Anti-euthanasia campaigner touring Australia with some very extreme views – NEWS.com.au

A vocal member of the QandA audience expressed her own feelings on euthanasia in Australia. Courtesy: ABC

William Toffler is touring Australia campaigning against euthanasia. Picture: Facinglife.tv/Youtube

AN ultraconservative, anti-euthanasia campaigner with extreme views on abortion and contraception is this week touring Australia and meeting with senior MPs.

US doctor William Toffler believes abortion can lead to breast cancer, contraception is against Gods plan and suicide is a sin. Now hes here on the dime of a Liberal politician to convince some powerful people not to legalise assisted dying, which has been legal in his home state of Oregon for 20 years.

Im here to educate people its probably not great to make Oregons mistake, he told news.com.au. Theres a shroud of secrecy, its corrupted the practice of medicine, violating the trust between doctors and patients.

The paradigm of situational killing is anathema to end-of-life care.

This is the perfect murder. Its very flawed, very dangerous and impossible to circumscribe.

William Toffler is touring Australia campaigning against euthanasia. Picture: Facinglife.tv/YoutubeSource:YouTube

Dr Toffler who is this week addressing MPs in Melbourne, Sydney, Adelaide and Perth says there are no adequate psychiatric tests for people who want to end their lives and that they are not asked whether they have life insurance or who the beneficiary is.

He lists a number of anecdotes about people who did not have appropriate mental health checks, about a woman absconding with her euthanised partners $25,000 and about medical staff failing to administer lethal doses properly.

While the statistics from Oregon indicate all is well, Dr Toffler says thats because cases are not properly investigated.

Victorian MP and Leader of the The Australian Sex Party Fiona Patten told news.com.au Dr Toffler was providing a lot of misinformation and misrepresenting the situation in Oregon.

She said she supported his right to free speech but that he had no evidence to support his theories and she felt he was trying to force his views on others.

Ms Patten said she had visited Oregon, where there had not been one case of litigation, and gained a very different picture from doctors and patients.

Im hoping people look at the evidence and listen to the experts in this area and vote on its merits, she said. I dont think Professor Toffler is very helpful in that respect.

Sex Party leader and Victorian MP Fiona Patten said Dr Toffler was trying to force his views on others. Picture: Mark StewartSource:News Corp Australia

The Catholic Church and Right to Die are very well funded. I know privately an enormous number of MPs would like to see physician assisted dying approved.

We received over 1000 submissions to our inquiry. I dont think anyone with compassion could have heard them and not want to give patients at the end of their lives and suffering some kind of autonomy.

She said the alternatives to assisted dying were often violent suicides, unregulated euthanasia or Dr Tofflers recommendation of sedation, in which patients died of starvation or dehydration.

Polls show around 80 per of Victorians and, it is believed, Australians nationwide support a law for voluntary assisted dying.

Shayne Higson, Vice President of Dying with Dignity, told news.com.au that the law in Oregon had been working safely and effectively for 20 years, supported by the public and medical profession, which was why similar laws are now in place across six states in America.

Hopefully the parliamentarians of Victoria and NSW will not be persuaded by scaremongering, she said. It is a challenge when groups like Right to Life bring people here and put them forward as experts. I dont think Dr Toffler would be considered an expert in Oregon.

Hes Catholic and represents a very small minority of people.

His views are not really credible. Its disappointing that Australians, especially the Victorian Parliament, are going to be exposed to his views. We deserve a better, evidence-based debate.

There is no slippery slope, and no evidence of widespread abuse.

Dr Toffler says that while the law currently only allows assisted dying for terminally ill, mentally competent patients, there is no reason this would not be extended if people were suffering for longer periods of time.

Andrew Irving, holding a photo of wife Marilyn, who passed away after a long illness, at a rally supporting a voluntary assisted dying bill. Picture: Luke BowdenSource:News Corp Australia

Claiming dignity by taking a massive overdose is specious, he said. I was married for 40 years my wife died 13 months ago with cancer of the uterus.

The reality is because my wife and I knew she was going to die there was suffering, but also great joy. Our days together all more special because we knew they were numbered.

I wouldnt trade it for a nanosecond. To say an overdose is dignified, what does it say about my family, my wife, who chose to live her life fully with support from family and doctors?

Many advocates for assisted dying have spoken out against Dr Tofflers visit, which comes as the debate heats up in Australia, particularly in Victoria and NSW, where Voluntary Assisted Dying Bills have been tabled to the state parliaments.

While Premier Daniel Andrews, most of his ministers, the Sex Party and the Greens are in favour of reform, some are not, including such as Deputy Premier James Merlino, Opposition leader Matthew Guy and socially conservative Liberals and crossbenchers.

Anne Gabrielides from NSW is terminally ill and campaigning for the right to die on her own terms.Source:News Corp Australia

A spokesperson from Go Gentle Australia told news.com.au in a statement: Dr Toffler is a controversial member of the religious right and was part of a very small minority in the Oregon Medical Association who opposed a womans right to choose abortion and did so because God told him so. He has publicly aligned himself with the discredited view that there is a link between abortion and breast cancer, a view opposed by, among others, the Australian Medical Association, the Cancer Council of Australia and the Breast Cancer Network, Australia.

Toffler is being sponsored in his visit to parliament by Liberal MLC Inga Peulich. Ms Peulich was one of two dissenting votes on the Cross-Parliamentary Inquiry into End-of-Life Choices Committee. Their recommendations (6-2 in favour) laid the groundwork for the voluntary assisted dying bill to go before Parliament later this year.

Along with the other dissenting voice Labor MP Daniel Mulino Ms Peulich chose not to travel with the Committee to Oregon, or other jurisdictions where assisted dying laws exist, to learn how they work.

Instead, she has chosen to sponsor a speech to MPs by a doctor with extreme religious views. A doctor whose opposition to Oregons Death with Dignity law not only predates its existence, but also flies in the face of its widespread acceptance after more than 20 years of operation.

The people of Victoria deserve better from Ms Peulich than the introduction of a religious extremist into this important public health debate.

See original here:

Anti-euthanasia campaigner touring Australia with some very extreme views - NEWS.com.au