A Saginaw resident says the parking tickets she acquired violated her constitutionalrights.
Alison Taylor had an assigned parking spot, but she says it was not being maintained so she had to park in the street. While doing so she received and paid for 14 parking tickets from the city. Before Taylor received each ticket, a parking attendant marked her vehicle with chalk to track how long it had beenthere.
The significance of this case is that even when the government is violating your rights a little bit, versus a whole lot, its still problematic and still should not be done.Philip Ellison, Alison Taylorsattorney
Taylor decided to sue the city in a class action lawsuit claiming that chalking tires to track how long a car has been parked is a violation of the Fourth Amendment, which protects against unreasonablesearches.
The significance of this case is that even when the government is violating your rights a little bit, versus a whole lot, its still problematic and still should not be done, says Taylors attorney, PhilipEllison.
The case was thrown out at first but won an appeal. Then it was thrown out again, but just recently won a second appeal with the 6th U.S. Circuit Court inCincinnati.
WDETs Laura Herberg spoke with Ellison about the case. Click on the audio player to hear that conversation or read a transcript, edited for brevity andclarity,below.
Laura Herberg, 101.9 WDET: What made you and your client think you had a casehere?
Philip Ellison, Taylors attorney: So for many years in the United States, the law on the Fourth Amendment was whether the activity or the area that was sought to be searched would be deemed reasonably private based on community expectations. In 2012, a U.S. Supreme Court case came out called Jones. And the Jones decision said, in addition to all the reasons for all the places where we say that we treat it with the reasonable expectation of privacy, were also going to say that when the government trespasses onto your property for the purpose of extracting information for enforcement thats asearch.
And lets back up just a little bit. For folks who arent really familiar with the Fourth Amendment, can you talk aboutwhat its intended todo?
The Fourth Amendment is a constitutional amendment. It protects people from unreasonable searches of their persons, houses, papers and effects unless the government gets a warrant first. And what thatsdesigned to do is to put somebody in between law enforcement officials, or what they called back in the day the constables, versus the citizenry. Essentially cops and constables cant come busting in your door or come busting in your horse and carriage without someone else reviewing the need for that, which would have been a judge or a magistrate signing off onthat.
Well, as the years have gone by and as our constitutional laws developed there have been some exceptions that have been created for when law enforcement no longer needs to get a warrant. But for the most part, when a law enforcement officer wants to search your private property they have to get a warrant from a judge. And if they dont get a warrant from a judge that generally violates the FourthAmendment.
How are you arguing that a chalk mark on a car qualifies as an unconstitutionalsearch?
Well, so the case in Jones was one where the law enforcement had placed a GPS tracking device physically on the vehicle of Mr. Jones wifes car. And so when Mr. Jones started driving around the police were tracking where he was or where he wasnt based on that GPS tracking device. And so when we looked at that case, we thought,isnt chalking essentially the same thing, a low-tech version, but the same thing? Its a device thats hooked to a vehicle to tell where someone is or isnt for a certain period of time. So we drew what we call in the legal business an analogy. We analogized it to the same circumstances. Chalking is not a GPS tracking device. But the principle is the same. Its the government tracking where you are and where you arent for the purposes of law enforcement or to enforce the law in some way. So, we came up with this idea and argued its very similar, and for the most part, at least for the appellate courts, its been verysuccessful.
It is a big deal, because its that old slippery slope argument. If you let them do A, then theyre going to want to do B. And then if you want to do B, theyre going to want to do C. And before you know it our rights under the Constitution have been completely eroded. PhilipEllison
What did the courtsay?
Well, this time around the court held that the reason that the lower federal court threw out our case the second time was anerror.
The lower court decided that the City of Saginaw could conduct chalking then later issue tickets based on a concept called the administrative search doctrine. An administrative search doctrine is very similar to why, for example, the government can come inspect power plants or the Liquor Control Commission can inspect bars. Theres a set regulatory way in which we dont require those types agencies to get a warrant ahead of time because basically you know when theyre coming, they announce when theyrecoming.
We argue that chalking is not the same thing. Here the government official, being the parking enforcement officer, comes through and just marks everybodys car with or without notice and just shows up to do that. And when youre trespassing on a car, much like the tracking device from Jones to see where someone is or where someone isnt, that provides the basis by which we can say the administrative search doctrine does not apply. And thats what the Sixth Circuitruled.
So these are all exceptions to the warrant requirement. The last time around, there was a couple other exceptions, one was called community caretaking, another one was called the automobile exception. The court there in the previous appeal said those dont apply. In this case, they held that the administrative search doesntapply.
So basically, were slicing the salami down to not much left for the city to be able to argue to make a sandwich out of to say theres no casehere.
Is this all about parking tickets and chalking or whats the significance of thiscase?
Well, the significance of this caseis that even when the government is violating your rights a little bit, versus a whole lot, its still problematic and still should not be done. I know theres a lot of folks when I review the comments online to some of the stories people post about this they say, Well, this is kind of ridiculous. Of all the problems we have in the world, why are we focused on chalking tires? Its no big deal. But it is a big deal, because its that old slippery slope argument. If you let them do A, then theyre going to want to do B. And then if you want to do B, theyre going to want to do C. And before you know it our rights under the Constitution have been completelyeroded.
