A new German law requires every entity that holds private keys for others (e.g., bitcoin exchanges and/or bitcoin custodians) and that actively addresses the German market must become licensed as early as January 1, 2020. And to address the most common misconception right at the beginning: No, it absolutely not matter where your company is based. What matters is if you are addressing the German market with your services.
The law implementing the amendment to the fourth EU money laundering directive (Federal Law Gazette I of December 19, 2019, p. 2602) included the crypto deposit business as a new financial service in the KWG . Companies that want to provide these services require BaFins permission when the law comes into effect on January 1, 2020. However, the law provides for transitional provisions for companies that have already performed the transactions that are now subject to authorization before they came into force.
Despite the many open questions that are still unresolved, let me start this piece by stating that I am a general supporter of regulation if executed right. And I believe this new law could pave the way for Germany to become the Crypto Heaven of Europe, as especially large financial institutions and investors are in favor of regulated entities. But to also be honest right from the start, this will heavily depend on how regulators finally deal with questions as they arise. Even the best of intentions can still backfire on the German ecosystem if executed poorly. But, I am full of hope that this will not be the case, as the regulators and the industry appear to be working together more and more. And by working with, instead of against, each other, good regulatory decisions seem possible.
Taking everything into account, here are the four things I believe to be the main challenges regarding the new regulations:
There is no clear definition of what actively addressing the German market means; this will be decided on a case-by-case basis. By one possible interpretation, anyone operating a designated German website or offering German marketing material is likely to be actively addressing the German market. But if someone for whatever reason has a growing number of German customers without any official marketing, it could also be concluded you somehow MUST be actively addressing the German market (as otherwise you simply wouldnt be able to gain this many new customers from Germany).
As the French are currently sorting out their regulations as well, it would have been great if both countries would have agreed on potentially passporting their respective licenses, meaning that if you are licensed in Germany, you could also operate in France without applying for a new license (or registering, to be exact). Although we strongly believe that this will come soon, it would have been great to have this agreement right from the start.
For an outsider not familiar with German regulations and law, the means of implementation and the timelines might seem strange (although they are very clever in fact). In short, you are deemed to be a licensed provider as of January 1, 2020, provisionally and retroactively, if you state to the officials that you plan to apply for a license before March 31, 2020, and then hand in your application before November 30, 2020 (yes, it appears to ask you to go back in time). This also means that if you say you are going to apply for a license before March 31, 2020, and then dont hand in your application before November 30, 2020, you are deemed to have been illegal since January 1, 2020.
Furthermore, it also means that if you are conducting your business as you always have, you will most likely be deemed illegal since January 1, 2020. And that is a felony and not a misdemeanor. Although this is the case, some market players really seem to rely on a tactic called reverse solicitation (which means that basically a customer is free to choose whatever supplier he or she wants) and not apply for such a license.
I strongly believe that this is not the best idea, given the massive political implications of this new rule. As weve seen in the past, I would assume that Germanys Federal Financial Supervisory Authority (BaFin) will regulate pretty strictly in this case, as otherwise the new law would simply make no sense and would harm the German economy, which would make little sense from a German point of view.
Big improvements are needed on the communication side, especially regarding the international community as this is an international topic. Up until now, I have seen neither a direct translation of the law nor any advice in English from the regulators. Although this is advantageous for those of us who work in consultancy and advise exchanges and custodians in exactly these matters, this lack of clear communication from regulators is problematic in general.
I sometimes laugh at a very funny cultural thing. Germans are known to have a form and a rule for pretty much everything. And it is true, that is how we are (with all the pros and cons that come with it). So it feels bizarre that, in this instance, it is not the case; hence the need for us to work together with regulators in order to establish proper rules and regulations on the fly.
For example, MPC (multi-party computation) is not addressed in the new law yet; the question of multisignature issues is also still open among a myriad of different other, sometimes very specific issues. This lack of clarity makes a typical German feel pretty uncomfortable, as we are simply not used to that. What we have, at best, is a step-by-step approach with educated guesses and a lot of communication still to come.
