History Highlight: Proponents of eugenics, population control, and …

Abortion advocates are attempting to paint the pro-life movement as racist by using the issue of immigration to claim that the motivation behind making abortion illegal is derived from an effort to increase the births of white babies. But this entire premise is absurd on its face, given the fact that for decades, abortion which is tethered to eugenics has disproportionately targeted Black Americans and other minorities. But even more to the point, the original promoters of the anti-immigration movement were aligned with the same eugenic movers and shakers that brought us abortion and Planned Parenthood.

According to the Harry H. Laughlin papers at Truman State University, The American eugenics movement greatly influenced U.S. policies regarding immigration. Policy writers were interested in the eugenics movement and immigration because the nativist side of eugenics focused on keeping the American race pure from immigrants who were seen as unfit.'

The very first anti-immigration group, theImmigration Restriction League (IRL), was founded in 1894 by three Harvard College graduates Charles Warren,Robert DeCourcy Ward,andPrescott Farnsworth Hall in response to an increasing sense of invasion of the United States by undesirable immigrants that threatened their sense of the American way of life,according to Harvard Colleges Houghton Library.

The Leagues goal, wrote researcher Adam S. Cohen, was to keep out groups they regarded as biologically undesirable. Immigration was a race question, pure and simple, Ward said. It is fundamentally a question as to what races shall dominate in the country. League members made no secret of whom they meant: Jews, Italians, Asians, and anyone else who did not share their northern European lineage, Cohen added.

The League was founded in Boston, but quickly spread to many other cities across the United States and they choseHall, who originally proposed calling the League the Eugenic Immigration League, to beChairman of the Committee on Immigration of the Eugenics Section of the American Genetic Association.

Immigration Restriction League Prescott F Hall Secretary 1904 National Archives

In Halls Eugenics, Ethics And Immigration, he wrote, The attempt to improve race stocks in recent times has, therefore, taken the form, not of killing off the less fit, but of preventing their coming into the State, either by being born into it or by migration. Eugenics includes, not only the prevention of unfit, but the conscious attempt to produce the more fit; indeed, it is in the latter sense that the word is most often used. Strictly speaking, however, it must include all attempts to improve the physical equipment of the individual in so far as he acquires it by heredity. The recent emphasis upon eugenics is a direct outcome of modern science.

The fact is, that our immigration laws, as at present administered, do not screen out the unfit so as to preserve the status quo, to say nothing of promoting eugenic improvement, Hall also wrote.

In his book Fatal Misconception, author Matthew Connelly cites Hall as stating, The moral seems to be this: Eugenics among individuals is encouraging the propagation of the fit and limiting or preventing the multiplication of the unfit Immigration restriction is a species ofsegregation on a large scale, by which inferior stocks can be prevented from both diluting and supplanting good stocks.

Eugenicists influence within the early anti-immigration movement was confirmed by University of Virginia historian Paul A. Lombardo, who wrote:

In 1911, Immigration Restriction League President Prescott Hall asked his former Harvard classmate Charles Davenport of the Eugenics Record Office (ERO) for assistance to influence Congressional debate on immigration. Davenport recommended a survey to determine the national origins of hereditary defectives in American prisons, mental hospitals and other charitable institutions. Davenport appointed ERO colleague Harry Laughlin to manage the research program.

Laughlin was a founding member andpresident of the American Eugenics Society and the architect of the 1924 anti-immigration act. Laughlin joined others of his day in promoting forced sterilization and evenauthored a model eugenics sterilization law. In 1933, Laughlins ideas werepublishedby Margaret Sangers Birth Control Review, and in 1938 hebecame part oftheCitizens Committee on Planned Parenthood.

In 1936, Laughlin received anhonorarydegree from the Nazi-controlled University of Heidelberg as a pioneer in the science of race cleansing, according to Lombardo.Smithsonian Magazine identifiedLaughlin as[o]ne of the primary examples of how eugenics played a role in immigration law.