Whats next for your client and for thecase?
Well, we head back to the local court and were back down for another round of legal cases and arguments to see how the case will develop and if we ultimately succeed in the case. Because interestingly, the Sixth Circuit didnt grant us the full win. They just simply said what the judge below did was an error. And we sent it back and we continue on with the case. We pick up right where we leftoff.
WDET strives to make our journalism accessible to everyone. As a public media institution, we maintain our journalistic integrity through independent support from readers like you. If you value WDET as your source of news, music and conversation, please make a gift today.
Donate today
Read the rest here:
A Saginaw Woman Who Sued the City Over How It Issues Parking Tickets Continues Fight in Court - WDET
- Protections for e-data clear Senate committee [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- Quinn: Supreme Court should clarify Fourth Amendment rights in the digital age [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- Fourth amendment | Wex Legal Dictionary / Encyclopedia ... [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution ... [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- The Fourth Amendment is destroyed by the Roberts led Supreme Court. - Video [Last Updated On: April 26th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 26th, 2014]
- Court may let cops search smartphones [Last Updated On: April 28th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 28th, 2014]
- Supreme Court to hear case on police searches of cellphones [Last Updated On: April 28th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 28th, 2014]
- Fourth Amendment in the digital age: Supreme Court to decide if police can search cellphones without a warrant [Last Updated On: April 30th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 30th, 2014]
- What Scalia knows about illegal searches [Last Updated On: April 30th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 30th, 2014]
- Should police be allowed to search your smartphone - Video [Last Updated On: April 30th, 2014] [Originally Added On: April 30th, 2014]
- Fourth Amendment to the United States Constitution - Video [Last Updated On: May 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 1st, 2014]
- Rand Paul Third Party Records Should Get Fourth Amendment Protection O'Reilly Factor 6 11 2013 - Video [Last Updated On: May 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 1st, 2014]
- The Shaky Legal Foundation of NSA Surveillance on Americans [Last Updated On: May 2nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 2nd, 2014]
- Pennsylvania Supreme Court rules police don't need warrants to search cars [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2014]
- Local police: Updated vehicle-search law still requires probable cause [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2014]
- Liberal Supreme Court Justice Comes To The Defense Of Scalia [Last Updated On: May 3rd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 3rd, 2014]
- Gerald Celente - Trends In The News - America's Spiritual Death - (1/20/14) - Video [Last Updated On: May 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 4th, 2014]
- Smartphones and the Fourth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: May 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 4th, 2014]
- Fourth Amendment Searches And Seizures - Video [Last Updated On: May 5th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 5th, 2014]
- Fourth Amendment Defined & Explained - Law [Last Updated On: May 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 6th, 2014]
- Enforcement Techniques For Violations Of The Fourth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: May 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 6th, 2014]
- I-Team: Do police seek search warrant friendly judges? [Last Updated On: May 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 7th, 2014]
- Is Big Brother Listening? Applying the Fourth Amendment in an Electronic Age - Video [Last Updated On: May 9th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 9th, 2014]
- It Costs Less to Care [Last Updated On: May 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 10th, 2014]
- The Fourth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: May 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 10th, 2014]
- Magistrate waxes poetic while rejecting Gmail search request [Last Updated On: May 11th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 11th, 2014]
- License reader lawsuit can be heard, appeals court rules [Last Updated On: May 15th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 15th, 2014]
- Seize the Rojo - Video [Last Updated On: May 16th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 16th, 2014]
- NSA Spying Has a Disproportionate Effect on Immigrants [Last Updated On: May 17th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 17th, 2014]
- Motorists sue Aurora, police in 2012 traffic stop after bank robbery [Last Updated On: May 17th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 17th, 2014]
- Judge Says NSA Phone Surveillance Likely Unconstitutional - Video [Last Updated On: May 21st, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 21st, 2014]
- New York Attorney Heath D. Harte Releases a Statement on Fourth Amendment Rights [Last Updated On: May 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 22nd, 2014]
- Bangor Area School District teachers vote no to random drug [Last Updated On: May 24th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 24th, 2014]
- The Fourth Amendment Rights - Video [Last Updated On: May 24th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 24th, 2014]
- I Don't Care About The Contitution, Take Your Fourth Amendment And Shove It The Hills Hotel - Video [Last Updated On: May 27th, 2014] [Originally Added On: May 27th, 2014]
- Lonestar1776 at Illegal Checkpoint 80 Miles Inside Border - Standing UP & Pushing Back! pt 2/2 - Video [Last Updated On: September 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 1st, 2014]
- Suit charges Daytona Beach's rental inspection program violates civil rights [Last Updated On: September 2nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 2nd, 2014]
- 4th Amendment - Laws.com [Last Updated On: September 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 6th, 2014]
- YOU CAN ARREST ME NOW (cops refuse) - Video [Last Updated On: September 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 6th, 2014]
- The Feds Explain How They Seized The Silk Road Servers [Last Updated On: September 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 8th, 2014]
