Flying around social media yesterdaywere cheersthat Oxford University had issued a Statement on the Importance of Free Speech in response to a motion from the Oxford Student Union allegedly to ban ableist, classist and misogynist reading lists.
Heres Richard Dawkins on Twitter, for example:
I checked out the widely circulatedOxford Blue article linked to in Dawkins and others tweets, as well as theOxford Studentarticle first reporting on the Student Union motion. Though there were a few snippets here and there, neither article included or linked to the whole text of the motion, or even a substantial block of it.
And what of the Statement on the Importance of Free Speech that Oxford University released, according to the May 3rdOxford Blue article? Fortunately, the authors ofthe article included the entire text of that statement. However, it appears to be the exact same text already posted last year on at least a couple of Oxford sitesand released at least as early as May, 2017. Its not clear what actually happened here. Perhaps the university simply referred the journalists atOxford Blue to this pre-existing statement. [Update: according to the reporter, yes, this is what happened.]
Oxford Blue also reports that the university (they dont specify who) said, I can confirm that the University has no plans to censor reading materials assigned by our academics.
Censor reading materials? Is that what the students were calling for? Not exactly.
Jenny Saville, Stare III (detail)
A fellow twitterer answered my request for the actual motion, and from the looks of it, the students were basically aiming forfour things:
What to make of these demands? The first thing to note is that none of this is censorship. So, for the university to say that it has no plans to censor reading materials is not, strictly speaking, to reject the student union motion. The closest we get to censorship in the motion is in the condemnation called for in #4, above. That isnt technically censorship, but it may have similar effects (I dont know, as I dont know anything about those particular offices or whether Oxford faculty care aboutwhether they condemn their reading selections). [Note: in light of the correction of #4, above, I think it is safe to say that #4 does not come close to constituting censorship.] #2 might strike some as censorship but it seems pro-freedom to me, for if its effect would be to give students more choicehere, not to take a course they otherwise would have been required to.
(In one line in the original document, the students complain about the lack of criminalization of certain forms of biased speech, but what they end up calling for from Oxford isnt the criminalization of speech.)
The extent to which these demands are anti-free speech turns in part on what material is actually covered by it. I dont know enough about the legal context to know exactly what kinds of texts would be picked out by intended or likely to stir up hatred. Are historical documents and older writings ever included here? Has the assignment of a hateful text for the purposes of study ever been the target of the Public Order of 1986 or university policies based on it? Readers, help us out.
Heres the actual text of the motion (courtesy of Eric Sheng):
As you can see, the studentsnamed one example of a text they think would fall under their expanded hate speech proposal: Procreative Beneficence: Why We Should Select the Best Children by Julian Savulescu, which appeared inBioethicsin 2001. In this article, Savulescu argues that prospective parents should select the child, of the possible children they could have, who is expected to have the best life, or at least as good a life as the others, based on the relevant, available information, which they took to be objectionably ableist.
I dont think the students did themselves any favors with this choice of example, in which Savulescu distinguishes betweenidentifying conditions, such as poor memory, that tend to make peoples lives worse(a claim he endorses) and saying that people with those conditions are less deserving of respect or are less valuable (a claim he rejects). Regardless of whether one thinks Savulescus argument is any good, this article is certainly neither intended to, nor likely to stir up, hatred against disabled persons.The students are just mistakenthat it is an example of hate speech.
Suppose, though, that they werent mistaken. Even if it were hate speech, note thatthe students are not calling for Oxford to ban Savulescus essay. Rather, they are arguing that students be given the option to take a course in which it is assigned, and that students be warned about its content. One way to put this is that theyre arguing for informed consent for encountering hate speech.
Unfortunately, they are also asking for administrators* [students actually; see the correction to #4, above] to condemn the assigning of the reading. Though I tend to favor more speech approaches to allegedly objectionable speech, withoutmeasures toseparatethe authoritys expressive actions from its coercive ones (a la Brettschneider), this is an overreach. [Note: in light of the correction of #4, above, which makes clear that it is students, not administrators, being asked to condemn the readings, I retract this criticism.]
