The SEC Has Rejected Every Bitcoin ETF. This Firm Thinks It Has a Solution – Coindesk

One company thinks it knows how to get a bitcoin exchange-traded fund (ETF) approved by U.S. regulators.

Wilshire Phoenix, a relatively young financial firm in New York, filed to launch theUnited States Bitcoin & Treasury Investment Trust ETF in May with NYSE Arca. At that point, a dozen bitcoin ETF proposals had already been swatted down by the U.S. Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) including nine in one day. But unlike other ETF applications, Wilshire Phoenixs ETF will invest in both bitcoin and U.S. Treasury securities, commonly referred to as T-bills.

The SEC is currently reviewing the application.

Our proposed bitcoin-related ETF is quite different from those that have previously been submitted to the Commission for approval, Wilshire Phoenix founder and managing partner William Herrmann said in a phone interview. To name just a few distinctions, the composition of the Trust is very different. Our Trust is a multi-asset trust (bitcoin and T-Bills), as opposed to just bitcoin.

The SEC has long been hesitant to approve an ETF with exposure to digital assets, citing the markets relatively young age and the possible risks to investors. The agency has rejected a number of proposals, while other applicants haveproactively withdrawn their filings.

Herrmann says the Wilshire ETF has several mechanisms to address these concerns.

The Trust itself will automatically rebalance itself monthly to address possible concerns about bitcoins price volatility, Herrmann explained. Essentially, if bitcoins price volatility increases, the index will reduce its exposure to the cryptocurrency and instead increase its exposure to Treasury bills. As bitcoins volatility falls, the opposite occurs.

The weighting will be transparent, with the index being shown on Bloomberg and Thomson Reuters portals, he said.

The CMEs Bitcoin Reference Rate will provide the data for bitcoins price in the Trust, rather than use an in-house price method or one from any related party, he added.

Wilshire Phoenix is also hoping to address SEC concerns about market manipulation by using a surveillance sharing agreement, one component the regulator stressed was needed when rejecting a recent bitcoin ETF application. Herrmann said:

The CME has surveillance sharing agreements with both the CME futures market as well as the relevant portion of the spot market that forms the basis for the Trusts bitcoin values. This addresses the SEC concerns about the lack of surveillance sharing agreements with the relevant spot market, which is something previous applicants have not been able to address.

Most recently, the SECdenied Bitwise Asset Managements fund. Ina whopping 112-page order published Oct. 9, the regulator said surveillance-sharing agreements were necessary and market manipulation remains a real concern.

As recently as September, SEC Chairman Jay Clayton said that while progress has been made in the space,the market manipulation question had not been resolved.

For Wilshire Phoenixs proposal, the SECbegan accepting comments on the proposal in June, though a final decision is still months away. The agency is currently accepting comments on the proposal through Nov. 12, 2019.

Herrmann is optimistic about the ETF proposals chances, saying we developed the ETF consistent with investor protection as well as fair, orderly and efficient markets.

SEC image via Shutterstock

See the article here:

The SEC Has Rejected Every Bitcoin ETF. This Firm Thinks It Has a Solution - Coindesk