- Defence asks judge in NYC to toss out bulk of evidence in Silk Road case as illegally obtained [Last Updated On: September 9th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 9th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: Does obtaining leaked data from a misconfigured website violate the CFAA? [Last Updated On: September 9th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 9th, 2014]
- Family of a mentally ill woman files lawsuit against San Mateo Co. after deadly shooting [Last Updated On: September 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 10th, 2014]
- Minnesota Supreme Court upholds airport drug case decision [Last Updated On: September 12th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 12th, 2014]
- Law Talk - Obamacare Rollout; Fourth Amendment, NSA Spying Stop & Frisk DUI Check Points lta041 - Video [Last Updated On: September 12th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 12th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: The posse comitatus case and changing views of the exclusionary rule [Last Updated On: September 15th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 15th, 2014]
- Guest: Why the privacy of a public employees cellphone matters [Last Updated On: September 16th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 16th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: Apples dangerous game [Last Updated On: September 19th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 19th, 2014]
- Judge expounds on privacy rights [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2014]
- Great privacy essay: Fourth Amendment Doctrine in the Era of Total Surveillance [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2014]
- The Fourth Amendment By Maison Erdman - Video [Last Updated On: September 20th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 20th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: When administrative inspections of businesses turn into massive armed police raids [Last Updated On: September 22nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 22nd, 2014]
- The chilling loophole that lets police stop, question and search you for no good reason [Last Updated On: September 23rd, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 23rd, 2014]
- E.O. 12333: End-Running the Fourth Amendment | The Dissenter [Last Updated On: September 25th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 25th, 2014]
- Fourth Amendment: The History Behind "Unreasonable ... [Last Updated On: September 25th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 25th, 2014]
- Pet Owners Look to Muzzle Police Who Shoot Dogs [Last Updated On: September 27th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 27th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: A few thoughts on Heien v. North Carolina [Last Updated On: September 29th, 2014] [Originally Added On: September 29th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: Third Circuit on the mosaic theory and Smith v. Maryland [Last Updated On: October 1st, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 1st, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: Third Circuit gives narrow reading to exclusionary rule [Last Updated On: October 2nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 2nd, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: Supreme Court takes case on duration of traffic stops [Last Updated On: October 2nd, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 2nd, 2014]
- Search & Seizure, Racial Bias: The American Law Journal on the Philadelphia CNN-News Affiliate WFMZ Monday, October 6 ... [Last Updated On: October 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 4th, 2014]
- Argument preview: How many brake lights need to be working on your car? [Last Updated On: October 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 4th, 2014]
- The 'Barney Fife Loophole' to the Fourth Amendment [Last Updated On: October 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 4th, 2014]
- Search & Seizure: A New Fourth Amendment for a New Generation? - Promo - Video [Last Updated On: October 4th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 4th, 2014]
- Lubbock Liberty Workshop With Arnold Loewy On The Fourth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: October 5th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 5th, 2014]
- Ap Government Fourth Amendment Project - Video [Last Updated On: October 5th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 5th, 2014]
- Volokh Conspiracy: Oral argument in Heien v. North Carolina [Last Updated On: October 6th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 6th, 2014]
- Feds Hacked Silk Road Without a Warrant? Perfectly Legal, Prosecutors Argue [Last Updated On: October 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 7th, 2014]
- Supreme Court Starts Term with Fourth Amendment Case [Last Updated On: October 7th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 7th, 2014]
- Feds Say That Even If FBI Hacked The Silk Road, Ulbricht's Rights Weren't Violated [Last Updated On: October 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 8th, 2014]
- Argument analysis: A simple answer to a deceptively simple Fourth Amendment question? [Last Updated On: October 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 8th, 2014]
- Mass Collection of U.S. Phone Records Violates the Fourth Amendment - Video [Last Updated On: October 8th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 8th, 2014]
- Leggett sides with civil liberties supporters [Last Updated On: October 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 10th, 2014]
- Search & Seizure / Car Stops: A 'New' Fourth Amendment for a New Generation? - Video [Last Updated On: October 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 10th, 2014]
- Broken Lights And The Fourth Amendment National Constitution Center - Video [Last Updated On: October 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 10th, 2014]
- The Fourth Amendment- The Maininator Period 4 - Video [Last Updated On: October 10th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 10th, 2014]
- Judge nukes Ulbricht's complaint about WARRANTLESS FBI Silk Road server raid [Last Updated On: October 11th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 11th, 2014]
- Montgomery County will not hold immigrants without probable cause -- Gazette.Net [Last Updated On: October 13th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 13th, 2014]
- Debate: Does Mass Phone Data Collection Violate The 4th Amendment? [Last Updated On: October 15th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 15th, 2014]
- Does the mass collection of phone records violate the Fourth Amendment? [Last Updated On: October 18th, 2014] [Originally Added On: October 18th, 2014]