Obama administration’s encryption concerns meant to start a debate

U.S. President Barack Obamas administration still believes in the use of encryption to protect digital information, even after top officials have questioned how law enforcement agencies will get access to data on encrypted devices, a White House advisor said.

There is no scenario in which the U.S. government wants weaker encryption, Michael Daniel, the White Houses cybersecurity coordinator, said Thursday.

But Obama and other officials have raised questions about how to deal with technology that puts information literally beyond the reach of law enforcement under any sort of due process, Daniel said during a discussion about encryption and law enforcement at the Information Technology and Innovation Foundation in Washington, D.C.

In recent months, FBI director James Comey, U.S. National Security Agency director Michael Rogers and Obama himself have all raised concerns about law enforcement access to encrypted communications.

The officials raised those concerns after moves by Apple and Google to include encryption on smartphone operating systems, in part in response to news reports about large-scale surveillance programs at the NSA. But the concerns were meant to kick start a broad public debate about the amount of data law enforcement agencies should have access to, Daniel said.

Daniel didnt offer any suggestions about how to allow police access to encrypted data without building back doors into devices, but he said its important for the U.S. to work out a process that is acceptable to police, to tech vendors and to the public. The U.S. needs to come up with a solution that it can show the rest of the world as an alternative to more invasive options being pushed by China and other countries, he said.

This is a problem thats worth a lot of graduate students time, he said.

The debate about law enforcement access to electronic devices isnt going away, with the growing adoption of the Internet of things, drones and autonomous vehicles, noted Daniel Castro, vice president at ITIF. Law enforcement agencies will have interest in similar levels of access to those technologies as it does to smartphones and other devices, he said.

Other speakers at the ITIF event questioned how a new U.S. policy could create a process for law enforcement agencies to get access to encrypted data without also exposing that data to cyberattackers.

So far, encrypted communications havent created much of a problem, with the U.S. Courts 2013 wiretap report showing only nine cases nationwide where encryption limited police from gaining access to information, said Amie Stepanovich, senior policy counsel at Access, a digital rights group.

Continue reading here:
Obama administration's encryption concerns meant to start a debate