Another interesting fact is the way custodians (tech providers) are dealing with these issues. According to a study carried out by Digital Assets Custody (to my knowledge the largest digital assets custodian comparison website on the internet), it seems as if most specialized infrastructure providers for digital assets custody seem to be avoiding regulation like the plague by stating that they would only serve as a tech provider and not as a custodian that needs to be regulated.
While I understand this avoidance approach, as regulation comes with its very own challenges, it seems shortsighted. On the one hand, I believe that regulation will ultimately evolve, concentrating on exchanges as a first step, but then they will come to focus on custodial services.
Depending on each entitys respective tech stack and business model, it seems possible to me that not only the exchange but also the custodian will ultimately be deemed regulated entities. So it is basically just a matter of time before the regulators come knocking. And as seen in the past, its usually a good idea to be ahead of the game.
It is interesting to see that the new law around custodianship functions as kind of a wake-up call for the industry, although the respective players should have been alert in regards to Germany beforehand. This goes back to the view of the BaFin that judged Bitcoin as a so-called Unit of Account, making it a financial instrument; therefore, everybody dealing with these financial instruments should already have the proper licenses. This means that if you were to operate a bitcoin exchange you would depending on the business model need a license as a multilateral trading facility, for example. The Berlin Court of Appeal expressed a different view of this in a court case, resulting in some confusion here.
With the introduction of the newly created term Krytowerte (direct translation would be crypto values), it is now clear that bitcoin is indeed considered to be a financial instrument and that every entity dealing with it will have to be regulated in the same manner as firms dealing with any other financial instruments.
As the respective licenses are subject to the specifics of the business model, it is hard to give some general information about what is needed. The custodian licensing will most likely require two fit and proper managing directors, 125,000 ($136,000) in starting capital plus setup costs of around 250,000350,000 ($272,000$380,000) and recurring yearly costs of 350,000 ($380,000). (These are rough estimations and can vary widely depending on your business model and various costs.)
All in all, the new law makes operating a digital assets business harder. But on the flipside, it also brings some degree of clarity and security to the people who interact with providers in the digital asset space.
Will everybody be happy with this new direction? No. But its a start.
This is an op ed by Dr. Sven Hildebrandt. Views expressed are his own and do not necessarily reflect those of Bitcoin Magazine or BTC Inc.
See the original post:
How the Latest German Regulations Target Bitcoin Exchanges and... - Bitcoin Magazine
- Drake Just Lost $500,000 in Bitcoin Betting on the NBA Finals - Decrypt - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin Plunges to $65K, Altcoins Bleed 10%-20% as Week Turns Ugly - CoinDesk - June 18th, 2024
- Should You Buy Bitcoin While It's Less Than $70,000? - The Motley Fool - June 18th, 2024
- First Bitcoin ETF to List on Australia's Bourse in Global Wave - Bloomberg - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin Move on the Horizon Following Rare Quiet Period, According to On-Chain Analyst - The Daily Hodl - June 18th, 2024
- $66K BTC price now 'critical' 5 things to know in Bitcoin this week - Cointelegraph - June 18th, 2024
- Breaking Bitcoin with Casey Rodarmor - What Bitcoin Did - June 18th, 2024
- Why The U.S. Should Focus On Bitcoin Mining Policy - Forbes - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin, Dogecoin, and Ethereum Volatility Drive $290 Million in Liquidations - Decrypt - June 18th, 2024