In 1920, Laughlin appeared before the U.S. House of Representatives Committee on Immigration and Naturalization, where Lombardo says he argued that the American gene pool was being polluted by a rising tide of intellectually and morally defective immigrants primarily from eastern and southern Europe. Laughlins research culminated in his 1924 testimony to Congress in support of a eugenically-crafted immigration restriction bill, where Lombardo claims the resulting law, the Immigration Restriction Act of 1924, was designed consciously to halt the immigration of supposedly dysgenic Italians and eastern European Jews, whose numbers had mushroomed during the period from 1900 to 1920 The 1924 Act ended the greatest era of immigration in U.S. history.

Truman State Universitys special collections website points out that the 1924 anti-immigration act set an annual ceiling on the number of immigrants allowed entrance into the U.S., regardless of origin, except Arians, who were totally excluded, they claimed.

Harry Laughlin author of Immigration Act signed Committee for Planned Parenthood

Theodore Lothrop Stoddard, whobelievedthat non-white races must be excluded from America, was connected to Planned Parenthood founder Margaret Sanger and authored a book titled, The Rising Tide of Color. Stoddard was a journalist and Exalted Cyclops of the Massachusettschapter of the Ku Klux Klan.He served on Sangers National Council, her American Birth Control League (ABCL)Board of Directors, and the conference committee of theFirst American Birth Control Conference.

According to an article published by the United States Holocaust Memorial Museum:

Stoddard testified to Congress on immigration issues in the 1920s and 1930s. He supported restricting immigration to the United States, and he particularly opposed theadmission of groups heconsidered to be undesirable or racially inferior. On one occasion, Stoddard referred to refugees from the Middle East who were fleeing violence as parasitical and mongrel people who would be very undesirable immigrants.He also supported laws that would exclude Asians from entering the United States.

Author Matthew Connellywrote of Stoddard, Stoddard claimed that white men were responsible for their own demise, because they had reduced famine and disease and had thus removed checks to population increase among other races.

Sanger herself expressed concern about immigration. Writing in Plan for Peace, published in her Birth Control Review (BCR), she advocated a Population Congress which would keep the doors of immigration closed to the entrance of certain aliens whose condition is known to detrimental to the stamina of the race, such as feebleminded, idiots, morons, insane, syphilitic, epileptic, criminal, professional prostitutes, and others in this class barred by the immigration laws of 1924.

Plan for Peace by Margaret Sanger

Former Population Council employeeShannon HarveyonceallegedonTwitterthata Population Council VP had expressed concerns about African immigration into Europe,tweeting:

At a donor event a VP made this case for family planning: Theres widespread concern about 4bn people in Africa: poverty, environment, famines With 1bn Africans, immigration is more than [Europe] thinks they can handle. With 4bn people it will be a much bigger problem.

The Population Council brought the abortion pill RU486 (mifepristone) into the United States and set up the pills U.S. manufacturer, Danco Laboratories.

California abortionistEdward Allred, owner of the Family Planning Associates Medical Group (one of the largest privately owned abortion chains in the U.S. at the time) expressed what has since beendescribedas a racist view of Hispanics, eventellinga reporter from the San Diego Union that he hoped to stem the tide of the new influx of Hispanic immigrants. Allred said:

Population control is too important to be stopped by some right-wing pro-life types. Take the new influx of Hispanic immigrants. Their lack of respect for democracy and social order is frightening. I hope I can do something to stem that tide. Id set up a clinic in Mexico for free if I could. Maybe one in Calexico would help. The survival of our society could be at stake.

