Jimmy Jenkins/KJZZ
Joanna Duca, co-owner of Brush & Nib.
STEVE GOLDSTEIN: But first, the Arizona Supreme Court is allowing a calligraphy studio to refuse to sell their custom wedding invitations to LGBTQ couples. It's a blow to Phoenix's anti-discrimination ordinance. The decision was 4-3, and the majority said the ruling applied only to this company and only to their wedding invitations. But the decision raises all sorts of questions. We'll get some legal analysis in just a few minutes. But here to report on the reaction is KJZZ's Bret Jaspers. Good morning.
BRET JASPERS: Good morning.
GOLDSTEIN: So the people who brought the case with the owners of Brush & Nib Studios, they lost in lower court.
JASPERS: That's right. The two owners of Brush & Nib are Joanna Duka and Breanna Koski. They say making their wedding invitations is an artistic act and they shouldn't have to make custom invitations for same-sex couples because that would be compelling speech that's against their religious beliefs. The majority of justices on the state Supreme Court agreed with them. Here's Duka.
JOANNA DUKA (audio): Breanna and I are thankful and relieved that the court has upheld, not just our freedom, but the freedom of other speakers to choose what they say and what they don't say.
GOLDSTEIN: So what does this mean then for Phoenix's anti-discrimination ordinance?
JASPERS: Well the mayor and the city's lawyer said this was a narrow ruling, and the ordinance still stands. Here's a direct quote from the decision: "Our holding is limited to plaintiff's creation of custom wedding invitations that are materially similar to those contained in the record. We do not recognize a blanket exemption from the ordinance for all of plaintiff's business operations.".
GOLDSTEIN: So this is a narrow ruling by the court, then?
JASPERS: Well it seems so, but I'm really curious as to what your legal guest will say. The dissenting judges did not agree that this would only affect this one business. In fact, they thought this opened the door to discrimination in many other contexts. And the attorney for the calligrapher is Jonathan Scruggs, also said the analysis was broad. He's with the Christian Legal Group Alliance Defending Freedom.
GOLDSTEIN: Ok, so that's the group based in Scottsdale that represented the Colorado baker in a similar recent Supreme Court case.
JASPERS: Yeah, and they're also defending a florist in Washington state who refused a gay couple. Here's what Scruggs said about the ruling being brought.
JONATHAN SCRUGGS (audio): The analysis the court put forth is broad. Protecting the freedom of speech and freedom of religion. So that's what the ruling did. It protected the speech, as Phoenix acknowledged, that what our clients do is create speech.
JASPERS: But I talked to Brendan Mahoney. He's a lawyer who actually co-wrote Phoenix's anti-discrimination ordinance. His view is that this is a case of a certain group being denied, not the case of a message that's being compelled.
BRENDAN MAHONEY (audio): That was part of the question, is writing an invitation free speech or not? And if it is free speech, even free speech has its limits. In this case, it isn't a particular message. It's a broad class of people that are being discriminated against. And that's the distinction.
JASPERS: So Mahoney told me that it isn't that someone is coming to the calligraphers and asking them to write a different message than they typically write. It's asking them to provide a service that they're providing to the rest of the public and the calligraphers say each wedding invitation is unique and their unique artistic vision is at play. So that's why they say the city was compelling speech.
GOLDSTEIN: So how did Mayor Kate Gallego respond?
JASPERS: Well she wouldn't say, Gallego wouldn't say whether or not she's worried about other businesses bringing similar cases against the city. She framed it as part of a long-term struggle against discrimination.
KATE GALLEGO (audio): This case was never about one business refusing to acknowledge the humanity of our LGBTQ community. It was about whether we accept discrimination in our community. The ordinance is not just something nice to have on paper. It's something we have seen been used to lodge complaints by community members who have, who feel they have been unfairly targeted.
GOLDSTEIN: Bret, finally, this was in state court. Are there federal court appeals possible here?
JASPERS: Well, the city's lawyer kept repeating that they're reviewing the decision and reviewing their options. He wouldn't really say what the next steps even were.
GOLDSTEIN: KJZZ's Bret Jaspers, thank you.
JASPERS: You're welcome.
LAUREN GILGER: And now for a legal analysis of the case, we are joined by Professor Gregg Leslie, executive director of the First Amendment clinic at ASU's law school. Good morning, Gregg.
GREGG LESLIE: Good morning.
GILGER: OK. So let's start with that question that Bret brought up there. So the court says, the majority of the court said this was a narrow ruling, some of the dissenting judges disagreed. How narrow is this?
LESLIE: Well, it seems like it has to be a fairly narrow ruling. They very carefully parsed through whether the writing of an invitation is expressive, is speech basically. And they seem to have narrowed this to cases where somebody is expressing their opinion about something. Now, to agree with the outcome, you'd have to believe that a calligrapher, or, in the other case, a cake decorator, is actually communicating their thoughts on a wedding, to agree with the outcome, it seems. I've never thought of a calligrapher in that way but maybe some people do. I've never received a wedding invitation and thought, "Oh great, the calligrapher approves of this wedding."