- Trump says he wants all remaining Bitcoin to be made in the US - Reuters - June 18th, 2024
- T-Mobile owner Deutsche Telekom will soon mine Bitcoin in addition to running nodes - The Block - June 18th, 2024
- The Bitcoin Halving: Everything you need to know - Coinbase - June 18th, 2024
- Crypto-Breakthrough Bill Could See Bitcoin, Ethereum, and BlockDAG Network Prices Skyrocket Very Soon - Yahoo Finance - June 18th, 2024
- Ethereum poised to 50% surge this year against Bitcoin Fractal analysis - Cointelegraph - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin nears $65,000 as the selling pressure continues - ForexLive - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin Price Falls Below $66,000, Bond Yields Weigh. Ether Awaits Crypto ETFs. - Barron's - June 18th, 2024
- Donald Trump wants US to rule Bitcoin mining industry - Cointelegraph - June 18th, 2024
- How This Bitcoin Developer Lost 25,000 BTC - BeInCrypto - June 18th, 2024
- MicroStrategy Increases Convertible Note Offering by 40% to $700M in Bitcoin Splurge - CoinDesk - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin Mining Cost At $86,700: Price To Surpass This Soon? - NewsBTC - June 18th, 2024
- 3 reasons why Bitcoin analysts believe BTC price recovery is overdue - Cointelegraph - June 18th, 2024
- Analysts Predict BTC Hitting $200,000 Next Year and $1 Million by 2033 'We Believe Bitcoin Is in a New Bull Cycle ... - Bitcoin.com News - June 18th, 2024
- Leak Reveals Joe Biden Could Be Planning A Crypto Coup Amid Bitcoin, Ethereum And XRP Price Swings - Forbes - June 18th, 2024
- Drake on Brink of $1M Bitcoin Loss as NHL and NBA Bets Sour - CoinDesk - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin, Binance, Ethereum, Solana, and Ripple: The Biggest Crypto News of the Past Week - Cointribune EN - June 18th, 2024
- Bitcoin price pressured by whales, long-term holders, and miners: Bitfinex - Crypto Briefing - June 18th, 2024
- Michael Saylor Reacts to Bitcoin Dropping Below $67,000 by Sharing Crucial Advice - U.Today - June 18th, 2024
- Top 3 Price Prediction Bitcoin, Ethereum, Ripple: Bitcoin retesting its major resistance level - FXStreet - June 18th, 2024
- Donald Trump Speaks On Bitcoin Mining, Wants 'All The Remaining Bitcoin To Be Made In The USA' - Benzinga - June 18th, 2024
- Almost $500M in Liquidations as Bitcoin (BTC) Dumped to $64K and Alts Bled Out - CryptoPotato - June 18th, 2024
- Top 3 Price Prediction Bitcoin, Ethereum, Ripple: BTC likely to take markets on a rollercoaster - FXStreet - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin in the red to end the week after better-than-expected May jobs report - CNBC - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin Could Lift to $83K in the Coming Days, Analyst Says - CoinDesk - June 10th, 2024
- Best Places to Buy Bitcoin in 2024 - The Motley Fool - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin to reach $150,000 if Trump wins presidency: Standard Chartered - CNBC - June 10th, 2024
- Report: Speculation Returns as Bitcoin Market Shows Signs of Recovery Market Updates Bitcoin News - Bitcoin.com News - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin And The Future Of The Lightning Network - Forbes - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin Braced To Go 'Parabolic' After 'Amazing' 2017 Price Breakout Repeat - Forbes - June 10th, 2024
- Is Bitcoin On Track to Make a Big Move and Hit $100,000 in 2024? - The Motley Fool - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin network transaction fees temporarily soar to nearly $52 - Cointelegraph - June 10th, 2024
- XRP Reached Multi-Month Low, Solana (SOL) on Strongest Support, Bitcoin (BTC) Price Drop Is Better Than You Think - U.Today - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin Dips Below $70K, Reaches $68450 Low, $86M in BTC Longs Liquidated Markets and Prices Bitcoin News - Bitcoin.com News - June 10th, 2024
- Demand Growth for Bitcoin Surges: What Does This Mean? - CryptoPotato - June 10th, 2024
- First Mover Americas: Bitcoin Futures Positions Top Record $37B as Analysts Predict Bitcoin Surge to $83K - CoinDesk - June 10th, 2024