In 1967,Coloradobecame thefirst U.S. stateto legalize abortion, in large partdueto the leadership ofthen-Denver RepresentativeRichard D. Lamm, the abortion billsprincipal sponsor. Lamm, who later became Governor of the state, also opposed immigration into the U.S. and served on the boards of anti-immigration organizationslike theFederation of American Immigration Reform (FAIR),Progressives for Immigration Reform(PFIR),andCalifornians for Population Stabilization(CAPS). In addition to Lamm,Charles Westoff amemberof both the American Eugenics Society as well as Planned Parenthoods National Advisory Council alsoservedon the CAPS advisory board.

Garrett Hardin was both a NARALco-founderand an admitted anti-immigration (and pro-abortion) activist.In aninterview with Skeptic magazine in 1996, Hardin stated:

I started being an activist for legalized abortion in 1963. I spent most of my external time on that issue until the Supreme Court reached the famous 1973 Roe v. Wade decision. I thought the fight was all over. Well, I was wrong.

At the time, my wife and I were active in Planned Parenthood. She was on the local board of directors. The question came up in Planned Parenthood as to what our position should be on abortion. Some wanted to stay clear of it entirely because they realized there would be a lot of opposition. Fortunately, Planned Parenthood decided that it was a question of womens rights.

Abortion is above all other things a method of birth control. To put it another way, its a backstop for any system of birth control when the rest of the system fails.That decision to support the womans right to abortion put Planned Parenthood in a dangerous position.

A University of Californiaarchived historyof Hardin described him asa leading ecological thinker, whose views influenced debates on abortion, immigration, foreign aid, overpopulation, and other provocative issues.

UC Political Science Professor Matto MildenbergerdisturbinglydescribedHardin as aracist, eugenicist, nativist and Islamophobe. Hardin was against immigration,reportedlybecause most immigrants into the United States have been Mexicans, blacks from the Caribbean and Africa, and Asians. According to theGarret Hardin Society website, Hardin believed that an increasingly multicultural society was a recipe for social disorder. In 1990, Hardin wasawardedby the anti-immigration Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR), where heservedas a board member.

The Federation for American Immigration Reform (FAIR) is one of the largest anti-immigration organizations. FAIRs2001 annual reportdescribed itsfounderJohn Tantonas becominginterestedin immigration to the United States through his long-standing concerns about the effects of unplanned and uncontrolled population growth and resource depletion.

He was the national President of Zero Population Growth from 1975 to 1977 and was Chairman of its Immigration Study Committee from 1973 to 1975. He was organizer and President of theNorthern Michigan Planned Parenthoodchapter [1965-1971]. From 1971 to 1975, Dr. Tanton served as Chairman of the Sierra Club National Population Committee, the report added.

In Tantonsoral history, he claimed that in 1964, one of the first things we did was to establish a Planned Parenthood clinic in northern Michigan a fact confirmed by theDetroit News, which wrote that the Tantons (John and Mary Lou) co-founded the Northern Michigan Planned Parenthood in 1965. Mary Lou Tanton was also employed by FAIR. Herresumreveals that she served as president from 1975-1978, on the board of Washtenaw County League for Planned Parenthood (1961-1964), and on the Michigan Planned Parenthood Council-Public Affairs and Legislative Chairman (1976-1979).

John Tanton on Planned Parenthood board

TantonfundedFAIRin part frommoneyfrom the Pioneer Fund, an organizationfoundedby eugenicist leaders Harry Laughlin and Fredrick Henry Osborn, a leader of thePopulation Councilwho signed Sangers Citizens Committee for Planned Parenthood,publishedin her review in April of 1938.

Tanton wasintriguedbyPaul Ehrlichs book,The Population Bomb, and was eventually nominatedto the national board of Zero Population Growth (ZPG) andsubsequently elected national president of ZPG in 1975.Tantonhas beencalledthe father of the anti-immigration movement and hasnurturedmultiple anti-immigration groups like Numbers USA and FAIRs research arm, the Center for Immigration Studies.

