [Last Updated On: March 26th, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 26th, 2021]
- Who are the religious nones and why is this group of Americans growing? - Deseret News [Last Updated On: March 26th, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 26th, 2021]
- After Exposing a Proselytizing Teacher, an Atheist and His Child Are on the Run - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: March 26th, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 26th, 2021]
- Yes, Virginia, Atheists Have a Worldview - National Catholic Register [Last Updated On: March 26th, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 26th, 2021]
- Battle For The Soul Of Islam Analysis - Eurasia Review [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- Lord Muruga's weapon Vel becomes political tool to woo voters in TN - News Today [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- Most Democrats and Republicans Know Biden Is Catholic, but They Differ Sharply About How Religious He Is - Pew Research Center's Religion and Public... [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- A Washington Church Created a Bonkers Video Whining About COVID Restrictions - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- What is New Jersey's most popular superstition? (Hint: It brings good luck) - Asbury Park Press [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- Mike Moffett: Educating Ed and Easter | Op-eds | unionleader.com - The Union Leader [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- Congratulations, Atheists: Church Attendance in America is at an All-Time Low. - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- Researchers study mental health of believers, atheists - Winnipeg Free Press [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- What the New Atheists miss about the meaning of God - New Statesman [Last Updated On: March 31st, 2021] [Originally Added On: March 31st, 2021]
- Image of 2013 Bangladesh riots shared as violence against Hindus in West Bengal - Alt News [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Mormon Church President: People Who Have Religious Doubts Are Lazy Learners - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Keir Starmer promises bill to protect women and girls in wake of Sarah Everard killing - The Independent [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Thailand: Easter of conversion, Christ as the answer to the meaning of life - Malaysian Christian News [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- 'They tried to pray the gay away': Growing up gay in a deeply religious household - The Tab [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Why did Trump lose non-religious votes at the ballot? - The Jerusalem Post [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Check Out This Massive (Resurrected) Interactive Chart of Bible Contradictions - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Frank McNally on A History of Northern Ireland in 100 Euphemisms - The Irish Times [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- TN GOP Will Fix Statewide Ban on Priests in Government (But Atheist Ban Remains) - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Zoom event to promote dialogue between theists and nontheists - Idaho State Journal [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Podcast Ep. 369: Atheists No Longer Have to Swear to God to Vote in Alabama - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: April 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 11th, 2021]
- Why the Universe Itself Can't Be the Most Fundamental Thing - Walter Bradley Center for Natural and Artificial Intelligence [Last Updated On: April 19th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 19th, 2021]
- Everything Wrong With Exodus 1 in the Bible | Hemant Mehta | Friendly Atheist | Patheos - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: April 19th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 19th, 2021]
- THE REAL MRS MUHAMMAD Will Be Performed as Part of Suidoosterfees at Artscape Theatre This Month - Broadway World [Last Updated On: April 19th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 19th, 2021]
- Ford on Fridays: they call me the scat man. The bird scat man. - Victoria Buzz [Last Updated On: April 19th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 19th, 2021]
- Death Cult Pastor: One Day We'll Answer to God Even You, Friendly Atheist! - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: April 19th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 19th, 2021]
- Can you believe it? Religions been taking a hit - The Boston Globe [Last Updated On: April 19th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 19th, 2021]
- Atheist Sues L'Oreal Over Repeated Acts of Harassment by His Christian Boss - Friendly Atheist - Patheos [Last Updated On: April 19th, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 19th, 2021]
- Understanding the hate factory: How Rohan Joshi and his hateful post against Hindus gives us an insight into the liberal mind - OpIndia [Last Updated On: April 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 21st, 2021]
- Psychiatrist testifies about shooter's possible motivations in 9th day of Sutherland Springs trial - KENS5.com [Last Updated On: April 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 21st, 2021]
- Richard Dawkins loses humanist of the year title over trans comments - The Guardian [Last Updated On: April 21st, 2021] [Originally Added On: April 21st, 2021]
- Satyajit Ray's 100th birth anniversary falls on May 2. Sumit Paul dwells on the auteur's cinematic relevance in this age of the pandemic, blind faith... [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Leap of faith: NM-filmed Walking With Herb follows grieving grandfathers spiritual journey - Albuquerque Journal [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Letter to the Editor: By being secular, we include everyone - Canton Repository [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Civil ceremonies overtake religious as marriages fall by 53% in 2020 - BreakingNews.ie [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Rewind: Five Spoilery Teases For Marvel's Heroes Reborn, Out This Week - Bleeding Cool News [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Chimeras, Richard Dawkins, and the madness of Catholicism - Angelus News [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Where Steve Meyer Agrees with an Atheist Marxist - Discovery Institute [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Atheists Respond to National Day of Prayer This Week With Action to Feed the Hungry and Clean Up Litter - Good News Network [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2021]
- Bob Marley: Reggae king's only Scottish gig remembered on 40th anniversary of his death - The Scotsman [Last Updated On: May 11th, 2021] [Originally Added On: May 11th, 2021]