Health care decision leaves Americans divided

The Supreme Courts long-awaited ruling on the Affordable Care Act known to both admirers and critics as Obamacare has been characterized as a compromise, meaning it made almost everyone a little bit happy and a little bit sad.

Looks like they split the baby on this one, said one political activist in Denver.

Even CNN and Fox News were confused, announcing originally that the law had been struck down, based on partial information saying that the Court had ruled that the attempt to justify the Act on the grounds of interstate commerce was unfounded. But Chief Justice John Roberts, a staunch conservative, found a way to uphold the law on the basis of the governments right to levy taxes.

Compromises have been few and far between in this increasingly polarized political landscape, and so perhaps we should all welcome this rare event.

But judging by the level of anger surrounding the ruling, matched by the almost total ignorance of its provisions and effects among the general population, nothing has been solved by Thursdays decision. Instead, the battle will continue right up until Nov. 6, when voters can finally have their say.

A recent USA Today/Gallup poll indicated that Americans are evenly divided 46 percent to 46 percent on whether or not they favor the Affordable Care Act. The split reflects the deep chasm between Democrats and Republicans: 85 percent of Republicans want the Act repealed in its entirety, while 65 percent of Democrats want the bill maintained or expanded.

This is not a debate over health care, or even about the proper role of government in our society. It is politics, pure and simple. Republican challenger Mitt Romney himself the author of a similar health care bill in Massachusetts, lost no time in weighing in.

"If we want to get rid of Obamacare, we're going to have to replace President Obama," Romney told a news conference on Thursday.

Over the past several months, I have spoken to dozens of people about the health care act. Reactions are split fairly neatly along party lines, although neither side had a monopoly on logic.

This is not America, fumed Dr. Debra Russell, a self-described neuropsychotherapist in Beaufort, South Carolina. This is socialism, communism. I never thought I would see this sort of thing in my country. It is as bad as FDR.

More:

Health care decision leaves Americans divided

Related Posts

Comments are closed.