GILGER: But could you see this case being used to protect a different company who decided not to sell its different sort of artistic products to a gay couple or somebody else that they didn't want to?
LESLIE: Well, you're kind of touching on an important distinction. If it's about just selling a product to a couple, they would still say that falls, that is, the law is applicable there. If they're compelled to create speech, then yes, other businesses would probably object on the same grounds. It's that idea of being compelled to say something that's critical.
GILGER: Yeah. So this is a case, like Bret mentioned, that is being carried out across the country. We talked a lot about the Colorado baker case, we've covered that on The Show, and there's another one in Washington. The thought is that one of these cases will end up at the Supreme Court at some point. What are your views on that, and could it be this case?
LESLIE: Well it's strange, I don't know if the Supreme Court has an appetite to take these cases. When they considered Masterpiece Cake Shop, they really went out of their way to say "we don't want to consider this right now." Even after they took it, then they punted it back for the strangest of reasons. So I'm not sure if they're anxious to take it, and a further complication is that the U.S. Supreme Court won't review a state constitutional decision. So if the state Supreme Court decided it purely on First Amendment grounds, the U.S. Supreme Court might take it. But this court went out of its way to talk about the Arizona constitution, and they kind of pegged it to the Arizona constitution and the U.S. Supreme Court won't review the Arizona constitution.
GILGER: Right. Ok, so I want to, in the last few minutes we have here, dig into the First Amendment issue right at hand. So, what is considered free speech, religious speech, and what is not, in general, in these cases? What did the lower courts rule that ruled in favor of the city's ordinance?
LESLIE: Yeah. And I think there is no solid answer to that. That's why cases like this go to appellate courts. I would not have thought that writing out an invitation when, it's somebody else's wedding invitation, you're not really expressing anything, you're not welcoming people to a wedding, you're just providing the artistic touch on an invitation. I would not have thought that was speech in the sense that you could decide who or who not to work with based on that. So there is no clear standard, but you have to look at how much expression is involved in something and whether they're actually trying to communicate something. So, regardless of how it came out in this case, I think there are a lot of cases where somebody really engaged in artistic output could say that their rights are violated by having to comply with a law like this. And those will be tricky situations and there's no clear bright line rule that will tell us which ones, how those will come out at any particular time.
GILGER: Is this common that nondiscrimination ordinances like this come into conflict with First Amendment issues?
LESLIE: Well you saw it all the time, 50 years ago. In the 60s, when there were groups saying they didn't want to have to let African Americans stay in their hotels or sit at their lunch counters, and they would often try to claim Christian beliefs that justified that. So we saw it all the time then, we thought that era was over, I think. But then when cities started passing gay rights measures, and a lot of religious groups feel that's objectionable, it's kind of arisen again in this context, and it seems to be limited to this context.
GILGER: Alright. That's Gregg Leslie, executive director of the First Amendment clinic at ASU's law school. Gregg, thank you for coming in.
LESLIE: Thank you.
Read more:
Reactions Mixed After Brush & Nib Ruling - KJZZ
- Turkey's crackdown on freedom of speech intensifies [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Bill of Rights Transcript Text - National Archives and ... [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech (Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy) [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- 3 Muslims shot dead by Atheist || #muslimlivesmatter - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Media Studies 104A - 2015-02-10 - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- USA Freedom of Speech and Jesus Christ - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- France Arrests French Comedian Dieudonne 3 Days After Charlie Hebdo Freedom of Speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Charlie Hebdo's "Freedom of Speech" - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- John Robertson on Greg Shapiro's United States of Europe - S3Ep01 - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- The Illuminati: The Freedom of Speech 2015 Conspiracy - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Muslims oppose insult to Islam in the name of freedom of speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- RE: HannibalTheVictor13's resentment over thunderf00t and his "freedom of speech". - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Policy update restricts demonstrations [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- Italian senators pass bill criminalizing denial of genocides [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- Michael Buerk Interview - Freedom of Speech & Paris Attacks - Video [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- 'Freedom Of Speech' Topic Tuesday #12 - Video [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- One dead after shots fired at Copenhagen freedom of speech meeting [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Shots Fired at Copenhagen Free Speech Event: Reports [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- One man dead and three policemen wounded at freedom of speech seminar in Denmark [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen caf: two gunmen in terror attack at freedom of speech event [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- One dead in gun attack on Danish freedom of speech meeting [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Free Speech Debate Still Alive After Attack in Denmark [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Esau uses Freedom of Speech as a weapon! - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen attacks an 'affront to freedom of speech': Tony Abbott [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen suspect known to police [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen police kill suspect linked to two fatal attacks [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech and Freedom of Press - Lincoln University [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen Shooting: Deadly attack at free speech meeting with cartoonist who depicted Muh - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Shots fired at Copenhagens Krudttoenden cafe free speech event a report - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Media Studies 104A - 2015-02-12 - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- WallBuilders Live 2015-02-11 Wednesday - Freedom of Speech on College Campuses - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Yisrael Beytenu at Charlie Hebdo freedom of speech protest - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- TOI debate on freedom of speech wows Kolkata - The Times ... [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Muslims Killing Atheists! - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- AP Top Stories February 14 P - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Duck Dynasty's Phil Robertson to Receive Freedom of Speech Award [Last Updated On: February 17th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 17th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech, but... SHOTS - Video [Last Updated On: February 17th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 17th, 2015]