So what to think about all of this? Here are three takeaways (feel free to add your own):
(a) The students care about the welfare of the vulnerable among them and are pointing out what they take to be a problem of arbitrariness in law and policy (that thereare protections on the basis of, say, race and religion but not gender and class).
(b) The students are arguing for a more-freedom, more-information, and more-speech approach to solving this problem, rather than censorship.
(c) The students seem to have an overly inclusive conception of what counts as hate speech.
I think (a) is good, (b) is a mixed bag owing to the vague call forofficial condemnations and [see the correction to #4, above] the confused language of criminalization, and (c) is not terrible but not good, either.
The problem with (c) is not really the legal point, but rather an apparent tendency towards a kind of affirming the consequent. Heres an example. We might expect an atheist to criticize the ontological argument for the existence of God, but someone who criticizes the ontological argument for the existence of God is not necessarily an atheist.That is, it doesnt follow from ones making an argument an atheist would make that one is an atheistit depends on the argument (among other things). Similarly, it doesnt follow from ones making an argument a racist or sexist or classist would make that one is a racist or sexist or classistit depends on the argument (among other things). For example, we might expect a racist to argue against affirmative action, but it doesnt follow that one is a racist in virtue of arguing against affirmative action.
It isnt surprising that students are susceptible to thismistaken reasoning. For one thing, theyre still learning how to think carefully. For another, its not always a mistake to reason this way, and in some contexts (or for people with certain backgrounds) it could be a reasonable heuristic to employ.
Ironically, thiskind of reasoning might have been in play in the widely shared descriptions and attitudes expressed about this story, which framed the students as censors. We might think that someone who favors censorship might express the same kinds of concerns the Oxford Student Union did in their motion. But it would be a mistake to conclude, as many seemed to do, that because they expressed such concerns, the studentswere calling for censorship. They werent.
I suppose an additional takeaway would be that, as with some other disputes over speech, the combatants may have more in common than they realize.
Read the rest here:
Free Speech at Oxford (updated with an important correction) - Daily Nous
- University round table examines challenges to free speech [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- University of Worcester fares well in free speech study [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- A line beyond which one may not go [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Councillor accused of stifling free speech after making complaint against counterparts social media use [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- The French Debate: Free Speech Versus Hate Speech [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Church of England removing vicars right to free speech? - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- FREE SPEECH ZONE s08e06 (2-7-15) - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Charlie Hebdo/The Interview: Free Speech: Free to Murder? - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Free Speech & Liberty Pizza House opening comment 2015 - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- 2015=02-01 Limits of Free Speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Health Free Speech Petition and Litigation - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Putin Popularity Rating: Russian President's 80% approval rating may stem from free speech violation - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Steven Pinker's "Why free speech is fundamental" - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- "Islam & Free Speech" - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Free Speech and the Battle for Western Culture - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- (UPDATED) CAIR Officials Nationwide Condemn Charlie Hebdo Attack, Defend Free Speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- The Koch Brothers and $889 million free speech dollars - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Mark Zuckerberg Reverses Decision On Free Speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Rick Perry: Court ruling imposes chilling effect on free speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- TAVIS SMILEY | FREE SPEECH IN AMERICA | January 26-27, 2015 - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Lord Jamar: USA's Only About Free Speech When It's Convenient - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Free Speech vs Politically Correct (Liberal Hypocrisy) - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Sharif Nashashibi, Suzanne Nossel, Munir Pervaiz Saami discusses free speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- FREE SPEECH ZONE s08e04 (1-24-15) - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Do I Think #6: Voting, Free Speech & #GamerGate - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Chris Hedges: Roots of Terrorism, Free Speech Hypocrisy & Translating #JeSuisCharlie - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Q&A Banning Haters: What About Free Speech? - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Putin's grip on free speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Why Saudi Arabia Is Flogging A Free Speech Activist - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Islamists Deny Media Access at At Muslim Free Speech Conference - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Metallica- Free Speech For The Dumb - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- 1st Peoples, Palestine, and the Crushing of Free Speech - Steven Salaita - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Free Speech Hypocrisy In France - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Pope clarifies position on free speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Muslim response to Charlie Hebdo Attack - Free speech or insult? - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Charlie Hebdo, double standards and free speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Gays, Islam, Free Speech - Tony Perkins, Bill Maher & MORE! LiberalViewer Sunday Clip Round-Up 91 - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Free Speech: Mercury is Speech, Venus is Values - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- The Pope Supports "Free Speech" (sort of) - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Ring of Fire on Free Speech TV - 01/18/2015 (FULL EPISODE) - Video [Last Updated On: February 12th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 12th, 2015]
- Mad about free speech and North Korea? Hack back, says group [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- Ring of Fire on Free Speech TV - 02/08/2015 (FULL EPISODE) - Video [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- Ring of Fire on Free Speech TV - 02/01/2015 (FULL EPISODE) - Video [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- MP George Galloway on Free Speech Charlatans & Austin Powers Foreign Policy in Syria - Video [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- Limited Free Speech Isn't Free Speech - Video [Last Updated On: February 14th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 14th, 2015]
- Volokh Conspiracy: Murder at Copenhagen debate on free speech attended by Swedish Muhammad cartoonist [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- One dead after shooting at free speech event in Denmark featuring controversial artist [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Gunman kills 1 in attack on free speech event in Denmark [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Deadly shooting at Copenhagen free speech event [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Are Students Free to Speak Their Mind? Well at Southampton, yes. [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Shooting targets free speech event in Denmark, killing one [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Police: 1 dead in shooting at Copenhagen free speech event [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- The Heat debates free speech and assembly in France - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Detroit's Campus Martius: Banning Free Speech in Public Space - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Dr William Lane Craig: The Moral Argument (Proof of God) - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Did Pope Francis Preach Violence? - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Danish police kill gunman believed behind 2 shootings [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Danish shooter had gangland past [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Free speech in Britain: Police tracking people who bought ... [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Copenhagen shooting: Free speech seminar attacked - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Professor Advocates Violence Against White Racist - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Muslim Coward Attempts to Murder Swedish Artist - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Srsly Wrong - 41 - Free Speech Zone, Act 1 - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Free Speech and Charming Ignorance - Video [Last Updated On: February 15th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 15th, 2015]
- Police say Copenhagen gunman had criminal record, gang past [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Police say Copenhagen gunman had criminal record and gang past [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- U.S. Funds The Terrorist To Take Our Freedoms - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- First Copenhagen shooting victim identified as film maker - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Danes react to two fatal shootings - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Danish police doing forensic investigation after islamic terrorist was shot dead, 15/2-2015 - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Denmark: See BULLET-RIDDLED scene of first Copenhagen shooting - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Animatrix - Humans vs Machines HD - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- RickWells.us - General Jerry Boykin on UN Attempt To Prohibit Free Speech Regarding Islam - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Copenhagen Krudttnden Cafe Street View - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Muhammad Cartoonist Targeted! TSA Active Shooter VIDEO, The "Digital Dark Age" and more #TMS - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Copenhagen free speech debate shooting: One dead - Video [Last Updated On: February 16th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 16th, 2015]
- Germany: Copenhagen attacks, Ukraine ceasefire on Merkel's agenda - Video [Last Updated On: February 17th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 17th, 2015]
- Copenhagen Denmark Shooting - Lars Vilks - Calling Cards Of Hoax Fake Crap - Video [Last Updated On: February 17th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 17th, 2015]
- Danish prime minister visits - Video [Last Updated On: February 17th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 17th, 2015]
- Second Person Dead In Separate Suspected Terror Shootings In Copenhagen - Video [Last Updated On: February 17th, 2015] [Originally Added On: February 17th, 2015]