Cordelia Scaife May funds John Tantons anti-immigration orgs (Image: New York Times)

FAIR was alsofunded in part with the finances of philanthropist Cordelia Scaife May, who openlyadmired Margaret Sanger, was a friend to Garrett Hardin, worked with Planned Parenthood, and served on the board of the Population Council,contributing $11.4 million to the Councils work during the 1960s. In 1969,May signed an ad paid for by the Hugh Moore Fund which pointed to the flood of humanity now engulfing the earth and the urgent necessity of controlling it. According toPhilanthropy Daily,May gave Tanton a $500,000 grant to start the organization in 1978.

Hugh Moore Fund 1969 ad signed by Cordilia Scaife May against Latin immigration

FAIRs pastleadershipis a whos who of abortion and eugenics proponents and includes the previously mentioned Richard D. Lamm who drafted andsucceededin passing the nations first liberalized abortion law in Colorado. It also includes NARALco-founderGarrett Hardin, who also receivedfundingfrom the Pioneer Fund and was deeply involved with ZPG and Planned Parenthood. In1980, Hardin received Planned Parenthoods Margaret Sanger Award.

Hardin also belonged to the Hemlock Society and took hisown lifein 2003.

Former California congressman Anthony Beilenson also sat on FAIRs boardandreportedly helped passthe first liberalization of Californias abortion law in 1967. In his bookabout the Tantons, author John F. Rohe describes FAIR Chairman Sherry Barnes andSidney Swensrud as also working with Planned Parenthood.

FAIR Board member Sarah G. Epstein, daughter of Pathfinder Internationals eugenicistfounder Clarence Gamble,servedon the boards ofPlanned Parenthood of Metropolitan Washington, Center for Development and Population Activities, The Population Institute, andPathfinder International. (Clarence Gamble also served asdirectorof bothMargaret SangersAmerican Birth Control League andPlanned Parenthoodboards.) Epsteinwas a2009 sponsorof Planned Parenthoods Champions of Choice event.

Federation of American Anti-immigration Reform (FAIR) 2000 board John Tanton Donald A Collins

Also serving onFAIRs boardwas Donald A. Collins, a former vice chairman and trustee of the Planned Parenthood Federation of America and advisor of population affairs for the Scaife family of Pittsburgh. He alsoservedon the national oversight board of theCenter for Family Planning Program Development, whichlater morphedinto the Guttmacher Institute.

Florida abortion facility owner Joyce Tarnow, who also served on FAIRs board, once appeared on a local talk show where shesuggestedthat countries which needed help feeding their people should sink or swim on their own. The more people you help to survive the more people who are going to be reproducing and having children beyond what we can reasonably hope to have so that we can educate and house and feed these people, Tarnowstated.

Watch Tarnow in the documentary film Maafa21 below:

Tarnow founded theMiami chapter of Zero Population Growth in 1970 andserved on its national board from 19721974. Later, (1994) she co-founded Floridians for a Sustainable Population (FSP). In 2004, Tarnow was interviewed by a Broward-Palm Beach New Times reporter where Tarnow claimed thatFertility is an environmental issue before telling the media outlet, Thats why I try to get as many people sterilized as are in my way!

The article entitled Adios, Abortionist, then turned to immigration. Tarnow stated, We need to help nations that can subsist and let others wither on the vine. Regarding the nation of Haiti, Tarnow added that the people there need to stew in their own juices. Tarnow died in 2014.

The accusation that somehow the pro-life movement is attempting to increase the white population by restricting abortion is outlandish for many reasons. The abortion industrys current cries are to ensure that women of color, in particular, can access abortion even though Black women already currently account for 38.4% of all abortions in the U.S, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. This is stunning, considering that the Black community only makes up 12% of the U.S. population.

Aside from this, clear history shows that it is the abortion/population control/eugenics movement (which are not separate movements) that has always sought to keep certain people groups both from reproducing and from legally immigrating to the United States.

Like Live Action News on Facebookfor more pro-life news and commentary!

Read more:

History Highlight: Proponents of eugenics, population control, and ...