qBitcoin: A Way of Making Bitcoin Quantum-Computer Proof? – IEEE Spectrum

A new quantum cryptography-based Bitcoin standard has been proposed that could harden the popular cryptocurrency against the advent of full-fledged quantum computers. Bitcoin as it now exists involves traditional public key cryptography and thus could conceivably be hacked by a future quantum computer strong enough to break it. However, quantum cryptography, which is based not on difficult math problems but the fundamental laws of physics, is expected to be strong enough to withstand even quantum computer-powered attacks.

The proposal, dubbed qBitcoin, posits transmission of quantum cryptographic keys between a remitter and a receiver of the eponomous named cryptocurrency, qBitcoin. The system would use provably secure protocols such as theBB84quantum key distribution scheme.

To exchange qBitcoin, then, requires that there be a transmission network in place that can send and receive bits of quantum information, qubits. And that is no mean feat, considering it typically involves preserving the polarization states of individual photons across thousands of kilometers. To date, there are five knownquantum key distributionnetworks in the United States, Switzerland, Austria, and Japan. China is working ontheir ownmassive 2000-km link, as well. And a number of satellite-to-satellite and satellite-to-ground quantum key distribution networks are alsobeingdevelopedandprototyped.

Which is to say that qBitcoin or something like it could not be scaled up today. But if the quantum computer singularity is approaching, in which a powerful enough machinecould threaten existing cryptography standards, quantum cryptography would be an essential ingredient of the post-Y2Q age. So existing quantum key distribution networks might at least serve as outposts in a burgeoning global quantum network, like Western Union stations in the early days of the telegraph.

Some things about qBitcoin might appear the same to any Bitcoin user today. Bitcoin is a peer to peer system, and qBitcoin is also peer to peer, says Kazuki Ikeda, qBitcoins creator and PhD student in physics at Osaka University in Japan.Hesays compared to Bitcoin, qBitcoin would offer comparable or perhaps enhanced levels of privacy, anonymity, and security. (That said, his paper that makes this claim is still under peer review.)

However, the lucrative profession ofBitcoin mining, under Ikedas protocol, would be very different than what it is today. Transactions would still need to be verified and secured. Butinstead of todays system of acryptographic puzzles, qBitcoins security would rely on a 2001proposalfor creating aquantum digital signature.Such a signature would rely on the laws of quantum physics to secure the qBitcoin ledger from tampering or hacking.

Ikeda's proposal is certainly not the first to suggest a quantum-cryptographic improvement onclassical-cryptography-based digital currencies. Other proposals in2010,2016,and evenearlier this yearhave also offered up variations on the theme. All work to mitigate against the danger large-scale quantum computers would represent to Bitcoin.

Of course, not every solution to the quantum singularity is as promising as every other. A person going by the handle amluto criticized Ikedas qBitcoin proposal onaprominent message boardlast week. (amluto claimed to be author of one of aprevious quantum currency proposalsfrom 2010presumably the 2010 proposals co-author Andrew Lutomirski, althoughIEEE Spectrumwas unable to confirm this supposition at press time.)

This is nonsense It's like saying that you can transmit a file by mailing a USB stick, which absolutely guarantees that you, the sender, no longer have the original file. That's wrongall that mailing a USB stick guarantees is that you don't have the USB stick any more, not that you didn't keep a copy of the contents. Similarly, quantum teleportation eats the input state but says nothing about any other copies of the input state that may exist.

Ikeda says he disagrees with the analogy. The point, he says, is that there are no other copies of the input state as it's called abovein other words of the quantum keys that secure qBitcoin. So, Ikeda says, qBitcoin is safe just like Bitcoin is safe today.

But one day, thanks to quantum computers, Bitcoin, will no longer be safe. Someone will needto save it. And, no matter who devises the winning protocol, the thing that threatens Bitcoinmay in fact also be the thing that comes to its rescue: The cagey qubit.

IEEE Spectrums general technology blog, featuring news, analysis, and opinions about engineering, consumer electronics, and technology and society, from the editorial staff and freelance contributors.

Sign up for the Tech Alert newsletter and receive ground-breaking technology and science news from IEEE Spectrum every Thursday.

The Beijing-Shanghai project will form the backbone of the nations quantum communications network 26Oct2016

What is a blockchain and why is it the future of the web? 8Jul2015

New 53-kilometer record for quantum cryptography through the air could enable a 24/7 space-based quantum Internet 24Jul

While the fictional geniuses in HBOs Silicon Valley aim to reinvent the Internet, Mozilla and the NSF hope prize money will attract real-world innovations 23Aug

Organizations, organisms, and communication networks all have similar growth dynamics 18Aug

Annual Las Vegas gathering of white-hat hackers breaks into e-voting and registration systems, sometimes in just a few hours 3Aug

It looks a lot different than its decentralized predecessors. Can it last? 30Jun

This weeks Ukrainian malware attack cribbed from last months WannaCry ransomware outbreakbut foreshadows worse to come 30Jun

Mouser and Grant Imahara team up with the creative minds at WIRED Brand Lab to take a look at the modern city

Qudits can have 10 or more quantum states simultaneously compared to just two for qubits 28Jun

Record distance for quantum entanglement set at more than 1,200 km 15Jun

The human neocortex learns and recognizes new songs with amazing efficiency. See how it works 10Jun

Researchers publish taxonomy of trolls, sybils, and other online troublemakers 9Jun

The Pied Piper of the TV show's fictional quest to reinvent the Internet trails the progress of MaidSafe and the University of Michigan 9Jun

Enel talks a blockchain energy market while advocating incremental change in the sector 24May

The networking trick made famous by Bitcoin could make car-to-cloud communication easier and more secure 24May

But would a digital cybertreaty of the future bind Redmond to operate Windows XP as a public utility? 16May

Owlet provides new parents with much-needed sleep knowing that their infants heart rate and oxygen levels are constantly and effectively monitored.

The fictional entrepreneur of "Silicon Valley" sets out his plan to reinvent the Internet, and decentralized Web pioneer Brewster Kahle says it sounds very familiar 8May

Sovrin joins Hyperledger Indy to build a permissioned open ledger for identity management 2May

Read the original post:
qBitcoin: A Way of Making Bitcoin Quantum-Computer Proof? - IEEE Spectrum