- Letters to the editor: We must do more to stop terrorists [Last Updated On: February 18th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 18th, 2015]
- Freedom Of Speech Naam Ki Koi Chiz Hoti Hai - Alia Bhatt On AIB Controversy - Video [Last Updated On: February 18th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 18th, 2015]
- DoomShow,Freedom of Speech under attack by Terrrorists - Video [Last Updated On: February 18th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 18th, 2015]
- Greenpeace activist refutes govt charge of being anti-national [Last Updated On: February 19th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 19th, 2015]
- Jailed Al Jazeera journalist concerned about freedom of speech [Last Updated On: February 19th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 19th, 2015]
- Fan claims municipal police violating freedom of speech [Last Updated On: February 19th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 19th, 2015]
- Jailed journalist concerned about freedom of speech [Last Updated On: February 19th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 19th, 2015]
- Denmark: Police launch manhunt for Copenhagen cafe shooter - Video [Last Updated On: February 19th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 19th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech denied outside of Skillet concert Pittsburgh - Video [Last Updated On: February 19th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 19th, 2015]
- Alex Jones is Right! Snowden is Right! Government Crooks Via FaceBook! - Video [Last Updated On: February 21st, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 21st, 2015]
- "McCann Trolling" v "Freedom of Speech" - Video [Last Updated On: February 21st, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 21st, 2015]
- Aamir Khan disapproves AIB Roast, KJo reacts [Last Updated On: February 22nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 22nd, 2015]
- South Africa: Post the State of the Nation Address [Last Updated On: February 23rd, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 23rd, 2015]
- The Great Purge of Free Speech Has Begun............ - Video [Last Updated On: February 23rd, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 23rd, 2015]
- Big Brother Watch calls for reform of social media communications laws [Last Updated On: February 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 24th, 2015]
- Comment on Have an opinion? Stuff it! by boh-liao [Last Updated On: February 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 24th, 2015]
- Sports Hotline: What happened to freedom of speech - have Rangers fans lost their right to offend? [Last Updated On: February 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 24th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech: Canadians support Charlie Hebdos choice to publish images of Prophet Muhammad [Last Updated On: February 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 24th, 2015]
- Should there be limitations on freedom of speech? - Video [Last Updated On: February 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 24th, 2015]
- Topic Tuesday #39 - Freedom of Speech? (Minecraft Survival Games Gameplay) - Video [Last Updated On: February 24th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 24th, 2015]
- DW Freedom of Speech Award for Raif Badawi [Last Updated On: February 25th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 25th, 2015]
- THROWDOWN THURSDAY: The Four Causes of Anti-Israelism [Last Updated On: February 26th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 26th, 2015]
- FCC Reinstates Net Neutrality, Protecting Open Internet [Last Updated On: February 27th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 27th, 2015]
- CPDP 2015: Online privacy versus freedom of speech. Balancing rights in the EU context. - Video [Last Updated On: February 27th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 27th, 2015]
- Net neutrality lobby victorious after FCC ruling [Last Updated On: February 27th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 27th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech means tolerating opposing viewpoints [Last Updated On: March 2nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 2nd, 2015]
- The Death of Freedom of Speech on the Internet - Video [Last Updated On: March 2nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 2nd, 2015]
- Dangerman - Freedom Of Speech - Video [Last Updated On: March 2nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 2nd, 2015]
- Rebel Ratepayer Raps 4 Freedom of Speech in City of Melton, Melbourne - Video [Last Updated On: March 2nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 2nd, 2015]
- Students stand up for free speech at UI [Last Updated On: March 2nd, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 2nd, 2015]
- John Kerry asked to act on murder of Avijit Roy [Last Updated On: March 3rd, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 3rd, 2015]
- Not so Charlie now? [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2015]
- ISIS Supporters Threaten "Charlie Hedbo style" Attack Against Twitter Employees [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2015]
- AIB trying hard about freedom of speech - Video [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2015]
- Freedom of Speech situation in Bangladesh BBC World Service discussion - Video [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2015]
- Noam Chomsky on Freedom of Speech and Anti-Fascism [full] - Video [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2015]
- AND..Y we should stand up for freedom of speech | AIB Roast | Delhi Elections | AAP - Video [Last Updated On: March 4th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 4th, 2015]
- Vclav Havel Fellowship programme helps young journalists from post-Soviet bloc states [Last Updated On: March 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 5th, 2015]
- Murderers condemned as message of peace is North Herts conferences priority [Last Updated On: March 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 5th, 2015]
- four freedoms speech - FDR - Video [Last Updated On: March 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 5th, 2015]
- Watch what the youth feels about the AIB Roast Controversy & so called "freedom of speech" - Video [Last Updated On: March 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 5th, 2015]
- freedom of speech eminem remix - Video [Last Updated On: March 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 5th, 2015]
- Freedom of speech has no limits- - Video [Last Updated On: March 5th, 2015] [Originally Added On: March 5th, 2015]