- Crypto for Advisors: Layer 2s and the Evolution of Bitcoin - CoinDesk - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin Wyckoff pattern eyes $85K, but BTC price must close the week above this level first - Cointelegraph - June 10th, 2024
- Visualizing the 15 Most Valuable Bitcoin Addresses - Visual Capitalist - June 10th, 2024
- First Mover Americas: Bitcoin Fluctuates Around $71K, Consolidating This Week's Rally - CoinDesk - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin, Ethereum, and XRP Price Prediction: Will Bulls Make A Comeback This Week? - Coinpedia Fintech News - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin volatility hovering within 6% of record low levels - Cointelegraph - June 10th, 2024
- Why Did the Bitcoin Price Crash Below $70K and is the Bleeding Over? (Bitcoin Price Analysis) - CryptoPotato - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin Halving: How It Works And Why It Matters - Forbes - June 10th, 2024
- Mexican Billionaire Says to Buy Bitcoin, Musk vs. Nakamoto, and More Week in Review The Weekly Bitcoin News - Bitcoin.com News - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin: Etfs Accumulate 19 Consecutive Days Of Inflows! Ibit Leading The Way! - Cointribune EN - June 10th, 2024
- From AI to Bitcoin Mining: Heres a Timeline of Tethers Latest Investments - CryptoPotato - June 10th, 2024
- Forget Bitcoin: 3 Cryptocurrencies to Consider Instead - The Motley Fool - June 10th, 2024
- Key Reason Why Bitcoin Price Has Not Topped $70K Named by Top Trader - U.Today - June 10th, 2024
- Standard Chartered Sees Bitcoin Soaring to $150,000 by Year-End If Trump Wins Presidency - Yahoo Finance - June 10th, 2024
- Peter Brandt Predicts Bitcoin Bull Market With BTC Potentially Reaching $150000 Markets and Prices Bitcoin News - Bitcoin.com News - June 10th, 2024
- Polymarket Bets Show Growing Confidence in Trump's Election Victory Over Biden Bitcoin News - Bitcoin.com News - June 10th, 2024
- Bitcoin Tops $65,000 as Fund Inflows, Upcoming Halving Event Fuel RallyKey Level to Watch - Investopedia - March 5th, 2024
- Coinbase Stock Jumps. A Bitcoin, Crypto Frenzy Is Fueling Its Rally. - Barron's - March 5th, 2024
- Bitcoin Tops $67,000 on ETF-Led Demand Even With GBTC Outflows - Yahoo Finance - March 5th, 2024
- Bitcoin Has $70,000 In Its Sights: Stocks to Watch - Yahoo Finance - March 5th, 2024
- Are The Bitcoin ETFs Eating Golds Lunch? - Forbes - March 5th, 2024
- BlackRock looking to include Bitcoin exposure in other funds - CryptoSlate - March 5th, 2024
- Bitcoin Price Explained: Why the Crypto Is Surging Back to All-Time Highs - Markets Insider - March 5th, 2024
- Bitcoin ETF snapshot: Record volumes lead to second-best weekly inflows - Blockworks - March 5th, 2024
- MicroStrategy to Offer $600 Million in Convertible Notes to Buy More Bitcoin - Bloomberg - March 5th, 2024
- US Government Continues Bitcoin Seizures, Controls Nearly 1% of Circulating Supply - Bitcoin Magazine - March 5th, 2024
- Bitcoin value climbs above $65000, one step from all-time record - Euronews - March 5th, 2024
- What's driving the bitcoin surge? Experts weigh in. - ABC News - March 5th, 2024
- Bitwise CIO Says Bitcoin Could Top $200K This Year Citing 'Too Much Demand, Not Enough Supply' Markets and ... - Bitcoin.com News - March 5th, 2024
- MicroStrategy will use proceeds from convertible note sale to add to bitcoin stash - Blockworks - March 5th, 2024
- Is the Bitcoin halving the right time to invest in BTC? - Cointelegraph - March 5th, 2024
- These multi-billion-dollar banks are joining the bitcoin fray as price breaks $67000 - TheStreet - March 5th, 2024
- An Interesting (and Cheaper) Way to Play Bitcoin - RealMoney - March 5th, 2024
- Restricting access to growing bitcoin ETFs becoming 'hard to justify' - Blockworks - March 5th, 2024
- Bitcoin (BTC) Price To Hit New ATH in Next Few Hours, What To Expect Next? - Coinpedia Fintech News - March 5th, 2024
- Its Happening!Huge Mystery Whale And Sudden $65,000 Bitcoin Price Surge Fuels Secret Sovereign Bid And Tech Billionaire Predictions - Forbes - March 5th, 2024