Kemper County and the Perils of Clean Coal Technology – IEEE Spectrum

Politicians who talk about the future of clean coal as part of the U.S. energy mix need look no farther than the Kemper County Energy Facility in Mississippi to see both the promise and the peril that the technology has to offer.

Kemper is years behind schedule and billions of dollars over the $2.2-billion cost estimate given in 2010 when construction began. And a recent financial analysis paints a dim picture of the plants potential for profit.

A decade ago, integrated gasification combined cycle (IGCC)was heralded as the enabler ofa continued and even expanded use of coal for electric power generation. The process starts byturning coal into synthesis gas, a combination of hydrogen and carbon monoxide. The syn gas can then be cleaned of impurities, and burned to drive a turbine. Excess heat goes to power steam turbine. Dozens of U.S. projects were proposed. Equipment manufacturers and engineering firms alike focused resources to developing the technology.

Southern Company, whose utility business units operate 44,000 megawatts of installed capacity and generate electricity for 9 million customers across the southern United States, saw an opportunity for IGCC at a location in Kemper County, Miss.

In many ways, a better site for IGCC could scarcely be found. Kemper is close to an estimated 4 billion metric tons of mineable Mississippi lignite, a low-rank coal with high moisture and ash content. Southern owns the lignite fields and saw a way via IGCC to use that coal for power generation. Whats more, Kemper is close to mature oil fields, which became candidates for enhanced oil recovery (EOR)the use of carbon dioxide captured from the power plants coal gasification process to push out the oil.

The clean coal opportunity extended beyond Kemper County and Southern Co. Low-rank coals make up roughly half of the proven coal reserves in the United States and worldwide. Southern, along with KBR and in conjunction with the U.S. Energy Department, developed its own version of IGCC calledTransport Integrated Gasification (TRIG). That technology was developed to work with lower-rank coals and presented an opportunity to market domesticallyand evenexport the technology.

The Kemper County IGCC Project is a scale-up of a test plant that was already in operation in Alabama. The combined cycle portion of Kemper Countyhas worked well and has been generating electricity since August 2014 with conventional natural gas.

Its the gasification part of the plant that is proving problematic.

For one thing, the company found that many of the original design specs needed changes, delaying the project and boosting its cost. One design flaw miscalculated pipe thickness, length, quantity, and metallurgy. After these changes were made, additional changes needed to be done to support structures.

For another thing, integrated gasification is something akin to a chemistry set that has been bolted onto a conventional power plants front end.IGCC technology is intended not only to produce syngasbut also to create marketable byproducts from the gasification process, such as carbon dioxide. Thecaptured carbon dioxide from Kemper was earmarked to help stimulate production at nearby oil fields through EOR.

On paper, at least, IGCC offers an elegant approach to use coal for electric power generation, create cleaner burning synthetic gas, capture and reuse carbon dioxide, and manufacture chemical byproducts for sale. In practice, however, Kemper Countys technology is proving to be troublesome, expensive, and potentially uneconomic to run.

In mid-February, Mississippi Powerthe Southern Co. utility that is hosting the projectextended the expected in-service date of Kemper County until mid-March, the latest in a series of rescheduled dates.

The utility said in a statement that while integrated operation of the facilitys gasifiers and combustion turbines has continued for periods since late January, the schedule adjustment is needed because of issues experienced with the ash removal system in one of the gasifiers.

In particular, the plant has had a reoccurring issue in operating both of its gasifiers reliably over an extended period without forming clinkers ash fused to the gasifier walls. Neither gasifier has operated for longer than about six weeks without clinkers occurring. These chunks of ash are enough to impact the plants operating efficiency and bring the facilitydown for maintenance.

The issues dont end there. Aconfidential report[PDF]by URS, made public by in early Februarythe Mississippi Public Service Commission, outlined seven key technical milestones in addition to the clinkers that it said had yet to be achieved.

Most of the milestones focused on the gasification technology and the plants ability to deliver byproducts (including carbon dioxide for oil recovery) that met environmental specs.

Engineering challenges aside, a separate report called into question the plants overall economic viability. In particular, long-term natural gas price forecasts now suggest that the Kemper IGCC may not be competitive when compared to natural gas combined cycle units at the nearby Plant Sweatt site.

In a 19 February earnings conference call, Thomas Fanning, chairman, president and CEO of Southern, said:When we had this plant certificated(in 2010), we all thought that gas prices were going to be double digits. By 2016, however, that assessment had changed, resulting in a reduction of gas price forecasts of 25to 30 percent.

Hydraulic fracturing largely can be thanked for the change in fortune. Indeed, as far back as 2011 natural gas prices nationally were low enough to economically displace coal-fired generating units across multiple states.

Coal from parts of the Appalachian and Illinois basins were displaced first as natural gas prices fell and the fuels nagging price volatility eased. Among the last to be impacted would be inexpensive, low-rank coals that required little handling to move from the mine mouth to the power plant. Just such a scenario began to hit the Kemper IGCC in late 2016.

We know that gas forecasts have changed a lot over time, Fanning said on the analyst call. And with respect to whether we should recover it or not, I don't thinkI mean as a matter of fairness, I cannot imagine that the company is going to be held accountable for changing gas price forecasts.

What Fanning was alluding to was the fact that state officials who oversee Mississippi Power ultimately will decide whether or not the Kemper IGCC plant is used and useful and how the company can account for and recover the expenses related to its construction.

Regulators already have capped the amount that Mississippi Power customers must pay at just under $3 billion. But another $4 billion need to be accounted for and allocated through regulatory hearings that are expected to start once Kemper County enters service.

As for the upcoming regulatory process, Fanning said:We certainly have taken our lumps, but we have delivered what was certificated back in 2010. He expressed confidence that the Kemper IGCC would deliver what was required when IGCC technology was seen as offering an opportunity to develop clean coal for electric power generation.

Certainly there's a lot of different ways the regulatory process could unfold from there, Fanning said. That's our starting point.

IEEE Spectrums energy, power, and green tech blog, featuring news and analysis about the future of energy, climate, and the smart grid.

Sign up for the EnergyWise newsletter and get biweekly news on the power & energy industry, green technology, and conservation delivered directly to your inbox.

As coal industry jobs are lost, likely not to return, some in coal country have turned to coding 15Feb

Deregulation actions by congressional Republicans may undercut innovative sensor technology by quashing methane detection at oil and gas sites 13Feb

DOE report says renewable power generation jobs surpassed those in fossil fuels, and are growing faster 26Jan

Petra Nova, the world's biggest CCS project, started up last week, and other sites show that it's not just for coal anymore 16Jan

Analytics from Berkeley-based WattTime precisely match new loads on a grid to the power plant that will serve them, providing estimates of carbon intensity that are up to 45 percent more accurate than regional averages. Such tools can guide cleaner charging by electric vehicles, and yield a bigger carbon reduction bang from energy efficiency measures and renewable power projects. 26Dec2016

Some of the work of the U.S. Department of Energy's advanced research wing fits fine with Trump's priorities, but analysts worry the next generation of solar tech could suffer 5Dec2016

Aluminum-based device produces industrially useful compounds 20Jul2016

Claire, a Canadian microsatellite launched in June, is gearing up to take high-resolution snapshots of greenhouse gas plumes 5Jul2016

Simulations show the potential for wider problems, because of natural gas dependence and poor understanding of feedback effects between the two systems 24May2016

A silicon MEMS device that accurately measures gravity could make geophysical surveys easier, cheaper, and safer 30Mar2016

With carbon markets and subsidies in doubt, nuclear is no longer affordable 25Mar2016

World leaders set a high bar for climate action, striking a deal in Paris that well exceeds their action plans. But transparency, verification and peer pressure could close the gap 16Dec2015

Pledged carbon emissions fall well short of what's needed to hold global warming to 2 degrees Celsius this century. Emissions denial could ultimately turn up the heat even more 10Nov2015

Researchers calculate the maximum efficiency for using sunlight to turn carbon dioxide into fuel, and it's pretty good 26Oct2015

A $20 million Carbon XPrize funded by big fossil fuel producers and users sets a 4-1/2 year challenge to turn carbon dioxide into value-added products. Could there be more value in reducing emissions at the source? 29Sep2015

An attempt to understand VW's clean diesel tech instead uncovered one of history's greatest corporate cybercrimes 22Sep2015

You have to account not just for inflation but for what economists call oil intensity 21Sep2015

Regions could save $5.7 million-$210 million per year by replacing coal-fired power with renewable energy or energy efficiency measures 31Aug2015

But will all this data have any impact on policy? 20Aug2015

Superfast simulation would allow regions to trade higher electricity costs for reduced healthcare costs 17Aug2015

Link:

Kemper County and the Perils of Clean Coal Technology - IEEE Spectrum